The Fall Of The House Of Usher Comparison

Words: 444
Pages: 2

Journal Reflection Assignment [Gothic Tale]
Edgar Allan Poe’s film
The director in Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Fall of the House of Usher,” was trying to achieve a sense of fear by creating an ominous setting with the white smoke, in the entrance of the film, and dark castle in the background. Although the film did achieve a sense of uncertainty, and darkness similar to the text both utilized different details and methods to create this effect. For instance, in the text, concrete details like the Minute fungi spreaded on the castle, the horrifying spider webs, and the dark surroundings, which all easily instilled a sense of fear and death that is similar to the visuals in the movie, but differ in the type of detail? The virgin-like figure and twin of Usher, Lady Madeline, had an innocent demeanor in the film, and seemed as if she was unaware and naive of the ominous environment surrounding her. In the film, the dark gloves belonging to the mysterious figure that appears in several parts of the movie seem to be the culprit of the demise of Lady Madeline, which after she eats causes her to have a fainting spell and fall
…show more content…
In the text, less emphasis was placed on Lady Madeline virginal slim appearance and more is focused on her consciousness and mental state. For instance, the text described the complicated illness that Lady Madeline had, which baffled physicians indicating that it was uncommon and serious in nature. In the film, the environment of Lady Madeline seemed to be deteriorating, but in the text, Lady Madeline seemed to be deteriorating along with the environment through her mental illness, but no real emphasis is made on Usher’s mental state. I believe this was a successful adaptation for the time when the film was made, which created a sense of fear with the added elements of smoke, darkness and the jagged