A Criminal in the Making Essay

Submitted By rajookamal
Words: 3495
Pages: 14
Open Document
A Criminal in the Making: Choice or Circumstance

Submitted: August 1, 2013

Scientific social theories are formulated based on assumptions about people, their behaviour and their interaction in society. The Age of Enlightenment, an intellectual and scientific movement of 18th century Europe, was characterized by a rational and scientific approach to religious, social, political and economic issues. It was during this period, the idea that human beings were self determining entities possessing fundamental freedom of choice, or free will and rational thought was put forward. Once people were seen as having control over their lives, crime was seen as an individualized form of evil, or that moral wrong doing was by personal choice. English philosopher John Locke postulated that the mind is a blank slate or tabula rasa. Locke suggested that human beings are born neither good nor bad, without innate ideas, and derive knowledge through experience. No one is born a criminal, but something goes awry and deviating from the social norm results in what is deemed a crime. Henceforth, applying the choice/circumstance question to criminal behaviour in an attempt to understand “what went wrong” has generated conflict. The debate has caused much controversy in justifying human characteristics and social practices.
The social problems perspective of crime is a macro analyses which emphasizes that crime is a manifestation of underlying social problems beyond the control of individuals, whereas the social responsibility perspective is a micro analyses which holds that individuals are fundamentally responsible for their own behaviour and choices. However, social science is a slow uphill progression of improvements of methods, and it is important to avoid conclusions which may have harmful sociological or political (biased) effects on groups of people. Therefore, although a crucial distinction exists, perhaps those who become criminals are not the result of choice or circumstance respectively; they are a result of both.
The oldest known explanatory model for violations of social norms is that of demonic possession, spiritual influence or temptation. It was thought that criminal behaviour was the result of a possessed mind and/or body and the only way to exorcise the evil was usually by some torturous means such as trephination. However, in the late 1700s and early 1800s, as a direct consequence of Enlightenment thinking, superstitious beliefs and supernatural explanations for human behaviour were discarded, and people were seen as having control over their lives. The Classical School of criminological thought developed, and theorists such as Cesare Beccaria put forth the idea of rationality or that, “criminals have control over their behaviour, that they choose to commit crimes and they can be deterred by the threat of punishment” (Schmallenger and Volk, 2009: 130). Jeremy Bentham, another founding personality of the Classical School suggested the principle of hedonism or that pain and pleasure were two central determinants of human behaviour, and that individuals would only be deterred from committing crime if the pain of crime commission outweighed the pleasure derived from criminal activity. Bentham reiterated that self-interest is typically what motivates human behaviours.
Biological theories of criminology suggest that the basic determinants of human behaviour are constitutionally or physiologically based. The early biological theories viewed criminal behaviour as the result of defect in the individual that was either biological or genetic in nature and served to separate the criminal from the law abiding citizen. Contemporary biological theories concentrate more on variation in genetic and other biological factors in interaction with the environment. Sociologists and criminologists have speculated about and investigated visible physiological characteristics such as body type, facial features, gender and racial differences as well
Show More

Related Documents: A Criminal in the Making Essay

Eric Johnson And John Payne's Behavioral Decision-Making Theory

understand criminal decision making. The decision to commit a crime is the first behavior function of our criminal justice system (Carroll, 1982). Carrol believed that decisions by our law officials all follow the choice of which criminals commit crimes. As we all know each offender has their own way of thinking and none think alike. Researchers have tried to determine the process of what leads a criminal to commit a crime (Johnson & Payne, 1985.) A central part of decision making is constructed…

Words 220 - Pages 1

Rational Choice Theory

that people engage in deviant behavior if the situation dictates. In other words, if the situation they are in offers an opportunity to commit crime a would-be offender will take advantage of this opportunity. To understand the offender decision-making process during situation crime we can refer to the rational choice perspective, which considers man as a reasoning and rational being who assesses the benefits, costs, ends and means, and then makes a rational decision. Although rational choice theory…

Words 1382 - Pages 6

Enforcing The Criminal Justice Process

In the processes of criminal justice, there are systems that go in a step by step order, which include police, courts, and corrections. Although they have similarities such as enforcing the law, they all have different jobs to perform. These jobs include enforcing the law and stabilizing civil order, interpreting the laws to determine how the criminals will be charged, and enforcing the rules at criminal occupied facilities. What will be introduced first is the beginning step of enforcing the law…

Words 723 - Pages 3

Criminology assignment Essay

In the early 19th century there were many classists that believed in voluntarism. This mean that the criminal has the choice to commit the crime. They believed that punishment should be prompt and fair to all people , depending on the crime committed . They punished criminals to deter people. People believed that severe punishment was making no difference to crime rates , this meant that criminals were not deterred and recidivism rates were still high. The solution to this , to understand the cause…

Words 697 - Pages 3

Choice Theory Of Crime

Criminal acts and choices Choice theory plays an important role when there are reasons leading to a criminal activity. Choice theory has its own importance when creating strategies for controlling crime or when it is trying to reduce crime. This is an important theory to understand and how it affects the possibility of someone taking part in a criminal activity. Also, understand its attempt to control crime and how it would take place under the choice theory. Choice theory affects…

Words 651 - Pages 3

Effects Of The Three Strikes Law

Effect on decision-making process These two policies discussed with the three strikes law as well as the policy on first-time marijuana offenders have had a direct effect on the decision-making processes in the police and court systems of the criminal justice agencies. These policies affect the decision-making process by directly influencing how the different segments of the criminal justice system have to deal with offenders in these particular crimes. When you look at the three strikes policy…

Words 560 - Pages 3

Criminology: Crime and Raffaele Garofalo Answer Essay example

smuggling immigrants to our country and getting them involved in criminal activities. Finally we have destruction of cultural property where we get terrorists destroying cultural symbols. 2. Explain the similarities and differences between deviance and crime, and provide examples. Deviance is when we have someone violating social norms and laws. An example would be a house burgarly. Crime is when we have a human behavior violating a criminal law where we give a punishment. An example would be speeding…

Words 1153 - Pages 5

American Ourt System Essay

Danielle Diaz The United States courts and history and its purpose has been a strong order of justice in the nation since the first time it was established. The system was designed to allow the citizens of the United States to receive a fair criminal trial regardless of social status, gender, race, and ethnic background. The Court .A court is an institution that the government sets up to settle disputes through a legal process. Courts decide what really happened and what should be done about…

Words 765 - Pages 4

StudentNotes Part1 IntroCJSystem JCaplan Essay

Introduction to Criminal Justice | Rutgers University School of Criminal Justice | Dr. Joel Caplan PART ONE Crime and the Criminal Justice System Course Introduction System: a regularly interacting or interdependent group of parts forming a unified whole, whose operations … are directed toward The Criminal Justice System: • … Players… • It is a “system” because • Parts … Due to the very nature of the criminal justice system being a “system”, it is multidisciplinary…

Words 2712 - Pages 11

Analysis Of Bonnie Richard's Essay: The Insanity Defense

permissible act of the criminal law. Richard states that if a person did not understand the wrongfulness of their actions during the offense, then they should not be punished. The people with mental disorders should have the right to receive medical treatment because of their inability to be in contact with reality. Richard beings her argument by stating her positon to the controversial topic. Again, she is opposing the abolishment of the insanity defense, and is in favor of making adjustments to the…

Words 733 - Pages 3