The Hippocratic Oath Analysis

Words: 804
Pages: 4
Open Document
Charlie Gordon is a 37 year-old man that has an IQ of only 68. Charlie goes to night school with his teacher Miss Kinnian after he works at Donnegan's Plastic Box Company as the janitor. He gets an offer from Professor Nemur and Doctor Strauss to go through an operation that could make him smarter. In any operation or surgery, all doctors need to think ethically. Ethics are standards of what is supposed to be and what isn't that prescribe what ought to happen, usually in terms of fairness, benefits, virtues, and/or the study of one's standards. Charlie's doctors had to think and act like every other doctor. Therefore, Charlie Gordon's doctors acted ethically when they performed the surgery to make him smarter.
To be specific, thinking before …show more content…
The Hippocratic Oath is a promise that doctors make to protect and help others who are sick or in need. Parts of this oath are expressed in the story, such as, "I will respect the hard-won scientific gains of those physicians in whose steps I walk, and gladly share such knowledge as is mine with those who are to follow... I will remember that there is art to medicine as well as science, and that warmth, sympathy, and understanding may outweigh the surgeon's knife or the chemist's drug... I will remember that I remain a member of society, with special obligations to all my fellow human beings, those sound of mind and body as well as the infirm...," just to name a couple (Lasagna). Knowing of this oath, it's very clear to see that Prof. Nemur and Dr. Strauss were using it as a guideline that allowed them to act ethically throughout Charlie's …show more content…
They went through all that was necessary, knew every step, and how to cope with the situation emotionally. According to the "Five Steps of Ethical Thinking" by Andrew Dobrin, they showed that they knew how to think before they acted, which is a very good skill. By making sure it was safe on an animal whose cell structure was close to a human's, they showed that they used the Hippocratic Oath to make sure the human test subject was safe from any harm. Finally, even though they didn’t cover every little part of the ethical questions asked towards themselves and the patient, they covered everything that needed to be considered. Therefore, in conclusion, Professor Nemur and Doctor Strauss did act ethically while performing the operation on Charlie
Show More

Related Documents: The Hippocratic Oath Analysis

Analysis Of The Hippocratic Oath

PHYSICIAN ASSISTED SUICIDE TERESA WATSON PHI 103Inform Logic PROFESSOR JASON LUM May 19, 2013 The Hippocratic Oath is the often invoked against the morality of physician involvement in deaths of patients. The oath declares: “I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody if asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect.” Numerous churches share the opinion of the American Medical Association that this kind of involvement in the death of patients is unacceptable for physic. (UIC…

Words 3054 - Pages 13

Hippocratic Oath Analysis

Nursing's foundational principles are striking similar to some of the fundamental concepts in the Bible; as we compare the Hippocratic Oath also known as the Florence Nightingale Pledge to scripture we will determine if this ancient writing has relevance in nursing today. ANA website records the Hippocratic Oath as stating, I solemnly pledge myself before God and in the presence of this assembly, to pass my life in purity and to practice my profession faithfully. I will abstain from whatever is…

Words 510 - Pages 3

Essay about Prosecution of Nurse Ratched

and patients across the entire facility, disregarding her medical responsibilities and ultimately disregarding her Hippocratic Oath. This oath, taken by all physicians swearing by a number of healing gods in order to medically practise, states that practitioners must uphold specific ethical standards at all times. The accused prevailed her obsessive tendencies1 over the Hippocratic Oath, and as a government funded institute, in a country of a paramount calibre, it is expected that the highest degree…

Words 882 - Pages 4

Therapeutic Relationships In Specialist Palliative Care Nursing Practice

Concept Analysis Article 1 PEER REVIEWED CONCEPT ANALYSIS ARTICLE Peer Reviewed Concept Analysis Article Concept Analysis Article 2 Introduction In the article, “Therapeutic Relationships in Specialist Palliative Care Nursing Practice” by Deebs Canning, John Rosenberg, and Patsy Yates, the focus of the concept is on nursing care. Considered to be one of an essential focus of specialist nursing practice is the therapeutic relationships formed with those for…

Words 998 - Pages 4

Assisted Euthanasia Research Paper

Voluntary/Assisted Euthanasia Grand Canyon University Ethical Decision Making in Health Care Voluntary/Assisted Euthanasia (Thesis, Description of the topic and related ethical implications, Obligations to your profession and work as a nurse) Debra Burden The purpose of this paper is to define the issue and legalities of assisted death and the key ethical arguments, including the social values and norms, encompassing this topic. Also included in this paper on voluntary/assisted suicide…

Words 1199 - Pages 5

Essay on History of Munsterberg

psychology? Thoughts/behaviors interaction with the environment emotions, feelings etcReductionist approach to psychology argues that What we think are psychological experiences/behaviors can be better explained reducing them to a more fundamental analysis (first being biology) must be broken down to physics Trying to break behavior down (math example) What makes psychology different then other disciplines ?What counts as the history of psychology? Why study History? Prevent yourself from making…

Words 1436 - Pages 6

Essay Activist Anthropology

impossible goal but also potentially something more insidious: a cover for the harmful political effects of our work on those whom we researched and wrote about.” (Speed, 2006, p.213-214) It is an ethical dilemma for all researchers to ponder. As the Hippocratic Oath states so succinctly, “First do no harm.” Perhaps that should also be our mantra as we enter fieldwork as anthropologists. Speed’s work with the community of Nicolás Ruiz as they faced the International Labor Organization (ILO) led her to…

Words 1325 - Pages 6

Essay on Health Economics

Medical Care Expenditures (MCE) Medical Care Access Medical Care Outcomes (Quality) 6. List 3 alternative measures of medical care spending. 7. List 3 reasons why the U.S. over consumes medical care services. Financial Incentives Hippocratic Oath Few Scientific Studies Medical Malpractice Lawsuits/Defensive Medicine Physician Desire to Help Patient 8. List 3 of the 4 categories that most Americans without health insurance fall under. Working poor and employees of small businesses…

Words 3017 - Pages 13

Ethics Reflection Essay

p.18). The components of a research proposal should include a cover page, a comprehensive description of the research study, specific depiction of the participants to be targeted, the beneficence of the study to participants, benefits vs. risk analysis, and an explanation of the informed consent forms, right to refuse participation, confidentiality measures, and debriefing activities to be used in the study. These are some of the general considerations that the researcher must weigh and uphold…

Words 3200 - Pages 13

Essay on Nursing and Patient-centered Care

Leadership Cumulative Essay Mathew Johnson College Phoenix Leadership Prof. Monstade February 04, 2012 Leadership Cumulative Essay Introduction This essay will give insight into the author’s point of view on several facets of nursing today. The information provided will speak to lessons learned in the Everest College Nursing program. Topics covered shall consist of a reflection of the personal nursing philosophy, impact and concepts…

Words 3443 - Pages 14