Utilitarianism and Greatest Number Essay

Submitted By isaacjoel91
Words: 815
Pages: 4
Open Document
Assess the strengths and weaknesses of Utilitarianism

Utilitarianism is a teleological theory first devised by Jeremy Bentham. The theory focuses on the ‘greatest happiness for the greatest number’. Utilitarianism is a teleological theory; the end justifies the means, and thus a thinker would judge the rightness of an action by the end it produces, whether right or wrong. For example, stealing food for your starving family is justified because it results in a good end.

One strength of Act Utilitarianism is that it concentrates on the effects of an action; being a teleological theory. Therefore the consequences of an action are considered, and the theory becomes more of a guideline in society than a firm set of rules. Hence Utilitarianism is very appropriate in a secular society. Through this the circumstances of an individual or various situations can be adapted to the theory. Sarah K Tyler and Gordon Reid state in their book ‘Religious Studies A and A2’, ‘Consequences have real effect on people and should therefore be the basis for evaluating actions.’

Furthermore, for many people happiness is an important aspect of decision making; it is their main aim in life. To have ‘happiness for the greatest number’ as the basis of the theory, evidently overall the greatest happiness is achieved. If the promotion of happiness and lessening of pain is one of our key values, all human actions should have the aims and effects of Utilitarianism.

Equality is exercised in the theory of Utilitarianism; all are treated the same and none receive special treatment. A Utilitarian would argue that the common use of the principle of utility has led to great social reform in the UK, such as the Divorce and Abortion Acts of 1969.

A further strength of Utilitarianism is the simplicity to follow the teachings. The main aim is to maintain the ‘greatest happiness for the greatest number’, and any other suggestions of the theory all fall alongside. Mel Thompson states in his book ‘An introduction to Philosophy and Ethics (second edition)’, ‘It is straightforward and based on clear principle.’

Bentham has provided us with a way of calculating ‘happiness for the greatest number’ through the use of the Hedonic Calculus. The Hedonic Calculus is designed to measure how much pleasure or pain an action will cause. Actions are defined as good if they maximise pleasure and minimise pain for the greatest number. Bentham stated that ‘Nature has placed mankind under two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure.’

On the other hand, Act Utilitarianism relies on an individual’s ability to predict the consequences of an action, which is impossible! It provides a set of guidelines in the Hedonic Calculus which suggest how we can minimise pain and maximise pleasure, but these decisions can’t be implemented when an instantaneous decision is required. Many consequences are unforeseen; it is very difficult to predict what consequences will result from an action.

Some would argue that Bentham has committed the ‘naturalistic fallacy’, by deriving an ‘ought’ from an ‘is’. Stating that happiness is good is not the same as stating that happiness ought to be good. Happiness is a response to the attainment of things that
Show More

Related Documents: Utilitarianism and Greatest Number Essay

3rd Paper Ethics

The idea of utilitarianism came from a British philosopher named Jeremy Bentham. One of his students was John Stewart Mill. John S. Mill then studied his mentor’s (Bentham) work and published a novel called Utilitarianism. Mill had some very interesting things to say in Utilitarianism that people to this day are still conversing about. Mill goes into great detail about utilitarianism and its meaning. It is important to fully understand Mill’s teaching in Utilitarianism and understanding…

Words 1190 - Pages 5

Outline Utilitairanism Essay example

ethical theory of Utilitarianism In this essay I will be outlining and discussing the ethical theory of Utilitarianism and use examples in order to back my points. I will be discussing the main concepts within Utilitarianism and explaining them fully. Ethics is a branch of philosophy concerned with the study of what is good and bad. Utilitarianism is an ethical study which deals with the usefulness of an action and deals with the outcome of an action. Utilitarianism is suggests…

Words 1924 - Pages 8

Essay on WK1 D1

philosophy are utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics. The theory of utilitarianism, you see whether an act is the right thing to do or the wrong thing to do. You have to look at what will result from the act and you should choose the act that has the best results. In our book, Ethics and Social Responsibility it explains that utilitarianism is best described as “if there is only one cookie left in the cookie jar and you have two kids, they would split the cookie”. Utilitarianism is a little…

Words 434 - Pages 2

Utiliatrianism essay

1) Outline the important concepts of Utilitarianism. (21) Utilitarianism is a teleological theory in which guides people to make moral decisions. The key principle of utilitarianism is to bring about the ‘greatest happiness for the greatest number’ of people. This means that the most amounts of people should be satisfied and the most amount of pleasure should be gained, therefore making the act moral. However, because of this the minority are always forgotten, therefore meaning sometimes an immoral…

Words 1166 - Pages 5

Utilitarianism and Happiness Essay

Utilitarianism Sandra LaFave West Valley College The notion of an ethics based on utility — usefulness for human concerns, especially human happiness — was one of the revolutionary Continental ideas of the Enlightenment period. Cesare Beccaria (1738-1794), for example, in his extremely influential work On Crimes and Punishments, argues that punishments should be inflicted only insofar as they are useful for human purposes; and that governments should not think themselves free to punish inhumanely…

Words 3600 - Pages 15

Utilitarianism and Bentham Essay

features of utilitarianism (539 words) This theory of utilitarianism was defined by Jeremy Bentham. Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory which means that moral actions are evaluated by the consequences or outcomes of the action. The theory suggests that there is one rule/maxim that everyone should follow in order to determine what is right and wrong, i.e. the principle of ‘utility’ which suggests that everyone should do the most useful thing which serves the greatest number of people.…

Words 891 - Pages 4

Response To John Stuart Mill's Utilitarianism

criticism of utilitarianism. I will show this through advancing Mill’s response to the ‘swine’ objection, which states that humans should seek out higher pleasures over lower pleasures. Because ultimately a society which does not perceive higher pleasures as better and more pleasurable would be one which leads to disutility. Mill’s Utilitarianism: In Mill’s ‘Utilitarianism’ he states that utilitarianism is a moral theory which promotes the greatest amount of pleasure for the greatest number of people…

Words 1158 - Pages 5

Essay on Could a Christian be a utilitarian

Utilitarianism can exist alongside Christianity because both accept the equality of the individual. The difference is that the outcome in Utilitarianism is a mass decision as a product of individual and equal voting. Utilitarianism accepts the fact that in order to achieve the greatest good, there will be victims as a result. This would go against the idea of ‘agape’ and loving your neighbour. Christians believe that it is their responsibility to look after and help the weak, not to simply accept…

Words 462 - Pages 2

Key Features of Utilitarianism Essay

Examine the key features of utilitarianism (21) The theory of Utilitarianism is based on the concept of utility, a theory of usefulness. Utilitarianism is a system of morality that generates us with what the most useful thing to do in different situations and outcomes. Different Utilitarian approaches to morality have emerged each with their own theory of good and community of concerning individuals. Featuring the main influential contributors to this theory are Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill…

Words 1178 - Pages 5

Mill Utilitarianism

Both Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill's ethical theory were based on Utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is closely related to hedonism because it takes the principle that pleasure and pain are things that make an action right or wrong. Utilitarianism is a theory to which morally good action are those whose consequences produce the greatest happiness. In this way, there are two basic elements that define utilitarianism: its way of relating the good to the happiness of individuals and their consequentialism…

Words 326 - Pages 2