The Yellow Wallpaper Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Max Tablizo Ms. Barnes English IV 12 February 2024.

Imagine a woman, recently ushered into motherhood, whose once vibrant world now feels shrouded in darkness. As she navigates the challenges of caring for her newborn, she feels ensnared by her emotions. But, what if her distress isn't solely a result of hormonal fluctuations or biological predispositions? What if the true origins of her anguish lie hidden by the social dynamics surrounding her? In this psychoanalytical report, inspection and evaluation of social factors of the protagonist are present, along with the effects they have on her mental health. The protagonist of The Yellow Wallpaper’s husband wanted to dive deeper into his wife’s mental illness. He told the address that she had …show more content…
Hormonal and neurotransmitter imbalances can have serious impacts on mood regulation and depression. An article from Sage Journals (2012) states, “Normal pregnancy and the postpartum period cause adaptive endocrine changes, which would otherwise be considered pathological in nonpregnant women.” Research from this paper has concluded that the endocrine changes that happen in one's body as a result of postpartum distress are pathological (which means involving a mental disease) if found in a regular person. So it makes sense that the wife suffers from postpartum distress and that it is the cause of the way she acts. Social factors do not negate postpartum distress, and while they might be in play and empower the distress, that does not mean she doesn't have it, nor does it mean it's not the main cause. “This chapter focuses on one of the common fallacies in Western philosophy, 'false dilemma (FD)'. According to Andrea A. Lunsford, John J. Ruskiewicz, and Keith Walters, a FD tends to “reduce a complicated issue to excessively simple terms” or, when intentionally created, tends to “obscure legitimate alternatives”. FD reflects incorrect thinking because it presents a problem or issue as having only two possible solutions when in fact there are more.” As seen in this summary of “Bad Arguments: 100 of the Most …show more content…
While both might be at play, the social factors are what's taking her over the line and is the bigger reason why she has gone mad. People with postpartum distress get treated by social outreach and support groups. This means that people have had the effects of postpartum distress suppressed and treated while the wife’s case got worse; emphasizing how it was the treatment of isolation, aka social factors, that drove her crazy and not the distress itself. An article from PubMed Central (2023) states “Social support is an influential component of postpartum recovery, adjustment, and bonding.” Through research shown above, it is evident that a process in recovering from postpartum distress is social support and the outreach of others. The same research paper states the effect that social distancing has on someone who has postpartum distress. Focusing solely on the biological aspect of postpartum distress poses more risk, and if no change occurs in social factors, the chances of relapse are high. This means that addressing social factors first would be a wiser approach and proves it. It is hard to deep dive into a patient's body and biologically solve a hormonal imbalance. The British Journal of Social Work (2011) shows this when saying, “Research findings are

Show More

The Yellow Wallpaper Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Related Documents: The Yellow Wallpaper Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Botticelli: Readers Response Essay