Essay on The Weakness Within

Submitted By tiplubandar
Words: 1334
Pages: 6
Open Document
The Weakness Within

What is weakness of will? Is it a concept that truly exists or is it just something we have grown to accept because of its wide acceptance in society? The concept is a time less notion that has been a topic of discussion dating back as early as the era of the ancient Greeks. In fact, weakness of will was one of the major concepts discussed in Protagoras, one of the ancient Greek philosopher, Plato’s finest works. Protagoras is mainly composed of Plato’s accounts of a debate between Socrates and Protagoras, two prominent philosophers of the time the time. The debate began with Socrates challenging Protagoras, a self proclaimed teacher of virtue, on the credibility of the notion that virtue was in fact a skill that could be thought. After a long discussion on that topic along with many others, a dialogue about knowledge emerges and the debate concerns, the true importance of knowledge. Socrates and Protagoras both agree that the view of the mass is that while knowledge is present in a man, but knowledge is not what rules him, it is weakness of will that is embedded in anger, love, and fear among other things that rule a man and the knowledge is just a slave. They both agree that this view is incorrect and that knowledge is capable of ruling a person, so that if someone were able to know what is good and what is bad, he would not be forced to act by anything other than what knowledge dictates and make a conscious. The way in which Socrates presents it, his argument is all encompassing of any possible scenario and always holds to be true. Socrates conducts a dialogue as if he is speaking to the masses and intermittently asks Protagoras if he agrees with the arguments and conclusions that Socrates is making. First, through a series of questioning, Socrates established the premise that defines good as anything pleasurable and bad as anything painful. He establishes that the claim made by the masses that in a moment of passion one can be over come my pleasure and experience weakness of will can also be interpreted as choosing immediate pleasure over future pain. He also explains that in the opposite scenario, in a case like enduring the immediate pain of a medical procedure, one is making a conscious decision to choose that immediate pain in order to experience pleasure in the future. He does this by using the example of perception, in that things that are close seem larger and things that are far away, so as to say that immediate pleasure seems a lot more significant than the pain it may cause later. Being in the immediate proximity of pleasure causes one to perceive it to be a lot larger than it is and thus can be the root of the idea of being “over come by pleasure.” Socrates claims that every time one makes a decision, it is placed on a sort of sliding scale, where the one end is good therefore pleasurable and the other is bad and therefore painful. The art, he claims is, in weighing a certain amount of good over a bad and vice versa, an art that stems from knowledge. So to say that one was simply “over come my pleasure” and experienced a “weakness of will” is the ultimate form of ignorance. The argument that Socrates makes are very dramatic and for that reason it can, initially be subjected to a wide array of criticisms. One of the major sources of criticisms that can be made about Socrates argument includes the example of a strong drug addiction for example Heroin. Yes, the first time the addict got high, he/she made a conscious decision to choose pleasure over pain, probably being fully aware of the addictive consequences. That does not change the fact that once they are addicted, it is no longer a conscious decision to pick good over bad, the body has a physical need of the drug and the person is nothing but a slave that acts on impulse. Another source of criticism can arise when looking at a very particular set of conditions. For example, say that some criminal is holding a family hostage
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on The Weakness Within

Gender Inequality In Hamlet

presence of the motif, women’s weakness in Hamlet. Consequently, the weakness of Gertrude and Ophelia evinces through the influence of the men’s decisions along with, power on their actions and fates. The motif demonstrates the frailty of women in the play through the illustration of gender inequality, as Shakespeare characterizes the two leading women as weak-minded, submissive, as well as, tools of manipulation for the men. Throughout Act I, the motif of women’s weakness develops in the wake of Hamlet’s…

Words 1083 - Pages 5

A Description Of Guillian Barre

GBS is an acute inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy that affects the peripheral nervous system, causing motor weakness and sensory abnormalities. Signs/symptoms: Ascending muscle weakness, flaccid paralysis, decreased or absent deep tendon reflexes, respiratory compromise and respiratory failure, loss of bowel and bladder control, ataxia, pain, paresthesis, facial weakness, dysphagia, diplopia, difficulty speaking, labile blood pressure, cardiac dysrhythmias, tachycardia Medications/treatments:…

