Hrm In The United States Differ From HRM In Japan

Submitted By barrypower
Words: 842
Pages: 4
Open Document
1. How does HRM in the United States differ from HRM in Japan?
Because the Japanese traditionally honor lifetime employment, they go to greater lengths than in the US to hire the perfect employee for any given position, be it management or blue collar. In order to accomplish this, the Japanese firms form partnerships with local schools to begin vocational training as early as possible for students who do not intend to attend university. This type of grooming is not necessarily possible in other countries, and thus Japanese companies must make adjustments when hiring HCNs. In the United States, it appears these adjustments are at the expense of the job candidate. As noted in the case study, $13,000 on average is spent to assess every employee before they are even hired. The process can take up to 2 years from application to starting work with countless hours in between spent on the many rounds of assessment, trials and interviews. All told, only one in a hundred applicants ever receives a position.
Unlike in the United States, it is considered disloyal to abandon your company, and thus headhunting or poaching of employees has traditionally been taboo. This, however, is changing as younger Japanese employees are enticed by the financial rewards offered by competing firms. In Japan, executives receive a much smaller salary than their counterparts in the United States. However, they do receive a car, are reimbursed for expenses, and are granted entertainment and business gift allowances. While the salary of US executives is many times higher, these perquisites are generally not included. Japanese expatriate managers must contend with the particular schooling needs of employees’ children who must endure a particularly rigorous study regimen in order to prepare for their college entrance exams. The US is far more flexible in this regard, as entrance to university is far more accessible. Lastly, labor relations in Japan are far more cordial than those in the United States. Unlike in the US where unions and management are often at odds with one another, in Japan they view each other as companions who try to solve problems for their mutual benefit. Thus, strikes are far rarer in Japan. The idea of a strike contradicts the collectivist and conformist nature of the country.
2. What do you see as the basic advantages and disadvantages of each system? While US companies do not have the retention rate of firms in Japan, it is clear that the time and money saved in hiring employees, particularly non-managerial employees, helps to balance this out. Japanese firms’ relationships with vocational programs in secondary school is a tremendous advantage, as it allocates workers far more effectively, prepares workers at a younger age, and allows the firms to determine the strongest candidates early on in the process. If the US were to adopt this system, it is highly likely that we could fill many of the thousands of skilled labor jobs that are currently going unfilled, and thus lower the unemployment rate. US firms’ ability to headhunt and poach skilled managers, particularly those with international experience is a double-edged sword. When it works to a company’s advantage, it is a boon; however, if employees are not satisfied with their compensation, it can mean a devastating loss of time and money invested to the company. Labor relations is a very volatile
Show More

Related Documents: Hrm In The United States Differ From HRM In Japan

Reasons Behind Japan's Attack On Pearl Harbor

soldiers were training hard and few people were worried. The attack started for many reasons. One is because for thousands of years, Japan kept apart from the rest of the world. Japan needed many resources, so Japan decided to use world trade. The Japanese military grew very powerful. Only the US stood in japan’s way for world rule. Because the US slapped a trade embargo on Japan, Japan couldn’t trade for US oil. Japan had two choices. One is follow US’s demands, the other was to attack. Japan decided…

Words 368 - Pages 2

Essay on HR in companies

in training and its contribution to national competitiveness one must understand what national competitiveness is. According to Porter (1990) some see it as a set of macro variables such as exchange rates, or low deficits that make a nation more competitive than others, while others see it as the superiority of some nation's management techniques that yield industrial advantage over foreign competitors. However, this might not be true as countries with large deficits such as the US and Japan still…

Words 1047 - Pages 5

Report on Case Study: Walmart Japan Essay

BUSINESS CULTURE REPORT ON CASE STUDY: Wal-Mart in Japan Question 1: How would you characterize Wal-Mart’s approach to global management? The trademark of Wal-Mart’s global management approach focuses on 3 main strategies: low price, best value, large selection of goods & high quality service. Being the world’s largest retailer, Wal-Mart will enter the international market by providing a wide variety of products at a lower price than its domestic competitors. In addition, one of the common…

Words 1225 - Pages 5

Essay on Abeje Maxwel8

The Medieval Era saw the emergence of two distinct warrior classes in Europe and Japan. These were the Samurai’s and the Knights. They were marked in history as a code for courage and sacrifice. Never had the world seen such courageous and dedicated warriors before them. Although, they represented two different cultures; they were similar in several ways. The Samurai’s were the military class warriors of Japan. The Knights were the military class defenses and protectors of the Church in Europe…

Words 514 - Pages 3

Essay Forecast

INTERNATIONAL MARKET AND BUSINESS NEEDS TASK 1- Collect Market Intelligence REPORT. 1.INTRODUCTION- The objective of this report is to forecast international market and business needs throughout Australian Academy of Mentoring Coaching (AAMC) Training group. AAMC already expanded their operations overseas starting in India in 2009, currently (november 2013) they are stablished and expanding their business through the asian market. This means that AAMC should always make sure they know about how…

Words 2966 - Pages 12

Aikido and Janika Love Eisman Essay

2015 Aikido The beginnings of the particular fighting style, Aikido, can be traced back to the founder, a man named Morihei Ueshiba, born in 1883 in Japan. He grew up in a place where his father was beaten by thugs and attacked for his political beliefs, and so he set out to make himself strong, dedicating everything he had to vigorous physical training before transitioning into martial arts. He was awarded several certificates of mastery, such as jujitsu, fencing, and spear fighting, for his efforts…

Words 582 - Pages 3

Shizuka Arakawa Essay

was born on December 29, 1981 in Shinagwa, Tokyo, Japan. Shizuka grew up in Sendia, Miyagi and is the only child of Koichi and Sachi Arakawa. Shizuka was named after Shizuka Gozen or as some people say Lady Shizuka; a very famous person in Japanese history and literature. Shizuka Arakawa is known because she was the first Japanese figure skater to win a gold medal for Japan “I never expected that I would be the first one to win a medal for Japan, so I didn't feel that pressure. But I'm very happy…

Words 762 - Pages 4

Hiroshima And Nagasaki Research Paper

Japanese culture. We made sure the content of the agreement would be acceptable to the Japanese belief in honour and we were still refused and insulted. This refusal to co operate meant that I was forced to take action by increasing the pressure on Japan to agree. Including the strategic incendiary firebombing of the capital Tokyo, if this was not enough to prompt the Emperor to consider ending this war then nothing would. Blinded by pride and honour the Japanese government has failed its own people…

Words 2023 - Pages 9

Can the Concept of ‘Early’ and ‘Late’ Industrialization Explain the Key Institutional and Organizational Characteristics of National Business Systems, and Do They Have Any Bearing on Long-Term National Competitiveness? Essay

financial systems possess a long term perspective to work in partnership. Hutton (1995) mentioned that Germany regards bank as their loyal shareholder on behalf of typical companies, in order to make long-term loans. They also concentrate on labour training and education, which brings them a large skilled workforce. The Japanese economic system develops long-term relationships with their employees for the sake of trust, reputation and cooperation. They improve and transform their employees’ skills to…

Words 2523 - Pages 11

Pearl Harbor Attack

surprise military strike conducted by the Imperial Japanese Navy against the United States naval base at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii, on the morning of December 7, 1941 (December 8 in Japan). The attack was intended as a preventive action in order to keep the U.S. Pacific Fleet from interfering with military actions the Empire of Japan was planning in Southeast Asia against overseas territories of the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, and the United States. The base was attacked by 353[13] Japanese fighters…

Words 376 - Pages 2