Eyewitness Testimony Analysis

Words: 462

Pages: 2

Open Document

In the informative essay “The Problem with Eyewitness Testimony,” Laura Englhardet explained the reasoning about why criminals shouldn’t be convicted on eyewitness only. Eyewitness testimony can make a deep impression on a jury, which is often exclusively assigned the role of sorting out credibility issues and making judgments about the truth of witness statements. I believe it is extremely important to be as correct as possible in your testimony considering judges will trust you and you could accidentally frame a person for a crime that will ruin their life.
Elizabeth Loftus conducted a very simple but intelligent experiment in the mid-seventies demonstrating the effect of a third party’s introducing false facts into memory. During the experiments she would just simply show a slide of a car at an intersection with either a yield sign or a stop sign to a subject. Then many experimenters falsely substituted the term "yield sign" in questions directed to participants who had actually seen the stop sign slide. The results indicated that subjects remembered seeing the false image. This experiment is closely related to the actual eyewitness crime testimonies and helps law enforcements understand that people will just jump to conclusions. “Courts, lawyers and police officers are now aware of the …show more content…
I don’t think “the competence of the average person” should be questioned if they make a mistake. The people being questioned had most likely been under a lot of stress, so it would make sense for them to jump to conclusions or make mistakes. But with these aspects in mind you should not depend on an eyewitness but instead you should need physical proof. The entire article is saying how faulty eyewitness testimony is and how many people have been put behind bars for a crime they did not actually

Ronald Cotton Eyewitness Testimony

The case of ronald cotton is a powerful example that demonstrate that eyewitness testimony is not always reliable. Ronald cotton was wrongly convicted of the rape of Jennifer Thompson by means of the victim’s testimony before DNA analysis was widely used. What I find interesting is during the police interrogation, when Jennifer Thompson was going through the pictures ,she said it felt like she was taking the S.A.T exam. I think this was an odd comparison for a photo lineup because it only…

Words 451 - Pages 2

Essay about Psychology Ewt

Age -Children may be unlikely to have the confidence to correct mistakes made by adults during interviews where they are giving testimony, Roberts and Lamb (1999) did a analysis of 3-14 year olds in 68 interviews for abuse cases in USA. They listened to interviews and recorded how many changes were made by adults. e.g. if the child said near the school and the adult later said in the school, and how many of those were corrected by the child. Out of 140 changes, only a third were corrected, and only…

Words 412 - Pages 2

Gang Violence Essay

testing with 3 out of 4 involving cases of eyewitness misidentification. (Innocence Project 1999) In 1907 or 1908, Hugo Munsterberg published “On the Witness Stand”; he questioned the reliability of eyewitness identification. As recent as 30 or 40 years ago, the Supreme Court acknowledged that eyewitness identification is problematic and can lead to wrongful convictions. The Supreme Court instructed lower courts to determine the validity of eyewitness testimony based on irrelevant factors, like the…

Words 2835 - Pages 12

Criminal Justice System: Forensic Evidence Analysis

The Reliability of Memory in the Criminal Justice System Chelsea Tatz Manhattanville College Introduction Eyewitness testimony plays a key role in the criminal justice system. While forensic evidence has begun to play a part role in criminal investigations, it the memories of witnesses that those in the justice system rely on (Brainerd, C.J., 2013, pg. 547). Witness memories of events and their ability to identify potential suspects are the foundation used to direct investigations…

Words 1689 - Pages 7

Forensic Psychology Review Essay

What types of activities do clinical forensic psychologists do? 2. Psychology in the law what kind of activities: A psychologist in court providing expert testimony concerning some issue of relevance to a particular case. EX: the psychologist might testify that, based on his or her understanding of the psychological research, the eyewitness on the stand may have incorrectly identified the defendant from a police lineup. A police officer using his or her knowledge of psychology in an investigation…

Words 1762 - Pages 8

Genocide Historiography Report

For historians studying the Armenian genocide and its causes, government documents such as eyewitness accounts and correspondence between departments to determine the intent of the State to destroy the Armenian population. To investigate women’s involvement in the genocide process, my sources for this project will rely heavily on oral histories…

Words 1294 - Pages 6

Dual Court System Essay

Their testimony at trial provides an effective way of introducing scientific evidence in such areas as medicine, psychology, ballistics, crime scene analysis, photography, and many other disciplines. Lay witness testimony are going to be about what they saw like who committed the crime or who crime on the crime scene shortly after the crime occurred or it will provide…

Words 1073 - Pages 5

Wrongful Conviction: the Darryl Hunt Case Essays

committing crimes. For instance, Conroy and Warden (2011) established that when 85 people were incarcerated wrongfully, actual perpetrators committed eleven sexual assaults, fourteen murders, ten kidnappings, and over sixty other felonies. Findings and Analysis Cases of wrongful conviction and confinement are an indictment on the criminal justice system, and present challenges for all stakeholders. A person convicted wrongfully suffers the most inhuman conditions, is ostracized from society, and finds…

Words 1248 - Pages 5

Adoption: Public Speaking and Main Points Essay

1. Dyadic communication | Happens between two people. (Like a conversation) | 2. Small group communication | Involves a small number of people who can see and speak directly with one another. | 3. Mass communication | Occurs between a speaker and a larger audience of unknown people who usually are not present with the speaker. | 4. Public speaking | A speaker delivers a message with a specific purpose to an audience of people who are present during the delivery…

Words 1572 - Pages 7

Essay on Child Abuse and Forensic Interviewer

Ila Ann Still Capstone Project Week 10 Final Application Assignment May 10, 2014 Professor Cynthia Jackson Several problems exist when it comes to laws, investigations, testimony, training, education, information sharing and the debate between the legal and psycholegal community when it pertains to the cases of child abuse. In 2012, the Federal Bureau of Investigations reported that an estimated 1,214,462 violent crimes occurred (U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation, 2012)…

Words 6197 - Pages 25