Title VII Constructive Discharge Claim ( Essay

Submitted By tamecabusby
Words: 1822
Pages: 8
Open Document
Toy Company

To: CEO
From: Student

Date: 4/19/2014

Re: Title VII Constructive Discharge Claim (Former Employee)
Comments:
It has been brought to my attention that a former employee has filed a claim against the company alleging “Constructive Discharge under the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.”

Under Title VII of the Civil Rights act of 1964, employees in the US are protected in the workplace from discrimination based on race, color, ethnicity, gender or religion. Title VII also prohibits employment discrimination based on association with any race, color, ethnicity, gender or religion (The Civil Rights Act of 1964, 2013).
The issue that we are facing alleging constructive discharge to be relevant is as follows:
As a result of company growth, at the beginning of the New Year the entire production staff schedule was changed. The new production schedule required employees to work four 12- hour shifts with 4 days off. The 4 working days can occur any day of the week between Monday and Sunday unlike the previous production schedule which was Monday through Friday with Saturdays off. The office staff members’ schedules remained the same, working Monday through Friday 8:00Am to 5:00PM.
The former employee quit after the new schedule change, and filed a claim stating “Constructive Discharge” and alleging the new schedule may sometimes fall on religious holy days. While it may be true that sometimes the new schedule may fall on some religious holy days, Constructive discharge occurs when an employee quits because of intolerable working conditions.
In this case, I do not believe that this instance appears to be biased even though it appeared to have created an unbalanced and unfair work environment which would fall under the protection of “Unintentional Discrimination.” under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Additionally, the organization falls under the protection of the Title VII Civil Rights Act of 1964 “Religion law.” This law states that “A person’s religion is his or her declared or practiced faith or hearing.” The law also prohibits employers to involve religion in the workplace or application process in any way. Finally, the former employee would have to prove a prima facie case which is proof that the evidence before trial is sufficient to prove the case unless there is substantial contradictory evidence presented at trial.
I’ve included a few case scenarios below for your reference.
(1) In Tepper v Potter, the plaintiff Martin Tepper who is a Messianic Jew, was granted permission for 10 years to have Saturdays off so that he could observe his Sabbath on that day. He was also able to be absent from work on other Jewish religious holidays (PlunkettCooney, 2007). The company experienced budget constraints, thus a decrease in staffing. The decreased in staffing caused Mr. Tepper to have issues scheduling his Saturdays off. In this event, the Postal office attempted to accommodate Mr. Tepper’s beliefs by asking other employees to work on his scheduled days and dividing his workload amongst other employees (PlunkettCooney, 2007). This caused many of the employees to be upset and to complain to management saying that the practice was unfair. The Postal union met and voted to terminate Teppers accommodation. Mr. Tepper was presented with the issue and the decision and was advised that management could no longer accommodate his Saturdays without putting an extra hardship on the other employees. Mr. Tepper was also presented the option of reserving his vacation time for his Saturday absences, and allowed to take time off without pay and exchange days with the other postal workers. He responded by filing a complaint with alleging Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 for failure to accommodate his religion and religious discrimination. This case was dismissed by the trial court on a motion for summary judgment. Tepper was not satisfied so he appealed the decision (PlunkettCooney,
Show More

Related Documents: Title VII Constructive Discharge Claim ( Essay

Human Resources Task 1 Essay

Toys Division Subject: A. K. Whitter Claim of Constructive Discharge Date: 08.03.2014 cc: Legal, Human Resources I. Claim and Constructive Discharge Definition Having received notice of a claim being filed by A.K. Whitter, a former employee of Kyds Toys, alleging forceable resignation due to constructive discharge on the premise of the work schedule policy change requiring shift work by all production employees. The complainant is seeking relief under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Even…

Words 2072 - Pages 9

Task 1 Human Resources Memo Essay examples

CEO FROM: Jon Doe DATE: May 6, 2014 SUBJECT: Recommended Response to Constructive Discharge Claim ________________________________________________________________ Constructive Discharge Constructive discharge is defined as the action made by the former employee to terminate his or her relationship with the company based on the existence of a hostile environment. In order to justify a claim of constructive discharge, it is common for the former employee to prove that he or her was subject to…

