Essay on The Bully Problem

Submitted By fanzengfanzeng
Words: 1776
Pages: 8
Open Document
The Bully Problem

Eric is a pupil at The Beeches School. David is the headmaster of the school. For a number of weeks Eric has been subject to severe bullying from Bob, a fellow pupil. David, the headmaster, is aware that the bullying is taking place but takes no steps to remonstrate with, or punish, Bob. Bob continues to bully Eric. Eventually, Eric can take no more and swallows some bleach in an attempt to kill himself. Zelda discovers Eric foaming at the mouth and goes into shock. Sam rings for an ambulance. The ambulance takes one hour to arrive when the normal response time would be twenty minutes. By the time the ambulance arrives Eric is dead. It is determined that had the ambulance arrived twenty minutes after Sam’s call, Eric would probably have died anyway but there was a 20% chance that with proper treatment he would have pulled through. Zelda now suffers from severe depression. Discuss.

Model answer

Taking each possible claimant in turn –

Eric’s estate

Claim against Bob for harassment/battery

Bob committed a tort in relation to Eric in bullying him – either the tort of harassment (Protection from Harassment Act 1997) or battery (assuming the bullying consisted in hitting Eric). Eric’s estate will be entitled to sue Bob for damages in respect of the injuries and consequential pain and suffering experienced by Eric as a result of Bob’s bullying before he died.

Claim against David in negligence

David owed Eric a duty to take reasonable steps to see that he would be physically safe at school. So – when he was alerted to the bullying that Eric was being subjected to while at school, David owed Eric a duty to take reasonable steps to stop the bullying happening. David probably breached this duty in failing to do anything to stop the bullying; it is unlikely that, applying the Bolam test, that there is a body of opinion among headteachers that the best way of dealing with bullying is to ignore it. If David did breach the duty of care that he owed Eric in failing to do anything about the bullying Eric was being subjected to, it still has to be established that had David not breached this duty of care, Bob would have stopped bullying Eric. If he would have, then Eric’s estate will be entitled to sue David for compensation for the injuries and pain and suffering that Eric experienced at Bob’s hands after David became aware of the problem. If Bob would have continued bullying Eric whatever David did then Eric’s estate will not be entitled to sue David for damages – while David was negligent in relation to Eric, his negligence did not cause Eric to suffer any loss before he died.

Eric’s parents

Eric’s parents will want to bring an action for bereavement under the Fatal Accidents Act against Bob, David and the ambulance service.

Claim against Bob

Eric’s parents will probably be able to succeed in bringing an action for bereavement against Bob. To succeed, they would have to show that: (1) Bob committed a tort in relation to Eric in bullying him; (2) Bob’s tort caused Eric to died; and (3) had Eric lived, he would have been entitled to sue Bob for compensatory damages. We have already seen that (1) is made out. It could be argued that (2) is not made out; it could be argued that Eric’s suicide was a voluntary and unreasonable act which had the effect of breaking the chain of causation between Bob’s bullying and Eric’s death. However, it is doubtful whether such an argument would succeed – Eric hardly acted voluntarily in killing himself. Finally, there is no doubt that (3) is made out.

Claim against David

Eric’s parents will also be entitled to bring an action for bereavement against David – so long as it can be shown that David was negligent in failing to deal with Bob’s bullying of Eric and that Bob would no longer have bullied Eric (and therefore Eric would not have killed himself) had David not been negligent.

Claim against the ambulance service

An action for bereavement
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on The Bully Problem

Are Bullies The Real Problem?

