What Is Cultural Ethical Relativism

Words: 626

Pages: 3

Open Document

Trevar Boiarsky
Phil 2306
Jenson
2/6/2017
Critique of Cultural Ethical Relativism The idea of Cultural Ethical Relativism is that there are many cultures throughout our world, but there does not lie an independent standard from which we may judge another culture. “The argument for Cultural Ethical Relativism is (Rachels, 2012: p.18): P1. If Different cultures have different moral codes, then there is no objective truth in morality. P2. Different cultures have different moral codes. C. Therefore, there is no objective truth in morality.” Each society has a different moral code. A moral code is made of standards to live by, and there are reasons for which those standards were made. There is always a logic that can be applied to any moral code. So, if a culture has logic behind their code, how can there be an objective truth? There cannot be an objective truth because every culture is different, so different scenarios apply to different cultures. People live daily life in completely dissimilar ways in each culture. Therefore, one may believe this to be true. …show more content…
For example, in the Satere-Mawe tribe in Brazil, boys become men by putting on gloves filled with irritated bullet ants. Bullet ants have the highest rated pain index and the pain is like being hit by a bullet. Here in America, boys become men in their later teenage years when they are almost through with puberty and become independent. In the tribe, men are thought to be warriors, so the reason behind their ritual is that warriors are meant to show strength and not weakness. When a boy becomes strong in this culture, they become a man. Here, when a boy becomes a man, he can support himself

Essay on Moral Skepticism Response

Ethical Relativism What constitutes right and wrong behavior is a highly debated concept, which differs among diverse cultures, societies, traditions, and beliefs when determining specific rules about those actions. Ethical relativism is the theory that some moral standards are true, but their truth is relative to societies/cultures or each individual person and thus those standards will only apply within a culture or to an individual. The theory is subject to a number of objections, two of which…

Words 1319 - Pages 6

Cultural Relativism: A Theory Of Ethical Action

aware of our surroundings, our parents and elders have instilled in us a fundamental awareness of what is right and wrong. It is actually an inherent trait of all humans and grows from our desire to get along well with each other in order to live a peaceful life. To achieve this way of life we understand that we must do to other people what we expect them to do to us in return. We try very hard to do what we feel and see as the right things to do in certain situations. This is the foundation of ethics…

Words 1879 - Pages 8

Cultural Relativism And Morality

Carlise Richmond World View Assignment #2 American History March 10, 2015 Cultural Relativism and Morality Cultural relativism was coined by Franz Boas, a anthropological researcher, who was fascinated by other cultures and languages of indigenous cultures of the Baffin Isle Inuit. Franz said that a "...civilization is not something absolute, but ... is relative, and ... our ideas and conceptions are true only so far as our civilization goes…

Words 630 - Pages 3

Essay Culture and Moral Code

PHI105 – Intro to Ethics Professor Millard Chapter 2 Cultural Relativism PART A: 1. A.) Page 16 Cultural Relativism challenges our belief in the objectivity and universality of moral truth. Cultural relativists have made all the following claims: 1. Different societies have different moral codes. 2. The moral code of a society determines what is right within that society; that is, if the moral code of a society says that a certain action is right, then that action is right…

Words 939 - Pages 4

Essay Ethics: Ethics and Ethical Relativism

Ethical Relativism has many definitions and has meaning different meanings when stated in theory in general by the following definition “In ethics, the belief that nothing is objectively right or wrong and that the definition of right or wrong depends on the prevailing view of a particular individual, culture, or historical period..”(The American Heritage® New Dictionary of Cultural Literacy, 2005) Also can be viewed in three points of interest as well what is right for one person is not always…

Words 1453 - Pages 6

Visual Media Essay

Relativist Perspective “The Relativist Perspective means the ethical behaviors that are derived subjectively from the experiences of individuals and groups” (Ferrell, Ferrell, Fraedrich, 2015). This philosophy is based around the actions of others and then they will choose the ethical standards in it being right or wrong. For example, in the business world a “relativist would try to anticipate the conflicts that might arise between the different philosophies held by members of the organizations…

Words 660 - Pages 3

Examples Of Moral Relativism

Morality and Relativism Philosopher Jesse Prinz wrote the article “Death of Morality” in 2011. He was a much known Philosopher at CUNY. In his article he discusses morality and how it relates to culture. He finds morality to be cultural. According to dictionary.com, cultural relativismis”the concept that the importance of a particular cultural idea varies from onesociety or societal subgroup to another, the view that ethical and moralstandards are relative to what a particular society or culture…

Words 585 - Pages 3

Cultural Relativism Divine Command Theory

Anthony Parrillo Professor Frim PHI-160 8 November 2015 Cultural Relativism and Divine Command Theory Philosophers have been arguing for centuries about the nature of morality. In the field of ethics, philosophers have focused their attention on answering important questions such as: What is right and wrong? What is good and bad? By what process should we make moral decisions? Philosophers have posited answers through a range of moral theories. Unfortunately, no theory is perfect. Not surprisingly…

Words 993 - Pages 4

Ethical Absolutism, Relativism, And Pluralism

common systems of thought regarding ethics, which are, absolutism, relativism, and pluralism. Ethical absolutists claim that there is a single standard, which is their own, when determining what assessments…

Words 2525 - Pages 11

James Rachel's Argument Against Universal Values

Amongst the growing tensions between countries and protests striving for true equality for all, lies an issue of what our values are as a human race and from culture to culture. While everyone is a product of his or her culture, which causes different perceptions of actions, we are all human at our core and do not have one strict moral code, but some universal ethical standards at the root of our human nature. One proponent of this soft universalism was the philosopher James Rachels. He attempted…

Words 558 - Pages 3