Paul's Case By Willa Cather

Words: 1761
Pages: 8
Open Document
Whether the story takes place in the fantasy or in the present-day world the literary element of setting is significant to the development and evolution of the road map for any plot. In “Paul’s Case” authored by Willa Cather the setting changes within this fictional story and plays an important aspect in revealing the protagonist’s character. Paul, the average young man, Cather portrays is in search for the elegant things in life and believes that money can transform his identity to someone influential. She is coy in her presentation of this narcissistic character and uses the settings skillfully to serve as the stage for the development of Paul’s character. As the physical settings change, from Paul’s high school in Pittsburgh, to Carnegie …show more content…
The premise for her story is said to be based on her experience with two boys in her classes (Sirridge.). At the onset of the story, Paul is confronted by his teachers at his school. The reader is given the first impression of Paul who shows up “suave and smiling” according to Cather’s description. (Cather 195). With a red carnation in his overcoat, this setting establishes a focus on the resentment Paul feels towards the formal establishment of school. He lies to the faculty and does not show sincere remorse for his inappropriate behavior in school. The foundation of the school and the notion of authority are considered revolting to Paul. According to Triolo’s literary review, “His teachers felt this afternoon that his whole attitude was symbolized by his shrug and his flippantly red carnation flower, and they fell upon him without mercy, his English teacher leading the pack” (Triolo 107). The teachers unpitying attitude towards Paul supports the setting chosen to express Paul’s feelings of rejection of school and authority. Later in the story, Paul depicts the school-room “as more than ever repulsive; the bare floors and naked walls; the prosy men who never wore frock coats, or violets in their button-holes…" (Cather 202). …show more content…
The fantasy for Paul is played out in his role as an usher at Carnegie Hall and in his experiences in New York at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel. The realism for Paul exists at his school, in his home and in his final act of suicide. Cather’s ability to place the reader into these different settings, both in the fantastical and in the real world, creates a dramatic visual flow. Her choice of settings and the vivid descriptions and language convey what Paul saw and how he felt. Within each setting, a different perception of the protagonist’s character is revealed. As was shown in the many examples cited, the story reveals an explicit connection between the settings and the revelation of the protagonist’s true narcissistic
Show More

Related Documents: Paul's Case By Willa Cather

Paul's Case By Willa Cather Summary

every person dreams of something different, some wanting to live simply, and some to the extreme. Some wanting to live materialistically, and some wanting to live doing things that make them feel good. The short story “Paul’s Case” by Willa Cather represents this idea well. Although Paul’s lifestyle of working at Carnegie Hall, and staying in fancy New York City hotels may seem like something someone would do for show, Paul does it in attempt to find his…

Words 743 - Pages 3

Summary Of Paul's Case By Willa Cather

The world on Cordelia Street did not amuse Paul, he saw it as mundane and boring. The real excitement, through Paul’s point of view, was found in the theater. Throughout the short story “Paul’s Case” by Willa Cather, it was clear that Paul wanted to escape. Paul wanted to live in a more exciting world, opposite of his world on Cordelia Street. Living on Cordelia street was as boring as life could get, every day it was the same routine; the neighbor kids played in the streets on the weekends, the…

Words 437 - Pages 2

Essay about ENG1001 Noor Kamal Assignment2

Environments on the Protagonist In “Paul’s Case” by Willa Cather Kamal Noor TRU ID: T00040004 ENG 1001 Dr. Don. Stanley Dated: April 15, 2015 The different physical and social environments in “Paul’s Case” by Willa Cather profoundly influence the behavior of the protagonist, Paul. The hostility Paul feels at school, his boring social life at home, his dream world in the Carnegie Hall and his final escape to the New York City all contribute to Paul’s isolation from the ordinary world…

Words 751 - Pages 4

Literary Analysis Essay On Paul's Case

by money/desire for power or position. In the story Paul’s Case, by Willa Cather exemplifies the literary criticism economic theory through the main character Paul’s internal self and his life around him. The economic theory is shown in this story by the way Paul has a desire for the nicer things. When learning that the theory has to do with how money can make people feel a certain way, it makes you think about how that was used in Paul’s Case. “His clothes were a trifle outgrown and the tan velvet…

Words 847 - Pages 4

Essay on Willa Cather

Name: Yasmin Siddiqui Professor: Brian Centrone Writing II: Section 106 February 6th, 2014 “Paul’s Case” What clues does Cather provide in her story to suggest Paul is gay? Do you think both Paul and the reader are aware of this? What do you think was Cather's intention when writing this story? Using Stevens' "Introduction to Gay and Lesbian Writing," discuss the significance of "Paul's Case as a piece of gay writing, and how, over 100 years after its publication, it is still relevant. -…

Words 630 - Pages 3

A Rose For Emily Vs. Paul's Case

are victims of their own societies, driving both characters to isolate themselves. In the short stories “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner and “Paul’s Case” by Willa Cather. Emily is isolated by her father who thinks no one is good enough for her. Similarly, Paul isolates himself from his family as well as from people in his school. Emily’s and Paul’s irrational decisions are a result of isolation, a persistent theme in both short stories, and are…

Words 454 - Pages 2

Judgment and Paul Essay

Paul’s Case Paul’s Case was a story in the third person limited written by Willa Cather. Paul’s Case is the story of a young man who struggles with his identity. Paul feels that he knows where he belongs, but his family and teachers refuse to support his choices. Paul struggles with both internal and external conflicts, causing him to be very confused character. To Paul’s family and teachers he comes off as abnormal and strange kid. But Paul feels he is just misunderstood and that no one wants…

Words 491 - Pages 2

Oppression In Barbara Ehrenreich's Life In The Bubble

the glass. Since the person behind the barrier is deemed unfit to do work, they are not considered to be conventional members of society. The main characters of America by Richard Blanco, Nickel and Dimed by Barbara Ehrenreich, and Paul´s Case by Willa Cather all experience a form of oppression on a large scale in America, all making them feel less than a person. This oppression stems from where…

Words 743 - Pages 3

Creativity In Paul's Case

The majority of humans have been following traditions, yet some stand up and go against traditions, which lead to risks. According to Willa Cather in “Paul’s Case”, the protagonist, who is Paul, got in trouble at school and is waiting for his dad, until he decides to go against traditions which leads to his death. In “Paul’s Case”, Cather uses a third person direct limited omniscient and a physical integral setting to prove a point moving away from traditions creates creativity but also may lead…

Words 448 - Pages 2

Identity Issues In Chinua Achebe's Things Fall Apart

To understand why the main characters of Things Fall Apart, by Chinua Achebe; Wuthering Heights, by Emily Brontë; Frankenstein, by Mary Shelley; and, Paul’s Case, by Willa Cather, all have issues with their identity, one needs to look further into their upbringing and their surroundings. For Heathcliff, the Monster, and Okonkwo, they all suffer identity issues because of how they were brought up in this world. For Paul, it was less about how he was brought up and more about how he felt as he got…

Words 589 - Pages 3