Are Bullies the Real Problem? School’s claims they don’t tolerate bullying, yet do nothing when a situation arises. Bullying, it’s always been a big problem in schools and on social media around the world. But are schools really doing all they can to prevent this victimization and help when there is a situation? Many people have complained about ruthless teasing in schools across the southern suburbs of Perth, but only two mothers we know of have taken the issue into their own hands. “It’s just…

Words 786 - Pages 4

The Problem Of School Bullies: What The Research Tells Us

Appendices and References Michael Whitmore Columbia Southern University Research Methods MBA 5652 Professor Spangenburg Appendices References Beaty, L. & Alexeyev, E. (2008). The Problem of School Bullies: What the Research tells Us. Adolescence; Spring 2008;43, 169 Bullying Statistics. (2010). Retrieved from http://www.bullyingstatistics.org/content/bullying-statistics-2010.html Cassel, V., Bell, A. & Springer, J. (2011). Analysis of State Bullying Laws and Policies…

Words 413 - Pages 2

Potential Bullying Essay

Bullying is a huge problem in teen’s lives which is affecting their time in school, in my opinion kids are taking bullying too far and schools need to do more about it, students are bullying other students which is effecting them too much as where the commit suicide, school anti­bullying programs are bringing the problem into the open, the law needs to be toughened to add criminal penalties, they need to have counseling and help for them to try to stop. Parents are oblivious to what’s happening to their children in school…

Words 1593 - Pages 7

Bullying: High School and Small Midwestern Towns Essay examples

Bullying in schools has become a national dilemma. It affects students and makes many students not feel safe in school. Bullying has both short term and long term effects on the victim as well as the bully. Most of these problems will start in middle school and continue to growth throughout the high school year. Many school have restricted rules against bullying; however, many of these schools do not follow their own rules. Students are bullied in all short of places such as hallways, locker room…

Words 511 - Pages 3

Essay on bullies are vitumes too

December 11, 2013 Bullies are Victims Too Bullies cry for help is being hidden behind the aggregation they have toward other children. The consequences and effects of bullying for bullies are very hard to deal with they include suffering mentally in the future, commit suicide, and suffering from depression. Children begin to bully because of abuse at home, feelings, and inferiority. Bullying is a series of repeated intentionally mean actions that include the same children in the same bully and victim…

Words 972 - Pages 4

Verbal Bullying Essay

Bully... What does the word make you think of? For some people, it's that girl at school who always makes fun of them. For others, it's the biggest guy in the neighborhood who's always trying to beat them up or take their things. Sometimes "bully" means a whole group of kids, ganging up on someone else. No matter what situation or form it comes in, bullying can make you feel depressed, hurt, and alone. It can keep you from enjoying the activities and places that are part of your life. Bullying happens…

Words 1369 - Pages 6

Essay Nice: Bullying and Psychological Bullying

Every day thousands of teens wake up afraid to go to school. Bullying is a problem that affects millions of students of all races and classes. Bullying has everyone worried, not just the kids on its receiving end. Yet because parents, teachers, and other adults don't always see it, they may not understand how extreme bullying can get. Bullying is when a person is picked on over and over again by an individual or group with more power, either in terms of physical strength or social standing. Two…

Words 1006 - Pages 5

Tom Brown Bullying

initiated other professionals to conduct research, and vastly expanded the meaning of bullying” (Koo, 2007). From then on, more and more people began conducting research on bullying, expanding into the physiological effects that bullying has on the bully, the victim, and the…

Words 1383 - Pages 6

Tuesday Of The Other June Character Analysis

issue of bullying and to help the reader understand what it is like in real life. People often bully others because the bully wants to feel like the bully is weak. Most bullying occurs when the bully wants to feel better about themselves so they do it through bullying. But sometimes, the bully just wants to be mean and wants the victim to feel bad. Some bullies are jealous of their victim so they bully their victim so they won’t feel so jealous about them. Bullying is when a person repeatedly hurts…

Words 1129 - Pages 5

Cyberbullying: Bullying and Dangerous Metal Health Essay

(When Cyberbullying Turns 6). As reported by “Cyberbullying Statistics”, nearly half of teens become a victim to cyber bullying, but only 1 in 10 of the victims tell a parent/guardian (12). Cyber bullying has been a growing problem in recent years but remains to be a problem parents know nearly nothing about. It is an increasing contributor to teen suicide and dangerous metal health factors towards teens (Cyberbullying Effects 1). In addition to Rebecca’s devastating story, cyber bullying is a…

Words 882 - Pages 4