Pretrial Identification

Words: 427
Pages: 2
Open Document
The police use many different methods to identify potential suspects and besides the concerns of self-incrimination and right to counsel there is also the concern of how reliable the technique is (Hall, 2014). Pretrial identifications are based on an individual’s perception of an incident (Hall, 2014). So, if five witnesses were identifying a potential suspect from a lineup, they all could have perceived the details of that incident differently and causing an unreliable identification (Hall, 2014). The amount of time from the incident to the lineup can have a dramatic factor in the reliability of the identification (Hall, 2014). The more time that goes by, the more unreliable a pretrial identification can be. Also, each witness or victim …show more content…
Supreme Court case, United States v. Wade, revealed the following revelation. “The identification of strangers is proverbially untrustworthy….A major factor contributing to the high incidence of miscarriage of justice from mistaken identification has been the degree of suggestion inherent in the manner in which the prosecution presents the suspect to witness for pretrial identification” (Hall, 2014, p. 506). The fact is that these suggestions are not just conducted intentionally, but they also can be unintentional (Hall, 2014). A pretrial identification that I would find to be unduly suggestive would include the types of photos used in a photographic array. If I were the prosecution, and had three witnesses and one victim to identify two suspects using a photo array, the types of photos I showed in the array would have a significant impact on how suggestive the technique is. For example, if all the photos of the potential suspects were displayed using their mug shots, which displayed these individuals in black and white striped jail uniforms while the other photos showed individuals in civilian cloths being free in society, I believe that would be too suggestive of who is guilty. Also, if the two suspects were white males in their mid-twenties and the photos used in the array only had the two suspects photos while the rest where black males in their mid-forties, this would also be too suggestive of who the witnesses are to
Show More

Related Documents: Pretrial Identification

Essay race and ethnicity in prosecution first edition

Research Findings ..................................................................................... 7 Initial Screening ........................................................................................................................ 7 Pretrial Release and Bail Procedure…

Words 9859 - Pages 40

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Artificial Intelligence

This is already being implemented by state judges in New Jersey, who are now using the Public Safety Assessment to assist in making pretrial decisions about defendants. Moreover, Noory Bechor, a commercial lawyer tired of the fact that 80 percent of his work was spent reviewing contracts, designed LawGeex, a platform for automatized contract review. On LawGeex, users upload a contract…

Words 1276 - Pages 6

Essay about acc 4435

Unit 5—Overview of the Federal Rules of Evidence The law of evidence is a set of rules and principles that govern the admissibility of evidence into various types of judicial and administrative proceedings. Evidence is any matter, verbal, physical or electronic that can be used to support the existence of a factual proposition. One of its main purposes is to protect the jury from being misled. There are two basic categories of evidence, direct and circumstantial. Within these general groups…

Words 8538 - Pages 35

Essay on Final Project

Final Project Whitney Polen Introduction to Forensic Psychology FPSY 6101/FPSY 5101/PSYC 8101 January 2, 2015 Heather Morris Unit 11 Introduction This…

Words 2962 - Pages 12

Molecular Evidence Of HIV-1 Transmission In A Criminal Case

one published study rejected a hypothesis of transmission between a Baltimore surgeon and one of his patients (12). Because of the rapid rate of evolution of HIV-1, phylogenetic analysis of HIV-1 DNA sequences is a powerful tool for the identification of closely related viral strains that may be used to infer the transmission between individuals. In the case of the State of Louisiana vs. Richard J. Schmidt, the prosecution argued successfully that the methods of genomic DNA isolation, PCR…

Words 5777 - Pages 24

Essay about Definitions: Health Care Practitioners

profession as they function as individuals in society. Protocol: A code prescribing correct behavior in a specific situation, such as a situation arising in a medical office. Courtesy: The practice of good manners. Compassion: The identification with and understanding of another's situation, feelings, and motives. Common Sense: Sound practical judgment. Critical Thinking: The ability to think analytically, using fewer emotions and more rationality. Chapter 3 (pg.55-78) Licensure:…

Words 2957 - Pages 12

The Duke Lacrosse Team And The Prosecutor

MGT5019 Ethics in Business Assignment # 8 Assignment 8 Signature Assignment – The Duke Lacrosse Team and the Prosecutor Faculty Use Only <Faculty comments here> <Faculty Name> <Grade Earned> <Writing Score> <Date Graded> Table of Contents Learner: Stanley Coniglio 1 Assignment 8 Signature Assignment – The Duke Lacrosse Team and the Prosecutor 3 Introduction 4 Impact on Stakeholders 5 The Race Factor 6 Elitism and the Rush to Condemn 7 Further Persecution from Duke University…

Words 2934 - Pages 12

Americas First Serial Killers Essay example

FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY | H.H HOLMES | AMERICAS FIRST SERIAL KILLER | | Kevin Hutter | 10/20/2011 | H.H HOLMES, THE FIRST AMERICAN SERIAL KILLER, IN THE FOLLOW RESEARCH PAPER WE WILL BE LOOKING AT PSYCHOLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF HIS CRIMES TROUGH HIS EARLY CHILDHOOD TILL HIS EXECUTION IN THE LATE 1800’S | Herman Webster Mudgett, better known under the alias of Dr. Henry Howard Holmes, was one of the first documented American serial killers in the modern sense of the term. Mudgett was born…

Words 2911 - Pages 12