Health Care Policy In The United States And France

Submitted By tylerdove
Words: 2912
Pages: 12
Open Document
Taylor Dove
9:30-10:45
28 November 2012

Health Care Policy in the United States and France:
Common Ideals, Diverging Approach

Health care policy is one of the foremost issues of controversy in most modern societies across the globe today. The debate centers on the government’s role in providing health services to its citizens. No two countries in the world have a system in which their governments play the exact same part in regulating health care, portraying the vast number of opinions and views on the issue. France and the United States exemplify a pair of countries that differ in their approaches to health care policy. Considering their approaches, France and the U.S. differ most with respect to the degree of health care costs that are socialized and the role played by the state in regulating health services. However, the health care systems in place in these two countries, despite the prevailing American inclination toward European health care, share many common characteristics based on the common ideals of individual rights and popular sovereignty. There are also problems shared by the health care systems of these two countries, namely, rising costs. The analysis concludes that French policy is overall more efficient than that of the U.S. and that this is primarily due to differences in culture and history.
The institution of health care has been widely disputed in the political arena of every developed nation throughout history. The debate over the role of the state in the lives of individual citizens of a nation is as old as the idea of the state itself and applies to the institution of health care due to its nature: that health care is typically viewed as a moral issue. Health care, specifically, refers to “the prevention, treatment, and management of illness and the preservation of mental and physical well-being through the services offered by the medical and allied health professions.” (4) On opposite ends of the political spectrum lay two differing opinions as to how it should be made available. On one hand are those that view access to health care as an inalienable right: the right to life, and that it shares this characteristic with rights such as freedom of speech and should be protected by the government. Others take the view that health care should be left completely to markets and that the government has little or no place in its regulation and they defend their view by appealing to our right of individual freedom. The scope of government regulation of health services is disputed on a broad scale ranging from the advocation of complete government control of the health care sector to an almost completely hands-off policy in which it is left entirely to actors in the free market to provide these services. Despite the wide range of views, health care has been socialized, to a greater or lesser extent, in all modern, industrialized societies for a long time. What remains undecided, however, is the proper degree of socialization. The differing degrees of socialization in health care policy across nations are reflected, to an extent, in the divergent approaches of the United States and France. Americans often generally view health care in European countries as a nationalized industry. However, this assertion is false. While some countries do have completely nationalized health care systems, it is the case that all modern health care systems are socialized to some extent, and fortunately so. (3) In truth, very few seriously ill patients or accident victims would be able to pay for the actual costs of the medical services that they require. The reality is that the health care systems in the U.S. and France have been surprisingly similar throughout history and continue to share many similarities. In general, countries have developed two basic ways of socializing the cost of health care to provide health security for their citizens. One way is the creation of a nationalized health service, where funding for
Show More

Related Documents: Health Care Policy In The United States And France

Operational Definition Of Health

Definition of Health Why is the definition of health important to health policy? "Health is important and essential not only to the physical and mental well-being of people but also to nations' economics. The United States is expected to spend more than $2.6 trillion in pursuit of health in 2010, which represents 17.7% of the nation's gross domestic product and to spend more than $4.3 trillion annually, or 20.3% of GDP, by 2018. In 1948, the World Health Organization defined health as the "state…

Words 1168 - Pages 5

Childhood Obesity Essay

self-esteem (Tyler & Horner, 2008). Today, 17.1% of U.S. children are obese, meaning they have a body mass index (BMI) of greater than or equal to the 95th percentile. In addition, 16.5% are overweight, meaning their BMI greater than or equal to 85% but less than 95% (Tyler & Horner). The past decade has seen rapid growth in research into various aspects of this epidemic. However, in most countries, there has been a far slower response in terms of the number of funded policies and services…

Words 3036 - Pages 13

Adult Prisons

“Approximately 500,000 adolescents are sent to juvenile detention centers each year, and more than 26,000 are detained on any given day, according to a publication released by the Juvenile Policy Institute and entitled "The Dangers of Detention: The Impact of Incarcerating Youth in Detention and Other Secure Facilities” ’ (Greenwood). Beth Greenwood, a writer for Everyday Life shows the ridiculous amounts of teenagers in custody, and even more shocking is the fact that there are children in adult…

Words 1508 - Pages 7

HCS 451 Organizational Performance Management Essay

three specific healthcare organizations; long-term care, VA hospitals, and community/public health systems. We will also discuss how each organization monitors performances, and how each organization achieves regulatory and accreditation compliance. Communication with leadership in order to align organizational goals, and compliance with regulations and development of risk and quality management systems will also be addressed. Long-term care, VA hospitals, and…

Words 1771 - Pages 8

2012 Presidential Election Essay

2012 Presidential Election: An Election to Preserve America By: Morgan Jenny April 17, 2014 PAS 320- Dr. Bruce Tyler Final exam paper During President Barack Obama’s first term conservatives felt that success came in the form of fighting Obama with every step he took. He took office hoping to bring real change and support for middle and lower class Americans; the type of progressive inclusion these classes had not seen in five decades. Conservatives hope to not only stymie his efforts…

Words 1366 - Pages 6

Standardized Testing Essay

Jessica Schama Dr. Stenberg FYS-100 1 May 2015 Bullying Bullying has become one of the largest on-going growing problems within our society today. Statistics from Family First Aid, about 30 percent of teenagers in the U.S. have been involved in bullying. It has evolved from just the mere average big kid picking on the small kid on the playground. Bullying has long lasting effects that have a great impact on the victim’s life. First, what is bullying? Bullying is unwanted aggressive behavior among…

Words 1935 - Pages 8

Bubonic Plague Essays

flea or rat. It does not spread from person to person. The side effects include swollen or tender lymph glands, fevers, chills headache and weakness. It is only treatable if caught early, but is still deadly. The bubonic plague remains a serious health problem in Madagascar. The plague is endemic in the animal population, and cannot be wiped out. The amount of infected rats in the prisons means the plague can be spread easily. The fleas from the infected rats infect prison guards, prisoners, and…

Words 2630 - Pages 11

Biography Of Henry Clay

Henry Clay was well loved by many, he also gained enemies. In his early years as a Senator from Kentucky and elected Speaker of the House. He was considered a leader of the “War Hawks”. After the war in 1812 his view seemed to change about war, nothing was gained by War and it was very costly. From then on he seemed to avoid war, he always seem to come up with a compromise to resolve issues and seem to avoid war. He ran for president three time and never succeeded. He was a self-made man, no formal…

Words 4443 - Pages 18

Mapping the Issue: Gay Rights Essay

would not be accepted. In the past decade that acceptance has been slowly changing. But it is not enough. There are still so many problems facing the LGBT community such as homeless LGBT youth, discrimination on employment, education, and medical care, as well as freedom to marry in all states among many others. As a friend to many openly gay men, and women I have seen first hand accounts of discrimination against LGBT’s. This semester I want to conduct my research on the current LGBT rights of…

Words 1122 - Pages 5

Essay on Research: Management and Leadership Style

Abstract The purpose of this literature review is to discuss the impact leadership style and management experience levels has only employees. The writer’s interest in this topic stems from personal experience while employed at a community behavioral health agency. A discrepancy regarding the organization’s supportive methods of providing services to the community verses the non-supportive management style towards the staff surfaced, and indicated an increase in employee stress levels ultimately having…

Words 2168 - Pages 9