Essay System: Engineer a. Engineer

Submitted By beyondbelief12
Words: 1488
Pages: 6
Open Document
taNSPE Board of Ethical Review 2/21/01 - Approved Case No. 00-10 Pg. 1

CONTINGENCY FEES – ENGINEER/ATTORNEY HIRING ENGINEERING EXPERT

Case No. 00-10 Facts: Engineer A is both an attorney and an engineer. Engineer A is retained by Client X on a contingency basis to perform legal services in connection with an accident in which Client X alleges that a manufactured product caused the accident. Engineer A interviews a number of experts familiar with the product and the reasons for similar accidents and hires Engineer B, an expert in the product in question. No written agreement is executed between Engineer A and Engineer B for the services in question. Engineer B reviews the facts and circumstances surrounding the accident, conducts and completes study, and issues a report to Engineer A. Engineer A reviews Engineer B’s report and informs Client X that it appears that no basis exists for a lawsuit. Engineer B bills Engineer A for his professional services. Engineer A refuses to pay, indicating that since Engineer A was not paid for his services, Engineer A has no obligation to pay Engineer B. Question: Was it ethical for Engineer A to refuse to pay Engineer B for Engineer B’s services? References:
Preamble Code of Ethics: Engineering is an important and learned profession. As members of this profession, engineers are expected to exhibit the highest standards of honesty and integrity. Engineering has a direct and vital impact on the quality of life for all people. Accordingly, the services provided by engineers require honesty, impartiality, fairness and equity, and must be dedicated to the protection of the public health, safety and welfare. Engineers must perform under a standard of professional behavior which requires adherence to the highest principles of ethical conduct. Avoid deceptive acts. Conduct themselves honorably, responsibly, ethically and lawfully so as to enhance the honor, reputation and usefulness of the profession. Engineers shall not request, propose, or accept a commission on a contingent basis under circumstances in which their judgment may be compromised.

Section I.5. Section I.6.

-

Code of Ethics: Code of Ethics:

Section III.6.a.

-

Code of Ethics:

Discussion: The facts in this case illustrate a frequently encountered situation often presented within the design and construction industry – payment disputes that occur between clients that ripple into disputes between design and construction industry parties. The Board of Ethical Review has considered ethics cases in the past involving an engineer being retained on a speculative basis. In BER Case No. 77-4, a county agency published an open announcement to consulting engineering firms soliciting
Copyright © 2000 National Society of Professional Engineer (NSPE) www.nspe.org . All rights reserved. To request permission to reproduce this NSPE Board of Ethical Review Case, please contact the NSPE Legal Department (legal@nspe.org)

NSPE Board of Ethical Review 2/21/01 - Approved Case No. 00-10 Pg. 2

expressions of interest in providing services for a water system project. The announcement made it clear that the engagement would be for the purpose of preparing an engineering report to be submitted to a federal agency to seek financial assistance for the proposed project. It was also made clear that the agency did not have any present funds to pay the consultant, that the agency was not committed to carrying through the project to construction, that if the report shows that the project is not feasible either from an engineering or financial standpoint, "…or that there is discerned a majority sentiment against the project for whatever reason, prior to federal funding commitment, then the project preparation will be terminated." The announcement further stated, "The consulting engineer would be retained solely on the basis of speculation that the project may proceed through the construction phase. If the project is stopped at any time
Show More

Related Documents: Essay System: Engineer a. Engineer

Engineer: Global Positioning System and Gps Receiver Essay

GPS systems Introduction: Our ancestors had to go to pretty extreme measures to keep from getting lost. They erected monumental landmarks, laboriously drafted detailed maps and learned to read the stars in the night sky. Things are much, much easier today. For less than $100, you can get a pocket-sized gadget that will tell you exactly where you are on Earth at any moment. As long as you have a GPS receiver and a clear view of the sky, you'll never be lost again. The Global Positioning System…

