The Morality Of Abortion

Submitted By Peter-Hussey
Words: 1221
Pages: 5
Open Document
The morality of abortion is a long debated dispute. The concept of taking a persons life has been an exhausting and relentless debate. Typically abortion is debated amongst politics and the law. It answers serious philosophical questions such as; is it right to take a human life or when does a human life begin? In this paper I am going to analyze when life begins and the legal parameters associated with this claim. According to Judith Jarvis Thomson's “A defense of abortion” she argues that the fetus has a right to life but does not have the right to a woman’s body. She argues that life does not begin at conception all though there are many characteristics of a human being the fetus can not live on its own. This raises the question who has more rights? Does the fetus have the right to live or does a woman have more right to what happens in her own body? She goes on to analyze how a third party has no right to intervene and take the life unless it threatens the life of the mother. Then it is deemed necessary to take the life to save the mother. This however is a complex situation and an extreme case. She goes on to ensure that her claims do not support murder but self defense. It must be the mothers life or the child's. If the mother is in danger and could lose her life then she has the right to take action for survival. She is saying that a mother has a right to an abortion if she will suffer loss of life. There are three extreme cases where where they demonstrate just and unjust killing of a fetus.(Thomson,2014) The first example is of a violinist who shares your kidneys. To unplug him would kill him and be unjust. The reason it is unjust is because they violinist has not attached himself to you willingly. Therefore for a third party to remove him it would be considered unjust. Another example they provide is a women being raped. She has no choice in the matter of conceiving a child and had no intention of having the child. Under this extreme circumstance the women should have the right to choose to have an abortion. (Thomson,2014) They compare the woman's body to a house and how the child is a tenant and the mother is is the owner. The mother has the ultimate right to decide what happens to her body but what right does the unborn child have? Another example is of an unjust circumstance is the example they provide of two children getting a box of candy. They are brothers and the chocolate was meant for both kids. The older brother was given the chocolate and told to share with his younger brother. He dose not want to share with his brother so this is considered unjust. We can not confuse indecency with injustice; just because someone should do something out of decency dose not mean they are obligated due to being unjust. The premises and conclusions offered are of extreme cases and can not be set as precedence in law. They go on to explain they support abortion for some circumstance but not for the unjust cause of murder. The context of the writing pretends that the fetus becomes a human being at the moment of conception. (Thomson,2014) I am going to argue that the fetus has no rights and is not considered a being until it is able to survive on its own. According to supreme court justice Blackmun in the decision of Roe V. Wade Black mun developed a three tear theory. We are going to look at the second tier where “Blackmun’s Framework encompassed the period from the end of the first trimester to the point of fetal viability – the point at which a fetus can survive outside the womb, either through natural or artificial means, which typically takes place between about 24 and 28 weeks into a pregnancy.”(U.S. Supreme Court, para, 9) So according to the law this is when the fetus becomes a being and woman shall not have an abortion unless the mother has life threatening complications. This would deny the theory that life begins at conception and would give the definition of the mother being a host and the fetus
Show More

Related Documents: The Morality Of Abortion

A Character Analysis of the Film: Blood Diamond (2006) Essay

stolen and smuggled by Danny Archer (Leonardo DiCaprio) there is an unethical and immoral business dilemma he must deal with through other characters he encounters during the Sierra Leone Civil War of 1999. Another character, Solomon Vandy (Djimon Hounsou), is a native of the region that has been captured and forced into slavery as a diamond miner/laborer that invariably comes into contact with Archer after he discovers a large and rare diamond that he hides during his work shift. This aspect of the…

Words 2580 - Pages 11

Blood Diamonds Essay

the way they turned to violence. Instead of going about it peaceful they decided to kill the people of Sierra Leone and the government militia to take over the diamond mining camps. The RUF burned people’s homes, rape the women, and took their sons to help fight their war and made the fathers work in the diamond mines. The RUF needed the diamonds to finance their war. They used the diamonds to buy guns and supplies from Colonel Coetzee. Freedom was in the hands of the people by voting; so they cut…

Words 1383 - Pages 6

America History X Essay

comfortable with and do the best that he could with it. Even though he had a swastika tattoo on his chest, the prison officials forced him to work with the black men. Prison changed the way that Derek thought about life, causing him to change his way as well as no longer practicing in or for the KKK. The movie American History X is about two brothers, Danny and Derek Vineyard who are skinheads. Derek was the older of the two brothers. The movie beings as with three black men pulling up trying to break…

Words 1583 - Pages 7

sttartton essay

THE SHINING, first published in 1977. Jack Torrance is a man terrorized by demons. He loves his wife, and his son Danny, but Jack is the product of an abusive father, and has a tendency to lash out when angry (and drunk)–even at those he loves. His violent outbursts cost him his teaching job, and almost cost him his marriage. He takes a job at The Overlook, a hotel set high in the Colorado mountains, as a caretaker during the winter months while the hotel is closed, hoping the time of seclusion will…

Words 2069 - Pages 9

Essay Love: The Sopranos

history and the value of hard work. According to Tony his mother was a cruel and joyless woman who at once plotted with his uncle Jackie to have him killed but the plan failed. When the boss of DiMeo sent to prison in 1995 Tony became well respected by others. Tony’s relationship with his mother was quite strange she tried to have him killed on several occasions. Livia Soprano, Tony’s mom, was upset because she had heard about her son’s plan to put her into a nursing home. Tony is married to Carmela…

Words 1581 - Pages 7

Essay on The Ruthless

All the way from “Jack the Ripper” to Ted Bundy, everyone struggles with the question why? What made these monstrous individuals do the things they did to their victims? Researchers have found that due to a lethal combination of genetics, a difficult home life, and sometimes even what seems to be the smallest of things like a bad break up, these are the causes that create a serial killer in the making. “According to criminal investigators a serial killer can be defined as a person who enjoys luring…

Words 1153 - Pages 5

John Berger A Paternal Relationship

in front of my brother and me. At a young age, the father that was presented to me in the media had painted a picture that defined the standards of what a father should be. To site a specific example, the television show Full House’s character Danny Tanner showed me a kind, caring, loving, attentive father. He showed me someone who was insightful, involved and eager to be a part of his children’s lives. My parents divorced when I was four years old. I have little knowledge of the details surrounding…

Words 1206 - Pages 5

Genre: Native Americans in the United States Essay

People’s culture and history. Through the selected works, the paper illustrates the culture of the people which centers around nature and respect for the spirits, along with the history of their persecution of their beliefs and their culture. Each work is transitioned with a relevant quote towards the work and the meaning of it. My thesis weaves in through the works and brings up new questions concerning the topics and issues presented in the work, along with relevant analysis around the book with…

Words 1231 - Pages 5

Matewan

miners trying to form a union and is up against a big Coal Company as well as the notorious Baldwin Felts detective agency. Joe Kinnahan comes to Matewan on a train as a secret union organizer for the United Mine Workers. He sneaks into living in the home of Elma Radnor a coal miners’ widow. Kinnahan’s insertion was a key into the start of forming a union, educating the miners and establishing order in the mobilization in the forming of the coal miners union. Joe went from the enemy to the to the advocate…

Words 632 - Pages 3

Lam: Love and New York Essay

Carolyn Lam Ms. Clapp AP English Literature 13 April 2012 Some works of literature are based on a true story; John Patrick Shanley’s are based on life experiences. While his works of art are not play by play accounts for his life events, they are however based on occurrences in his life. Born in the Bronx on October 3rd, 1950 John Patrick Shanley was the youngest of five children. His mother was a telephone operator mother and his father a meat packer. At a very young age John Patrick Shanley already…

Words 5371 - Pages 22