Dred Scott Case Essay

Words: 645

Pages: 3

Open Document

In the year of 1857, the U.S. Supreme Court came with a decision in the Dred Scott case, stating to take their slaves into Western territory. This was one of the most controversial case that bloomed and had a big impact on the history of slavery. The main points in this event consist of the implications on the topics such as the status of slavery in the United States, the concept of Popular Sovereignty, and the future of slavery in America. As self-explanatory in the name of the case, Dred Scott plays a big role. But, who is Dred Scott? Dred Scott v. Stanford was a black slave, who lived with his master for five years in Illinois and Wisconsin territory which were both free states at the time of Scott’s residence. The Supreme Court was all in favor of the slave states. Five of the nine justices were from the South while a man, Robert Grier of Pennsylvania, was committed to pro-slavery. On March 6, 1857, as Scott fought for his freedom, the court held that he was not free based on his residence in either Illinois or Wisconsin due to not being considered a person under the United States Constitution. According to the opinions of the justices, African American people were not considered citizens …show more content…
The idea of Popular Sovereignty is the belief that the authority, legality and legitimacy of the government is created by the will or consent of it’s people. How was the event affected by the concept of popular sovereignty? It was questioned that if Congress could not exclude slaves from a territory, how could a territorial legislature do it? At some point, until statehood was granted, slavery was seemed as unprofaned as freedom of religion, speech, or any type of civil liberty guaranteed by the constitution. The way the Dred Scott Case affected the concept was that people felt that they had the right to either reject or accept slavery. However, the Supreme Court decision negated popular

Essay on Dred Scott Case

Stephanie Doan Ms. Hawkins English 11 Honors 15 January 2015 The Impact of the Dred Scott Case on Slavery The Dred Scott Case was the biggest and most prolific case in the 18th century. At the time, slavery was a big topic of discussion in the North and South. Upon the beginning of the New World, it is estimated that six to seven million slaves were imported to America during the 18th century alone. The Dred Scott case impacted slavery by giving southern slave owners a new legal standing, making abolitionists…

Words 1949 - Pages 8

Essay On The Dred Scott Court Case

Dred Scott Supreme Court Leads to Civil War The Civil War started when the Confederated went to the soldiers at Fort Sumter, North Carolina on April 12, 1861. This war was fought between the Union States, which were the Northerners, against the states of the Confederacy, the Southern states. It lasted a total of five years from 1861 to 1865 and there was many causes and events that led to the start of the War. There was differences between the northern and southern states about slavey, trading and…

Words 955 - Pages 4

Planned Parenthood V. Wade Summary

Dred Scott was born a slave in Virginia. Dred Scott was sold to Dr. John Emerson. After his owner died, the ownership reassigned to his wife Eliza Irene Emerson. Scott decided to sue her to gain their freedom. He claimed that because they had lived in a free state and territory where slavery was prohibited, they were truly already free. Supreme Court decision stated that slaves were not citizens. Just living in a free state or territory, even if it was for years, did not free slaves. Supreme court…

Words 1007 - Pages 5

Essay on Slavery in the United States and Constitution States

AP US Essay Throughout the Pre-Civil war era, conflicts between the north and south began to stir sectional discord and tension that lead to the framing of the constitution, jeopardizing its purpose. Sources of the discord were found under Literature, Polemics, increasing Tariffs, but mainly the Principle of the Constitution on which the governmental power lies within the people. With the basis of this principle conflicting with the views of the north and south ultimately lead to the Civil War…

Words 693 - Pages 3

Dred Scott Decision Essay

Arsh Parmar History 110-01 Book Essay #1: Abraham Lincoln. 1. What is the difference between a. and a. The main conflict between the North and the South that led to war. a. What was the Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854)? The Kansas-Nebraska Act was a law passed in 1854 that organized the territories of Nebraska and Kansas and left the status of slavery in those territories within the hands of the “popular sovereignty,” which essentially made the residents responsible for the decision. This bill was sponsored…

Words 991 - Pages 4

Causes of the Civil War Essay

Conner Ties Shrunk 3 12/3/14 Causes of the Civil War Essay The United States of America had just finished the Mexican American War which ended with battle of Chapultepec. After this American victory Mexico signed the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo and with that gained a huge chunk of land, but with that land came decisions. Many people would believe that after fighting a war against a common enemy the country would unified together even greater. However it was far from unified and on the verge…

Words 745 - Pages 3

Causes Of The American Civil War

Essay 5-A The Civil War in the US took place from 1861 to 1865. Many Americans lost their lives, but in the end, America was finally united. The United States was finally a single nation instead a company of states with their own establishments. The United States had many problems that led to the Civil War. One of the main causes for war was the social and economic differences between the North and the South. The South was basically a one crop economy because of the invention of the cotton gin…

Words 1135 - Pages 5

Civil War essay

Essay 5-A The Civil War in the US took place from 1861 to 1865. Many Americans lost their lives, but in the end, America was finally united. The United States was finally a single nation instead a company of states with their own establishments. The United States had many problems that led to the Civil War. One of the main causes for war was the social and economic differences between the North and the South. The South was basically a one crop economy because of the invention of the cotton gin…

Words 1142 - Pages 5

James K. Polk: Supporter Of Expansion In The United States

Dred Scott was a Missouri slave. His owner took Scott with him when he moved to a free state. The owner died and Scott sued his owner’s wife for his freedom. John Sanford, the owner’s wife brother, claimed ownership of Scott. He argued that Scott could not sue since he is private property and does not have the rights of citizenship. This case became known as the Dred Scott Decision and the Supreme Court decided to handle this case. Chief Justice, Roger Taney, declared that Scott had no…

Words 2814 - Pages 12

Effectiveness Of The Compromise Of 1850

Essay #5 While compromise over the system of slavery was possible in 1850 it was not effective in 1860’s. The compromise of 1850 was the continuation of the system of slavery, and the description of the events, which led to freeing of the slaves in 1860’s. The fundamental differences in agriculture and the adoption of slavery in the South of America gave rise to the early American History. The thirteen states had each developed separately and had differences in beliefs and their culture and issues…

Words 2138 - Pages 9