The Spread Of Firearms On The Anglo-French Frontiers

Submitted By pooja714
Words: 1492
Pages: 6
Open Document
The Downfall Trade
Whenever two cultures come into contact for the first time, trade is almost an inevitable outcome. It is a way to form new relationships between two alien communities that benefit both communities. This phenomenon can be traced throughout history. Trade is usually considered beneficial as both sides receive goods and products that were previously unknown to them. For the most part, these new goods are meant to improve the communities’ daily life by making routine chores easier or quicker. However, in this case of the Iroquois and European trade of the early colonies, trade, proved not to be beneficial, but fatal to these Indian tribes. Worchester presents this argument in his paper, “The Spread of Firearms among the Indians on the Anglo-French Frontiers". In Worchester’s essay, he describes the trade interaction, specifically of firearms, between the Iroquois and Europeans. He specifically argues that the trade of firearms was the main reason why Indian culture was so devastated in three main ways: it changed the aboriginal culture of the Indians, lead to a dependence on European powers, and forced intertribal conflicts over protection. While Worchester’s argument is partially true, he ignores the trade of other goods, specifically run, which also contributed to the demise of the Indian tribes. It was not just firearms which led to the demise of the tribes, but trade in general. In the first encounters between the two cultures, both were willing to trade certain goods in exchange for new, desired items that the other side possessed. The Europeans, especially the French, strongly desired furs from the Indians. This desire for fur gave the Iroquois their first opportunity to receive firearms, such as muskets and gunpowder. In addition, The Indians received what where considered European “luxuries” such as alcohol, especially rum, a new “novelty” item for the Indians. While both sides received what they initially wanted, the implications that they had were far reaching.
In Worcester’s Paper, to prove his thesis he uses certain techniques and a clear layout to enhance his argument. He primarily resorts to using firsthand accounts of battles, direct quotes and data facts and comparisons to bolster his statements. This ample supply of evidence is more than sufficient to support his viewpoints. In addition, his points were logically laid out and flowed in a way that persuaded the reader of his standpoint. However, the only criticism of his paper that one might have is the lack of a clear rebuttal. Only once did he mention any counter arguments that others might possess, and he does not do anything significant to address this. . However, his main thesis with his three supporting statements is convincing.
The first point that the author brings up is that the introduction of firearms deteriorated the traditional way of life for the Indians. Before guns and ammunitions, fatality in war between tribes was at most minimal, and only the one or two captives were religiously killed afterwards. This is best described by the encounter the author cites between the Pieegans and Cree in which, “None of the warriors was killed, which was usual in such engagements unless one side was overwhelmingly su- perior” (Worchester 110) However, after the introduction of guns, fatalities rates escalated, and warfare lead to a detrimental loss of life, especially in tribe culture where maintaining a certain population was critical. Again, this is best illustrated by Worcester when he states,” Several years later these two tribes met again. This time the Piegans and their Cree allies had ten guns, which they were anxious to try in battle. The Cree and Piegan marksmen killed or wounded every Shoshone warrior who exposed himself to shoot an arrow. Appalled by the deadly effect of their enemies' guns, the Shoshones fled with a considerable loss of life”( Worchester 110). In addition, the use of guns for hunting instead of the
Show More

Related Documents: The Spread Of Firearms On The Anglo-French Frontiers

mongols essay

empires was China which was ruled by the Great Khans and Persia, which is in the Middle East, was ruled by the ilkhans. In China and the Middle East, Persia, the Mongols had both a political and economic effect including administration, downfall of the economy and trade. One political effect the Mongols had in China and Persia was their administration. The Mongols weren’t very effective administrators so they had other people administer for them. In Persia the Mongols allowed the Persians to administer…

Words 857 - Pages 4

Essay about DBQ 2

The Dutch held 3 main trade routes (Baltic Trade Routes Map) that supplied them with all the essential resources. However, during the period of 1650-1713 The Dutch were hit hard with trading conflicts, shifting alliances, and general misfortune when it came to its economy. This led to the decline of there monopolies in the Atlantic, Baltic, and the East Indies. The decline in Dutch financial standpoint came because of its lack of security, provinces disunity, and lack of trade ability. The Dutch's…