Words 880 - Pages 4

Essay about HUMAN RESOURCE

HUMAN RESOURCE TASK 1 Memo To: CEO Date: 08/01/2013 Re: Lawsuit claim by a former Employee A. CONSTRUCTIVE DISCHARGE A former employee has recently brought a lawsuit against the company claiming a constructive discharge. He/she claims the company has religiously discriminated against him/her and was asked to work during days which his/her religion considers as a holy day which has forced him/her to quit the job because the company has made his/her working conditions unbearable. This memo is…

Words 1788 - Pages 8

Title VII Of The Civil Rights Act Of 1964

Hodge Entertainment 4511 Felicity Lane, Austin, 78725 To: John Smith, CEO From: Daniel Hodge CC: Fred Flintstone, Company Attorney Date: 11/21/2013 Re: Susan Smith Claim -Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 Mr. Smith, Constructive Discharge, under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, occurs when an employee is forced to resign due to an employer’s behavior becoming so intolerable that the employee feels they have no choice to resign. Due to the fact this action was not voluntary,…

Words 761 - Pages 4

Essay about JDT2 task 1

Findings: Constructive discharge as a legal concept: This refers to when the law treats an employee’s resignation as a discharge that was involuntary. This law requires an intolerable discriminatory or retaliatory working condition for the employee to have resigned or in this sense being discharged. With regards to XYZ Toy Company’s law suit a constructive discharge is only relevant if the former employee can justify how extreme working conditions aided the resignation. In this case, the…

Words 657 - Pages 3

Essay about Human Resources

TO: Company CEO FROM: Division Manager DATE: October 27, 2008 RE: EEOC Discrimination Claim A. Constructive discharge is explained in the University of Chicago Law Review this as such: “An employee who resigns after being subjected to unlawful discrimination is said to have been constructively discharged if a reasonable person would have found the discriminatory conditions to be intolerable.” (Finnegan, 1986) This is also known as the Reasonable Person Test, because to assist with legal decision…

Words 1313 - Pages 6

Jdt2 Task 1 Essay

MEMO TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Mrs. Jane Smith, CEO, Jinkie Pops Toy Co. Amy Hance, Elementary Division Manager August 22, 2012 Constructive Discharge Claim of Mr. William Fleck As per your request, I have reviewed the documentation relating to Mr. Fleck’s resignation and subsequent claim. I have researched pertinent case law and have prepared the following synopsis and recommendation for your review. As the Jinkie Pops Toy Company grows, operational changes are necessary to meet the demands of…

Words 882 - Pages 4

What Is Employment And Legal Issues

Employment & Legal Issues JDT2 Human Resources Task 1 Kathryn Francis August 21, 2014 To: Mr. Manager From: Date: August 21, 2014 Subject: Employment and legal issues Constructive Discharge The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) legal definition of Constructive Discharge is forcing an employee to resign by making the work environment so intolerable a reasonable person would not be able to stay (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, 2014). An employer who wants…

Words 2127 - Pages 9

Human Resources Task 1 Essays

Human Resources, Task1, Constructive discharge A constructive discharge occurs when an employee is legally justified in claiming that he was compelled to resign because the employer has made working conditions intolerable (By Gerard E. Dempsey and Janet N. Petsche August 1, 2006).In this situation, an employee resigns because the employer was unresponsive to a harassment complaint. Complaint is about policy requires employees to work on a religious holy day .In this scenario Discrimination…

Words 1281 - Pages 6

Essay about WGU HR Task1

TO: CEO Toy Co. FR: Julie Parks, Elementary Division Manager Re: Former Production Employee Lawsuit In the case of our former employee filing a claim based on Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, based of the new shift schedule change does not meet the constructive discharge definition. A construction discharge, as defined through several court cases highlighted in The University of Chicago Law Review (1986), as an employee who resigns because of unlawful discrimination that made it intolerable…

Words 1428 - Pages 6