Why Is Columbus Day Be Celebrated

Words: 1634
Pages: 7
Open Document
Holidays are an exciting part of an American’s life, whether that means you are still a child in school doing crafts lead by a teacher, you have a job and get to have the day off, or if you just get to see friends and family that you might not have seen in a while. Holidays have become a more prominent part of everyone living in the United States and to some this might cause more pressure for the celebration to go perfectly as planned but for most, it is a relaxing and enjoyable time. However, all the national and federal holidays celebrated in the United States have caused at least some amount of controversy at some point. These controversies typically occur when the holiday was first introduced or declared and have been caused by a variety …show more content…
Americans have several different valid reasons as to why this day should be removed from celebration and as a recognized holiday, the biggest reason being the history of why it is celebrated. Part of the controversy with this day is the claim that Christopher Columbus was not someone who can be seen as a role model alone and therefore does not deserve a day all to himself every year. The most evitable reason why people disagree with this holiday is because the history that is taught in school about this day, about how Christopher Columbus was the first person to discover what is today the United States, is untrue. There is historical proof that Viking had “discovered” the land long before Columbus arrived and even before that there were Native American Indians living on the land. Native Americans along with other groups of Americans have petitioned to have Columbus Day removed from the federal holiday system, for these reasons along with a few other minor reasons. Columbus Day has been replaced with Native America Day in South Dakota in order to identify the people who were truly here in the United States first (Short, Deborah J). South Dakota is the only state to officially make this change, and while some people ignore the fact that it is a holiday all together, Columbus Day continues as a holiday. This could because of the heritage that comes with the day and that helps made up …show more content…
Other than historical facts that can cause the issue, how commercialized a holiday might have become in the more recent years can also be a reason for disagreements. Some of the more conservative people do not believe that people in the more recent years are giving some of the more religious holidays the respect they deserve by not celebrating them in the “proper way”. Proper way meaning how some of the people that are celebrating holidays such as Easter and Christmas, are not Christians and are only celebrating the holiday for the candy and presents that come along with the holiday. This can cause some of the more extreme conservatives to want these holidays removed from the recognized federal system, and only to be celebrated by the people who are doing it for the original reasons of celebration. In recent years, there have been signs popping up that say things such as “keep the Christ in CHRISTmas” and “Silly rabbit Easter is for Jesus”. These signs are made to remind people the real reason why we celebrate these religious holidays. Then on the other side of the argument we have the liberal perspective which creates the “war on Christmas”. These people believe that America is not a country with the only religion being Christianity and therefore Christmas should be optionally celebrated and instead of saying “merry Christmas” the liberal
Show More

Related Documents: Why Is Columbus Day Be Celebrated

Columbus Essay

Zachary Myrtetus Mr Michalski World History Period 1 11//11/2014 Christopher Columbus A Villain or A Hero Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492. He was the first european to discover the americas and that is his most well known contribution to exploration. However Christopher Columbus should not be celebrated as hero for discovering the Americas but as a villain because he brought war and disease to the native people that killed millions. Bringing the overall population to approximately 60…

Words 409 - Pages 2

Christopher Columbus: Cruel Or Necessary?

Christopher Columbus was a great man, well not me, not this piece. Columbus was a cruel,and harsh man. He was violent, and mean. Yet everyone loved him.This is why Columbus Day should not be celebrated. He was unjust, and unfair for no reason. This is why Columbus Day is useless and has no meaning. Columbus was a man who came from England. He judged people by the color of their skin, or where they came from. He had native americans killed for their looks. They did nothing to him. Columbus even started…

Words 460 - Pages 2

Why Should We Celebrate Columbus Day

Columbus day should not be celebrated as a National Federal Holiday because he did more evil than good when connecting the New World to the Old. He mistreated the “Indians” and was an avarice leader. Christopher Columbus recognized the natives abundance of hospitality and quickly took advantage of it. “When you ask them for something they have, they never say no”, Columbus wrote when discussing the Indians. Another reason as to why Columbus day should not be celebrated as a holiday is the way he…

Words 293 - Pages 2

Essay On Why We Should Not Celebrate Columbus Day

in today’s terms, committed genocide should not be celebrated in the eyes of any reasonable person. Columbus Day, a national holiday, should not be celebrated in the United States (US) for three simple reasons, honesty, morality and exclusion. These three issues are the leading factors on why we should not celebrate Columbus Day. In all honesty, Christopher Columbus did not discover America. Across the US, our children are taught that Columbus discovered our noble land and claimed it for his country…

Words 774 - Pages 4

Argumentative Essay: The Celebration Of Christopher Columbus

The Celebration of Christopher Columbus Columbus Day should not be a celebratory holiday. Columbus does show some excellent qualities, but his Christopher’s voyage is more for selfish reasons than the pursuit of expanding Spain’s territory. This holiday should not be celebrated because his whole journey is to have a respected title in Spain, he killed/enslaved Arawaks and his treatment towards the Arawaks. Americans blind by the untrue facts of Columbus does not make them see the qualities that…

Words 867 - Pages 4

The Celebration Of Columbus Day

The celebration of Columbus Day on October 10 is a disgrace and an insult to any Native American and American that has ever lived. On this day Christopher Columbus is celebrated for “discovering” a new land, which would later become the United States. However, Columbus is by no means a hero or even should be recognized for being discover of the North America. How can one discover a land already discovered and inhabited by millions of natives (History.com). As being a Native American myself, I can…

Words 484 - Pages 2

Should We Celebrate Columbus Day

the familiar smells of a cookout and sound of the “1492” poem. Kids are taught all about how Columbus discovered America with the help of his three famous ships, the Nina, the Pinta, and the Santa Maria. But why is Columbus day a national holiday? What is celebrated? Any 3rd grader can answer that, it is a national holiday to celebrate Columbus finding America. But it’s not quite that simple. Columbus didn't actually discover America. In fact, he never set foot on North America. His four voyages…

Words 513 - Pages 3

Remembering Columbus Day

I am concerned with the debate of what Columbus Day should be called. The two sides of the argument are those who want to call the holiday “Columbus Day,” and those who want to call it “Indigenous Day.” In this letter I will explain why this holiday’s name should be changed to “Indigenous Day.” Columbus Day was first celebrated in 1792, as it was the 300th anniversary of Columbus “discovering” the Americas. From this point on, the celebration has continued on the second Monday of October. However…

Words 343 - Pages 2

Pros And Cons Of Columbus Day

pros and cons of why Columbus day should be a holiday. The main points of the pro side are Columbus’s achievements in history show why he should be celebrated, he is also admired by many Italian descendants. Although many people say Columbus was unfair, and brutal, for his time it was normal for example a gory civilization are the Mayans. The main points for cons are that we should celebrate Columbus's actions, Los Angeles made a counterpart Holiday call indigenous people’s day, which mourns the…

Words 162 - Pages 1

Christopher Columbus Day Research Paper

The celebration of Christopher Columbus should no longer be a national holiday because Columbus’s brutality outweighs his minor accomplishments. Every year on the second Monday of October our nation celebrates a man who never even stepped foot on the land that is now the United States. Children are not taught about the awful reality of Christopher Columbus, such as the enslavement, murder, torture and rape of thousands or even millions of indigenous people. Columbus did not discover our land he merely…

Words 1107 - Pages 5