What Are The Strengths And Weaknesses Of Restorative Justice

Words: 623

Pages: 3

Open Document

Restorative justice is a new and emerging way of justice that is becoming popular in countries around the world because of its positive effects of empowerment within community and economically practical costs against the tremendously expensive traditional retributive justice system, which is constantly being questioned for its’ effectiveness. Although, there are strengths and weakness in both approaches, they differ in terms of their core principles. Restorative justice’s strengths outweigh its’ weaknesses and the positives of retributive justice but are influenced by the media’s views which consequently has an immense weight on society’s response and creation of assumptions towards a justice system requiring the involvement of the community.

Restorative justice and retributive justice have major differences …show more content…
For example, if a man commits a robbery under the heavy influence of drugs or alcohol to get money to buy more drugs or alcohol, the media can shape the headline to be in favour of retributive justice by stating, “Intoxicated addict commits robbery in pursuit of more drugs is in need of strict prison sentence to further decrease rates of robbery”. In comparison, the media could have said “Intoxicated addicted commits robbery in pursuit of of more drugs is in need of rehabilitation and community service” which supports restorative justice.

The traditional retributive justice system needs to implement restorative justice because it’s strengths outweigh its weaknesses as well as the strengths of retributive justice. Restorative justice empowers the community by unifying them against the problem as a facilitator with direct involvement. This new approach addresses the needs of the of victims and offenders by making them equal participants and creates opportunities for them to state their concerns as well as acknowledge the harm that has been done.

Criminal Justice Vs Restorative Justice

me that restorative justice has these weaknesses as it is not a panacea. However, to address these weaknesses and move toward a better criminal justice system, I think that restorative justice must be used in conjunction with retributive justice. What has been examined previously indicates that both restorative and retributive justice have strengths and weaknesses in delivering justice. An ideal solution for a more robust criminal justice system would include aspects of both these justice systems…

Words 1659 - Pages 7

Justice In Criminal Justice

committed and an individual is caught in the act, there is a set process that one follows to adhere to the rules of the criminal justice system. This method can be simplified by looking at the common flow of events: (1) an individual is arrested, (2) individual is brought to court, (3) individual receives a punishment. Though it may appear that the way in which the criminal justice system functions is sufficient, many voice the concern that there are certain key players affected by crimes that are consistently…

Words 706 - Pages 3

Circle Justice Vs Criminal Justice

Circle Justice vs. Criminal Justice System Currently in the circle justice is often used, offenders and the juvenile justice system. The Circle Justice system is becoming popular as an alternative in many juvenile courts across the country. Many schools are using restorative processes of mediation. They have resources on how to support victims and on how to treat them with respect. The Circle Justice gives benefits such as, it repeats of offending for some offenders. The offenses brought to…

Words 208 - Pages 1

take home exam JST Essays

Part A- Short Answer Questions 2. 'Diversionary measures in the juvenile justice system are a cost-cutting measure that reduces the burden on the court system and provides less formal options of dealing with young offenders. It is a win-win'. Critique this statement by providing 5 key points regarding the advantages and disadvantages of diversionary measures. 1. Financial- Court based methods of dealing with youth justice are amongst the most costly means of dealing with juvenile crime due to high…

Words 3063 - Pages 13

Essay on Positive Psychology: A Brief History, Critics, Methodology, and Application

Running Head: APPLICATIONS OF POSITIVE PSYCHOLOGY 3 Positive Psychology: A Brief History, Methodology, and Application 1. Introduction 1.1. A Brief History The genealogy of positive psychology established its roots in the development of humanistic psychology in the mid-20th century. The more traditional approaches of modern psychology as developed by Freud and B. F. Skinner, respectively, are psychoanalysis, and behaviorism. One theory may suggest that…

Words 1448 - Pages 6

Essay about Anti-Bullying Prevention Proposal

Youth at Risk Prevention Proposal – XYZ High School Anti-Bullying Program 20130228 Juvenile Justice Prevention Program Proposal Section 1. DESCRIBE THE TARGET GROUP The direct target group is the current freshman class at suburban middle class XYZ High School (XYZHS). Naturally, as the sophomore, junior, and senior classes matriculate through the school, they will be indirectly affected by the program and expected to hold true to the lessons and values taught in the anti-bullying…

Words 6429 - Pages 26

Essay on Learning and Social Care

do not have to take them again. Each unit has:  a level - shows how difficult it is     a credit value - one credit represents about 10 hours' work a unit aim – explains what is coved in the unit learning outcomes – cover what you need to do (skills) or what you need to understand (knowledge) assessment criteria – what you need to show (evidence) Each learning outcome is linked to a number of assessment criteria. Evidence must be provided for all the assessment criteria to gain the unit.…

Words 30856 - Pages 124

Childcare: Education and Subject Code Essay

Ascentis Level 3 Award in Supporting Teaching and Learning in Schools Subject Code: 501/1289/2 Ascentis Level 3 Certificate in Supporting Teaching and Learning Subject Code: 501/1706/3 Level 2 Certificate in Cover Supervision Subject Code: 501/1718/X Ascentis Level 3 Diploma in Specialist Support for Teaching and Learning Subject Code: 501/1719/1 Level 3 Award/Certificate/Diploma Level 3 Award in Supporting Teaching and Learning in Schools Level 3 Certificate in Supporting Teaching and Learning…

Words 43098 - Pages 173