The Devil's Arithmetic: Comparing The Book And Movie

Words: 606
Pages: 3
Open Document
“The Devil’s Arithmetic” is about remembering. Everything that happened in the past, we have to remember so they don’t happen again. Even though they are telling the same story, they have some very big differences. In the book “The Devil’s Arithmetic”, it has so much detail and the plot is really clear. In the movie, I feel that the relationships were very confusing after reading the book and many of the major events were different. This book and movie are about a girl named Hannah. Her family is Jewish and they are practice all Jewish holidays with her Aunt Eva, who named Hannah after her friend who died in a camp in the Holocaust. Hannah doesn’t even want to go to the Seder because she doesn’t care about remembering. She thinks because it’s in the past, it’s already happened, it doesn’t matter anymore. She’s old enough to drink the wine at dinner, and she takes advantage and …show more content…
They both focus on remembering. They show that we have to remember the past so it doesn’t repeat itself. The whole purpose of Hannah going back to live in the concentration camp was that so she would realize how big of a deal it was and why she has to remember. Before, she was snotty and didn’t care about the past because it didn’t affect her. It already happened! But she got sent back, and when she came back she was humbled and she appreciated how much Aunt Eva went through. Another thing that was the same was the suffering. In both the movie and the book, so many people suffered. The people who were shot, hung, and gassed, they all suffered. They had hardly anything to eat and they had to work with no breaks and if they did, they might have gotten shot. Everyone in the camps suffered. Lastly, one of the major similarities, Hannah took Rivka’s place both times. Hannah knew that Rivka had to live because she was going to be an aunt someday to the actual Hannah. She didn’t care that she was dying, she cared about Rivka
Show More

Related Documents: The Devil's Arithmetic: Comparing The Book And Movie

Devil's Arithmetic Movie And Book Comparison Essay

in her book The Devil’s Arithmetic published in the year of 1988 that keeps readers on their seats and turning every page. This, in turn, has touched so many lives that the movie The Devil’s Arithmetic, directed by Donna Deitch--which came out ten years later--was based on it to help depict the story of a girl who experiences the sadistic life of the concentration camps. Although both have succeeded in portraying the overall story, the conspicuous differences between the book and the movie make each…

Words 1628 - Pages 7