Words 1571 - Pages 7

Software Engineering Essay

Computer Software Engineer Software engineers generally need to analyze the users' needs. Once this is done, they design, construct, test, and maintain the needed soft ware or systems. During the programming, or coding, they tell a computer, line by line, how it is to function. They also fix any problems that they run into. They must have strong coding skills, but these engineers are more likely to develop algorithms and solve problems than they are to write code. Software engineers work as part of…

Words 706 - Pages 3

Engineering Profile Essay

and social knowledge, we develop a disciplined art form of an occupation. All of this applied knowledge is needed in order to build devices and mechanical systems to improve the daily lives of people. A career in the department of engineering consists of practicing the scientific principles in order to meet social and consumer needs. Engineers develop efficient solutions to technical problems. There are different branches that stem out and create detailed tasks for each component of engineering.…

Words 1213 - Pages 5

Research Paper On Mechanical Engineering

description: Mechanical engineers researches, develops, design and build and test mechanical devices including engines and machinery. They also read and interpret blueprints, technical drawings, schematics, or computer-generated reports. Assist drafters in developing the structural design of products using drafting tools or computer-assisted design (CAD) or drafting equipment and software. Research, design, evaluate, install, operate, and maintain mechanical products, equipment, systems and processes to…

Words 352 - Pages 2

Essay On Computer Engineering

Occupational Research Nature of Work: Computer engineers are the minds behind today’s computer hardware, software, and information technology systems. Computer engineers use their background in computer science, electrical engineering, and mathematical analysis to design, develop, test, and evaluate various forms of computer technology. They must plan and produce computing devices that function both efficiently and economically. Computer engineers design and test hardware such as computer chips…

Words 615 - Pages 3

Aerospace Engineering Essay

Aerospace Engineer Aerospace Engineers have a variety of jobs. They may work from the casual airplane to sending objects out into space. Aerospace engineers who deal with aircrafts are normally title aeronautical engineers, those working with spacecrafts are named astronautical engineers. Such engineers develop technologies that assist in aviation, defense systems, and space exploration. Aeronautical engineers may specialize in a particular type of aerospace product. Aerospace engineers may be experts…

Words 710 - Pages 3

Nt1310 Unit 3 Careers Research Paper

Careers in Networking Many careers require basic network competencies. Networking professionals with titles such as Network Engineer or Systems Administrator must be comfortable designing or maintaining networks of all sizes. There is also no end to positions where basic networking knowledge is an asset. According to educators at Brigham Young University – Idaho, understanding key routing and switching principles is essential to a solid foundation in any IT career. This networking course is a requirement…

Words 1006 - Pages 5

Essay about Strategic Restructuring

Currently, there are six operational supervisors – one for each part of the manufacturing process – along with three engineers – a chemical engineer, a manufacturing engineer, and a mechanical engineer. The roles are currently separated so the supervisors are responsible for not only the people, but the entire part of the process they are over, including the technical document writing. Engineers perform data analysis and are essentially on call for problems outside of the realm of the maintenance department…

Words 1709 - Pages 7

Electrical Engineering Research Paper

Electrical & Electronics Engineers Project Outline Introduction A. The Basis of my future career. History & Nature of Work (Duties) A. Electrical & Electronics beginning and effects on daily life. B. What does Electrical & Electronics Engineers do? Preparation and Training A. Basic courses for both electrical and electronics. 1. College Programs-Computer architecture, switching theory, and computer design. 2. Electrical Programs- Mathematics and science more than technology and…

Words 1978 - Pages 8

Essay Learning Reflection

WHAT COMPUTER ENGINEERS DO Computer Engineering (CpE) – a combination of electrical engineering and computer science - deals with the study of computing ranging from microprocessors to supercomputers. Computer engineers are electrical engineers who specialize in either software design, hardware design or both. Specialization areas include: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Microprocessor and Microcontroller Systems, Assembly Language Programming, Coding, Cryptography and Information Protection, Distributed…

Words 658 - Pages 3