Essay on To Save Or Not To Save, That’s a Question

Submitted By stellayiyichen
Words: 1420
Pages: 6
Open Document
To Save Or Not To Save, That’s a Question
When Bowen H. McCoy, the managing director of Morgan Stanley Co. Inc., and the president of Morgan Stanley Realty, Inc. climbed the Himalayas in Nepal, he ran into an ethical dilemma. There were groups of men from many different cultural backgrounds around McCoy during the climb. While they rested at 15,500 feet on Himalayas, they found a nearly naked, with no shoes, and almost dying Indian holy man, a sadhu. The ethical dilemma they were forced into was if they should come back to the mountain to save the man and probably never reach their “climbing dream”, or ignore the sadhu in order to complete their personal desires. The result is that everyone in the group helped the sadhu a little bit, but finally they left the sadhu in the sun at about 15,000 feet and had pointed out to him there was a hut another 500 feet below. They knew the sadhu was well enough to throw rocks at the dogs, but they did not know if the sadhu lived or died in the end.
There are two reasons can show clearly that McCoy did not immediately recognize that he was confronted with an ethical dilemma. First of all, McCoy said in his paper: “I felt and continue to feel guilt about the sadhu. I had literally walked through a classic moral dilemma without fully thinking through the consequences. My excuses for my actions include a high adrenaline flow a superordinate goal, and a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity-factors in the usual corporate situation, especially when one is under stress (McCoy).” Secondly, when McCoy’s friend Stephen asked him “How do you feel about contributing to the death of a fellow man?” He even did not “fully comprehend what Stephen meant. (McCoy)“ Also, normally people always react a unexpected incident depending on their values without deeply thinking. Therefore, I believe McCoy did not immediately realize that he ran into an ethical dilemma.
McCoy made his decision, which was to leave the sadhu behind but with warmth and food. We can assess his decision through two ethical guidelines. The first one is the Golden Rule, which has a whole idea—“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” Of course, the sadhu does not wish to be left alone. Nobody in that situation wants to be left by others. Therefore, if McCoy exchanged positions with the sadhu, he would not want to be left as well. Driven by the desire of reaching his personal goal, McCoy did not consider the sadhu’s life, as he wants others to be considerate of his life if he is in the sadhu’s situation. He only thought about himself and he believed his will was only matter. In terms of the implied obligation by the social contract and comforting themselves, each of the individual groups of men did a singular act to help the sadhu, but none of them went the whole way to save this sadhu’s life. Therefore, McCoy’s decision is unethical if we test it through the Golden Rule.
The second theory is the Public Disclosure Test. That is one of the ethical guidelines, which helps one make a decision through thinking about what will happen if one’s actions are made public. People care about what others think about us, so this ethical guideline is a very useful method to help people make decisions. In McCoy’s case, we can assume there are three different public reactions. One of the reactions is stand in virtue side. Part of group of people think “helping others (saving other people’s lives)” is a character trait that is habitual and good for people to have because they lead to successful human living. They think leaving the sadhu and only pursuing personal goal is an absolutely wrong thing to do, so they will blame McCoy’s action. Other part of group of people is neutralism. They think saving other people’s lives is great and right thing to do, but they probably believe that what McCoy did cannot be blamed, because McCoy did not have responsibility to save the sadhu’s life and he can do what he wants to do. However, there might have some
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on To Save Or Not To Save, That’s a Question

Lamb To The Slaughter 'And' Gentlemen, Just Lather That's All

short stories, the conflict is fixated on something much darker…murder. There are three short stories that demonstrate this dark subject: Lamb to the Slaughter by Roald Dahl, Just Lather, That’s All by Hernando Tellez, and Gentlemen, Your Verdict by Michael Bruce. In the works: Lamb to the Slaughter, Just Lather, That’s All and Gentlemen, Your Verdict each protagonist has a similar conflict they are faced with. Each problem relates to murder, each protagonist must make an important decision, and each…

