Essay about Sociology and Weber

Submitted By sir22su
Words: 2403
Pages: 10
Open Document
Compare and Contrast Two of the Classical Sociological Theorists’ Approaches to One of the Dualisms that Craib Identified as Central to the Discipline of Sociology: Individual/Society; Action/Structure; Social Integration/System Integration; Modernity/Capitalism.
Sophia Robson

There are four fundamental dualisms, (as listed above) described by Craib, and every social theory developed must explain both sides of the dualism. (Craib, 1997: 7). In this essay, a comparison is made of Durkeim’s and Weber’s approaches to Craib’s first essential dualism, between the individual and society. The crucial idea being whether the theorist holds the individual or society, to be their starting point of analysis, and/or to be more significant, in their theory.
Durkheim (1858-1917) a French classical sociological theorist was one of the main founders of Sociology. Writing after the French Revolution, during a time of mass industrialisation, and social transformation, there was a need for social order, as traditional society was rapidly modernising. Durkheim (1964 [1895]) argued the case for a new sociological method in studying society based around ‘social facts’ (Durkheim, 1964 [1895]:1 ), which are the actions, thoughts or feelings that we have which conform to society’s norms, but are also:
…existing outside the individual consciousness. These types of conduct or thought are not only external to the individual but are, moreover, endowed with coercive power, by virtue of which they impose themselves upon him, independent of his individual will. (Durkheim, 1964 [1895]: 2)
Durkheim (1964 [1895]) maintained that the existence of social facts, social structures, external and internal social forces, proved that society existed as a distinct reality apart from the individuals within it, furthermore, as society has multiple layers, it must be scientifically studied. Therefore, Durkheim’s starting point for analysis was society, holding society as more important than the individual throughout. Individuals are therefore shaped, controlled and regulated by their society. Moreover, the social groups which individuals may belong to, can have different actions, thoughts and feelings; to those of their individual components.
Durkheim (1964 [1895]) suggests society is an entity itself, being greater than the sum of its parts, (as society existed before some of its current individuals were born). Durkheim’s (1964 [1895]) new sociological method was a positivist/scientific, approach towards social phenomena, implying research should be done empirically, enabling observations of parallels between social facts, in the hope of uncovering the functions of the phenomena. Durkheim (1951 [1897]) uses this approach in a study of suicide, which was chosen as is generally thought of as extremely personal. Durkheim (1951 [1897]) looked at data such as suicide rates, within different groups, endeavouring to uncover the social fact that came before the suicide. Durkheim believed this led to the suicide rather than an issue in the individual’s consciousness. Concluding further ‘Anomic suicide’ (Durkheim, 1951 [1897]:241) was the leading type of suicide in his time, the cause being that: as individual freedom increases, the regulative power of a united group decreases, so suicide rates increase as individuals become more isolated from the once unified group. The two other forms of suicide: ‘Egoistic suicide’ (Durkheim, 1951 [1897]:171) - where an individual fails in a successful society, and ‘Altruistic suicide’ (Durkheim ,1951 [1897]:217) - where an individual sacrifices himself for the greater need of the group. In the latter two cases, when there is stronger solidarity, (traditional societies), suicide rates increase. Therefore, moral regulation and group integration are key determinants for suicide.
However, despite this, individualism was still central to Durkheim’s analysis, especially as traditional society faded, and society moved towards modernity.
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Sociology and Weber

Sociology: Max Weber and Film Essay

actions would improve the government and the wealth of a country. System and organizations like this type try to find a way to keep power and control to gain economic advantages. This can be easily explained in max Weber theory of class, status and party but mostly in parties what Weber define as “ groups organized to obtain power” (108) in the movie we see how trade unions and organizations like IMF mandatory polices drove millions of argentines into poverty, multinational corporations were making…