Words 699 - Pages 3

The Rise And Fall Of The Ancient Ghana Empire

ancient Ghana Empire Here I will examine the upcoming and declining of the ancient empire Ghana. Ancient Ghana was a very fortunate empire. Ghana derived power and wealth from gold. The location of Ghana and its two closest rivers made it easy for trade to traffic. Majority of the knowledge of ancient Ghana comes from the Arab writers and mythical tales. Archaeologist have found some historical representations that could have rooted from ancient Ghana. Ancient Ghana was located about 400 miles…

Words 548 - Pages 3

Mayan Influence On The Mayans

preclassic period is when the civilization was the strongest. The game they played was invented in the preclassic period. The mayans still have some ruins standing. There are three periods of maya time they divided by beginning, thriving, and downfall periods. Maya people were said to be indigenous people. The last place the mayans were in control was the Northern Yucatan Peninsula. The famous mayan ruin is in the North Acropolis of Tikal, Guatemala. The mayans arrived in Mesoamerica around 250…

Words 6606 - Pages 27

Causes Of Disease In Ancient Empires

highest point, the point in which their society is thriving and they are at their strongest point, they are practically unstoppable. However, the harsh reality in which every Empire faces is the unfortunate collapse of an Empire, in other words the downfall of an Empire. Disease was the cause of many Empires like the Roman and Han Dynasty Empires to collapse. Cross Cultural Interaction is a big part of every empire, for many Empires it is the reason why they flourish. With the fact that Cross Cultural…

Words 1277 - Pages 6

Tom Walker Theme Essay example

based on greed are not logical and are never a beneficial choice. Another effect greed can have on a person is turning them into a fiend. One greedy choice can lead to another and one can be consumed in their own greed. In the story Tom made the trade with the devil, and even though he more money than a man can ever want her still goes into business as a broker. He has a plethora off money but still rips of the poor and uses them to make more money for himself(249-252). Tom ruined many lives just…

Words 943 - Pages 4

Roman Empire Dbq Analysis

Mediterranean Sea. The Roman and Han Empire were two of the most influential empires in history. Regardless of their huge size and wealth, both of these empires eventually collapsed. The Roman and the Han Empires both had differences which led to their downfall, but the main thing that led to the collapse of both empires is not one event. Instead, it was many catastrophic things happening at one time which led to the collapse of both empires. In the Roman Empire, Nero was an emperor from 54 to 68 AD…

Words 928 - Pages 4

Similarities And Differences In The Shang Dynasty

of crops. This, of course, wasn’t true, because it probably never happened. The differences in the Han Dynasty was that they actually stopped doing their trade routes, and their relationships with the people in the trade routes were going down. When the Han Dynasty was in real trouble, no one went to help them and this resulted in the downfall of the Han Dynasty. The similarities for these Dynasties…

Words 206 - Pages 1

Essay on W.Africa Empire

on the west African grasslands to the south of the Sahara desert. Cradled between two river basins and stretched across major trade routes, these civilizations grew from small nations to large empires. Each in turn fell due to internal decline and external forces from the north. Yet each, in turn, built off of the earlier accomplishments of the previous civilization. Trade routes, religion, governmental organization, civil improvements, and ruling people groups were all either developed for the first…

Words 1572 - Pages 7

Day of Empire Essay

subjects tried to rule independent states for themselves. Rome slipped into an Era of religious persecution and intolerance, sparking internal rebellions, leading into the ultimate downfall of the Roman Empire. As Rome developed its power, import taxes and limits on trade disintegrated, and Rome became a free trade zone, earning an enormous amount of revenue for the empire. The Roman economy extended globally, and the empire developed bronze coins as a familiar common currency. Socially, Rome…

Words 2011 - Pages 9