Words 553 - Pages 3

Elizabeth Proctor's Lie In The Crucible By Arthur Miller

In The Crucible, there are at least two characters who lie for reasons that can be related to The Death of a Salesman. Elizabeth Proctor lies to save her husband or at least that's what she thinks she is doing, just like Linda Loman. This part of the play was most interesting because her lie was meant to save her marriage and husband. We were taught that lying is morally wrong and unacceptable but Elizabeth did it out of good intentions. Nevertheless, does this make it fair and just? Abigail wanted…

Words 190 - Pages 1

Crucible Theme Essay

circumstance to sacrifice only themselves in order to save others life or lie to save their own life? Will I believe that most teenagers will save their own life rather than saving others, unless that people they are saving must be related to them or worth for them to save. It is because they may be scare of getting hurt or ruined their reputation after telling the truth. In The Crucible story, Arthur Miller describes how far humans will go to save themselves from punishments regardless of the consequences…

Words 677 - Pages 3

How Did George Kill Lennie Justified In Of Mice And Men

murder. Although others believe George was protecting Lennie from a gruesome death Lennie still did die, and George was the one that murdered him without much thought. George’s decision to kill Lennie was not justified because there were other ways to save Lennie without ending his life. One reason George’s decision of killing Lennie was not justified is because George made a rash decision to kill his friend with little thought beforehand. George and Lennie had a dream for their futures…

Words 621 - Pages 3

Unit 4520-275 Presentation Software Answer Key

This has affected my presentation in a negative way so for the next assignment I will be more focused and ready for any actions. Length of presentation – I think I have included enough information about my body transformation by this I mean the question of the assignment but there are further information that I would’ve included if I was given enough time to do so. Length of videos – The length of the video is really good as I have researched most of the music videos and body transformation videos…

Words 532 - Pages 3

Should Kids Get Payed For Chores

Parents don't get payed for doing chores so why should the kids? That's a great question. There lots of different good things that come out of paying kids to do chores. One of the reasons is kids that are fifteen or younger than that age according to Child Labor Laws aren't allowed to get a job in order to get money. Out of nature and social pressure kids are always asking for stuff and sometimes that stuff can be a little expensive. Getting payed for chores will be a great way for them to act like…

Words 491 - Pages 2

The Benefits Of Children

are, kids are costly. From diapers to driving lessons, raising kids costs a lot. To help manage your family finances, consider these simple ideas . The total bill for raising a child in Canada from birth to age 18 is, on average, about $244,000 — that’s around $13,500 a year — according to some comprehensive number-crunching by MoneySense in 2011. (And that doesn’t include the cost of post-secondary education.) From clothing and school supplies to childcare and extracurricular activities, spending…

Words 414 - Pages 2

Project 2 Essay

meeting goals which could give them a bigger bonus at the end of the quarter or year. Because of the combining of the two departments experience employees in the specialty department (contract furniture) could assist the employees that’s not so experience with questions they might have on how to handle an issue with a customer if a manager isn’t readily available and vice versa. The company needs to keep the customers happy and satisfy in addition to saving money; employees will adapt. Although, the…

Words 619 - Pages 3

Two Cheers For E-Cigarettes Analysis

are very deadly and are the causes of many deaths over America. They then continue to introduce the product of e-cigarettes, which is a substitute for the world’s know ‘cancer sticks’ or cigarettes. With in the passage they state the argumentative question if e-cigarettes are secure or not. As many may think that e- cigarettes are unsafe and not as different as the ‘cancer sticks.” Others, as I, believe that e- cigarettes can help us put down the addiction to cigarettes that exterminate many everyday…

Words 523 - Pages 3

Essay on Stem cell

laboratory. Stem cells have the possibility to save hundreds of thousands of lives, scientist work every day experimenting and learning about the affects of heart disease, discovering answers to questions that may save lives, and being able to apply them into stem cell therapies. Heart Disease, also known as cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the number one cause of death in America since the 1900s. Almost 2,600 people die of CVD in America each day, that’s roughly one person every 34 seconds. CVD is…

Words 742 - Pages 3