Sympathy Gratification Argument

Words: 961

Pages: 4

Open Document

One popular argument in favour of psychological egoism, the view that all intentional human actions are motivated by self-interest, is what I will call the sympathy gratification argument. It states that those actions seemingly motivated by altruism (e.g. helping the poor and the sick or working for a political cause to benefit all) are in fact motivated by a person’s own sympathy-based desires. After all, we are all social animals with varying degrees of sympathy. Our being social animals means each of us can identify with other similar beings to a greater or lesser extent and so we may feel their interests as being our own interests; this is called sympathy. So when we act “in the interests of others”, we are really only acting in those interests that we have made our own by identifying with the like being. Therefore, these seemingly altruistic acts are really not altruistic, but self-interested. …show more content…
This is made clear by the example that although I can expect not to get the Nobel Prize for this essay, my aim is not to avoid getting the Nobel Prize (though if you’d like to put my name forward, I wouldn’t fight you). The sympathy gratification argument relies on this premise since it presumes that because we do gratify our sympathetic desires every time we act “altruistically” our aim is really to gratify our sympathetic desires--if it did not presume this it would explicitly not rule out altruism. Yet, what proof is there that this was everyone’s aim (i.e. their actual motivation)? At some point, the psychological egoist, having no access to the person’s inner-world, will have to rely on expected outcomes of actions as proof which would be inadequate. The sympathy gratification argument therefore fails to make the motivation (i.e. the interest) identical with advantage and so altruistic action remains

The Munchausen Syndrome By Proxy

individuals appear to achieve some form of gratification from their actions in the deceptive relationship they create with the patient (Day and Moseley 14). MBP is a form of child abuse, as the caregiver subjects the children to pain and dangers that may be detrimental to their health and in some instances even cause death. The motive of the caregivers is to acquire some psychological or emotional gratification from their actions. Receiving the sympathy and support provided by family, friends, and…

Words 1552 - Pages 7

Essay on Response to Hunter S. Thompsons Ferar and Loathing in Las Vegas

Hunter S. Thompson’s Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas is a travelogue of sorts, due to the blurred lines between fiction and non-fiction, which deeply explores the status of the American Dream during the early 70’s, specifically 1971. Thompson states this purpose within the first three chapters of the book in the line, “Because I want you to know that we’re on our way to Las Vegas to find the American Dream.” (F&L pg 6) Although Thompson states in the beginning of the book that, “Our trip was different…

Words 1171 - Pages 5

The Monster In Mary Shelly's Frankenstein

Let me see that I excite the sympathy of some existing thing; do not deny me my request.”(130) The feeling of loneliness that the creature is feeling is leading him to plea such a request. Although, it means that there would be two creatures invented by the creator. After great convincing…

Words 1505 - Pages 7

Essay on Adam Smith and British Slavery

They consume little more than the poor, and in spite of their natural selfishness and rapacity, though they mean only their own conveniency, though the sole end which they propose from the labours of all the thousands whom they employ, be the gratification of their own vain and insatiable desires, they divide with the poor the produce of all their improvements. They are led by an invisible hand to make nearly the same distribution of the necessaries of life, which would have been made, had the earth…

Words 5308 - Pages 22

The Meaning Of Life

Psychological significance and value in life What is meaningful and valuable in life?[12] What is the value of life?[13] What is the reason to live? What are we living for?[6][14] These questions have resulted in a wide range of competing answers and arguments, from scientific theories, to philosophical, theological, and spiritual explanations. Western philosophical perspectives The philosophical perspectives on the meaning of life are those ideologies which explain life in terms of ideals or abstractions…

Words 3304 - Pages 14

Utilitarianism and Happiness Essay

Utilitarianism Sandra LaFave West Valley College The notion of an ethics based on utility — usefulness for human concerns, especially human happiness — was one of the revolutionary Continental ideas of the Enlightenment period. Cesare Beccaria (1738-1794), for example, in his extremely influential work On Crimes and Punishments, argues that punishments should be inflicted only insofar as they are useful for human purposes; and that governments should not think themselves free to punish inhumanely…

Words 3600 - Pages 15

The Role of Educational Psychology in Teaching Essay

The Role of Educational Psychology in Teaching Aundrea Riley PSY 6631: Psychological Foundations of Education March 9, 2012 Dabney Hunter McKenzie, Ph.D. Introduction There are many who have wondered about the place of educational psychology in teaching and learning. However, a closer look at the nature and scope of learning and teaching and the essence of educational psychology clearly shows a relationship that can be best described as mutually…

Words 2667 - Pages 11

School: Human and Wolfe Essay

Perspectives on Political Science, 40:123–131, 2011 Copyright C Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1045-7097 print / 1930-5478 online DOI: 10.1080/10457097.2011.585930 Science and the Fate of the Human Soul in Tom Wolfe CAROL MCNAMARA Abstract: This article investigates Tom Wolfe’s assessment of the age-old debate between nature and nurture, the Cartesian mind–body problem, and the tensions between science, politics, and morality that result from the human struggle to explain what the components…

Words 9513 - Pages 39

Wuthering Heights Study Questions

Wuthering Heights Study Questions Chapter 1 1. The setting is austere and mysterious. It does not suit Mr. Lockwood quite well; he finds Wuthering Heights extremely disagreeable and its inhabitants bitter and unsociable. 2. “Wuthering” is descriptive of the atmospheric tumult of the novel in that it describes the violent winds that blow during storms on the moors. Wuthering Heights is removed from society. The adjective not only describes the setting itself, but the inhabitants as…

Words 3909 - Pages 16

Love: Communication and Transmission View Essay

CHAPTER 1 A Cultural Approach to Communication James Carey (from Communication as Culture) When I decided some years ago to read seriously the literature of communications, a wise man suggested I begin with John Dewey. It was advice I have never regretted accepting. Although there are limitations to Dewey–his literary style was described by William James as damnable–there is a depth to his work, a natural excess common to seminal minds, that offers permanent complexities, and paradoxes over which…

Words 8149 - Pages 33