Words 1039 - Pages 5

Sociology: Max Weber and Formal Organizations Essay

there available storage for the information gathered. This caused organizations to be very unproductive. Also, the worldview from the varying time frames is also different. According to Macionis (2006), “Tradition, according to German sociologist Max Weber, consists of values and beliefs passed from generation to generation.” (p. 119). In the prior years, organizations were conservative and this caused low efficiency and not a lot of room for change. In the past century, it seemed that work ethics were…

Words 1224 - Pages 5

Auguste Commpte's Theory

Auguste Compte, who lived in France when chaos erupted after Napoleon lost the Battle to conquer Europe tried to look for ways to improve the society and believed that sociology could greatly contribute towards that. Compte coined the word Sociology and called it the queen of sciences. Compte believed that all societies passed through three stages of developed which are: Theological, metaphysical and positive stages. In the theological stage, Compte believed that life was guided by religious ideas…

Words 765 - Pages 4

Essay about Sociologists

Sociology is considered a science because it uses the scientific method. Using various methods of empirical investigation and critical analysis, sociology is considered a social science. Sociology looks at a wide range of behavior than economist or political scientist. Political science studies the organization and functioning of system government. Sociology also studies political life but less as an isolated phenomenon and more in terms of general sociological principles. The focus of the economist…

Words 1340 - Pages 6

Study Guide Essay examples

Principles of Sociology Chapter 1 Study Guide *Directions: To get the best use of this study guide, study for personal understanding instead of simple memorization. Your tests will have scenarios on them and simple recall questions. In scenarios, one must apply what is known; therefore, if you just memorize and do not understand what you have memorized, you will not succeed. *The questions below are not the questions that are on the test; however, the topics they include will be on the test:…

Words 586 - Pages 3

Max Weber Essay

Max Weber, a German economist and sociologist is considered to be one of the most significant classical theorists because his methods that are still being implemented into modern sociological research. Weber is best known for his essay, The Protestant Ethic and Spirit of Capitalism, as well as being highly regarded for his ideas on bureaucracy, his study on class, status and party, and for his theory of social action., Almost all of Weber's writing's have had some kind, if not, a major impact on…

Words 1771 - Pages 8

Mr. Ng Essay

Penguin Business ------------------------------------------------- Pages: 5-8 Max Weber Max Weber (1864-1920) was born in Germany. He qualified in law and then became a member of the staff of Berlin University. He remained an academic for the rest of his life, having a primary interest in the broad sweep of the historical development of civilisations through studies of the sociology of religion and the sociology of economic life. In his approach to both of these topics he showed a tremendous…

Words 1754 - Pages 8

Is Classical Sociology Still Relevant Today? Essay example

Choose any one concept or argument developed within classical sociology. Critically evaluate the use made of this concept or argument by contemporary sociology in trying to understand a current social issue This essay looks at the argument taken from a classical sociologist called Weber, throughout this essay it explains rationalization and how it has become modernized using Ritzer to explain this by demonstrating his McDonaldization theory. The theory will be clarified by contemporary sociologists…

Words 1239 - Pages 5

Philosophy 1000 Essay

CONFLICT AND ANALYSIS: THE LEGACY OF MAX WEBER KEY POINTS Key Contributions of M. Weber: 1) Theory of Society: Similarities and Differences with E. Durkheim and K. Marx: action vs. structure; individual vs. collectivity; 2) 3-fold Methodology: comparative method, verstehen, ideal types M. Weber: Theory of Society Max Weber (1864-1920): Overview of Weber’s legacy: similarities and differences to Durkheim and Marx; Topics of interest: history of religion; bureaucracy; social stratification;…

Words 520 - Pages 3

Who Am I ? Essay

been taught a lot of theories in the past year, the names of Marx, Durkheim, Weber, Simmel, and Du Bois will always stick with me because their ideas of how the world works is most fascinating. First of all, what is Sociology? Well, it’s basically the study of the origin, structure, and development of human society. In other words, it’s the study of people and how they react to social forces in their environment. Sociology is one of many disciplines of social science – that including: history, economic…

Words 6572 - Pages 27