Words 343 - Pages 2

Things Fall Apart Essay

and they are strong for many different reasons. In the novel, Things Fall Apart, by Chinua Achebe, Okonkwo is a man in charge of a tribe within the Ibo culture. With all the troubles he encounters in the novel, Okonkwo is still able to show his strength as a leader. Besides Okonkwo’s fear of ending up like his father, his need for power, fear of poverty and weakness, and overall success, ultimately made Okonkwo a strong leader of the tribe. To begin, Okonkwo’s need for power encourages him to be a…

Words 1121 - Pages 5

Realism Approach To The Ukraine Crisis Essay

theoretical tradition in international relations and the natures of realism has offered explicit explanations for the behaviours of states. However, in the terms of the natures, realism could be explained by its tenets, the crisis and its strength and weakness. Realism could be defined by a number of major fundamental principles. In realism, the state is considered as the most significant actor and its goal in an anarchic world is survival. The survival could be accomplished by the accumulation of power…

Words 677 - Pages 3

Right Arm Strength Research Paper

Weakness in Right Arm Arm weakness is defined as a limited ability to move your arm because of decreased strength in a muscle, or a loss of strength in the arm. A weakness in right arm may happen suddenly or increasingly progress over time, may be accompanied by muscle weakness in other body muscles, or might occur with symptoms, including arm pain. If you have right arm weakness, you could have some difficulty moving the arm, or you simply may have difficulty performing daily tasks with the arm…

Words 1043 - Pages 5

Theories Of Transformational Leadership

Although I demonstrate a lot of transformational leadership qualities, there are weakness within this theory I possess as well. The first being my self-esteem. Self-esteem is defined as an individual's overall self-evaluation of his/her competences (Rosenberg, 1965). An individual with high self-esteem (Rosenberg, 1979): "has self-respect, considers himself a person of worth. Appreciating his own merits, he nonetheless recognizes his faults ["Low self-esteem"] means that the individual lacks respect…

Words 342 - Pages 2

Creativity: Management and Organization Essay

environment of the market. The environment can be broken down through 4ps which are the basis of the creativity which highlight the product, place, people and process. And the other is through the SWOT analysis which helps in determining the strength, weakness, opportunity and threats surrounding the organization and through an overview of the organization though internal environment and the external environment. 1. 4 Ps Figure 2 i. Product When an organization is formed the first concept…

Words 1696 - Pages 7

Saint Thomas Health Case Study

consists of events or recognition of colleagues within the hospital. The goals of the website must be exclusive of how the organization wants to present and maintain information (Turisco & Kilbridge, 2000). There are also links that take you to systems that are used throughout the hospital such as PeopleSoft, Kronos, or Information Technology Request. Any need that an employee may have to perform his or her job duty can be found on the website. The weakness in the site is that the links are hard to find…

Words 289 - Pages 2

Essay JET Task 1 Autosaved

balance sheet or income statement for two or more accounting periods, to compute both total and relative variances for each line item.” Competition Bikes Inc. will be analyzed in each area in regards to years 6, 7, & 8. Analyzing the strengths and weakness of the operations throughout the discussed years will take place throughout the assignment. The Strengths of Competition Bikes Inc. will first be analyzed and discussed. Firstly, Revenue will be analyzed for years 6 & 7, in which there are strengths…

Words 3451 - Pages 14

In the Time of the Butterflies Essay

However, here, the “weakness” within everyone is clear and in reality, is what contributes greatly to Trujillo’s success. Through acts like these, Alvarez is discommending the citizens for being weak and unable to fight back. In addition to the weakness possessed by everyone, Trujillo also does some revolting things. We can see the emphasis on his ruthless acts here, “Suddenly, the dark…

Words 1227 - Pages 5