Sherman Anti-Trust Act Against Labor Unions

Words: 892
Pages: 4
Open Document
The government further supported this theory by applying the Sherman Anti-Trust Act against labor unions. The Sherman Anti-trust Act was originally passed to break up monopolies rather than unions, but it was invoked mainly against unions to hurt their power. The justification for this was explained as it was stated “combinations are condemned, not only when they take the form of trusts, but in whatever form found, if they be in restraint of trade”. The failure of the unions’ strikes, along with the involvement of the federal government in these affairs proved there was a negative attitude of unions from the government. The violence and anarchy that was associated with socialist unions, spread the common “anti-union” sentiment, not just within …show more content…
In 1935 the Wagner Act was established, which provided more federal protection for unions, by legalizing union membership in the U.S and giving unions the power to compel employers to recognize and bargain with legitimate unions. In 1947 the Taft-Hartley Act, designed to amend a lot of the Wagner Act, was passed. The Taft-Hartley Act made closed shops, workplaces, (where being part of a union was a condition to being hired) illegal, and allowed states to pass “right-to-work” laws, prohibiting union shops (in which workers would have to join a union after being hired). It also allowed the president to issue an order that any labor union strikes which threatened national safety or health, could not be carried out. Although many laborers tried to repeal the act, the Taft-Hartley Act stayed in effect until 1959 when the Landrum-Griffin Act amended some of its features. The Act damaged weaker unions and made it more difficult to organize workers who had never been part of a labor union before- esp. women, minorities, and most workers in the south. Although the popular sentiment toward labor unions changed from a positive to negative one in the 1930’s and 40’s, by the …show more content…
CEO and executive compensation is flourishing, while the middle class suffers from layoffs, unemployment and stagnant wages. Support of labor unions has greatly increased since the establishment of the first labor unions however current union agendas still include increasing wages, raising the standard of living for the working class, ensuring safe working conditions, and increasing benefits for both workers and their families. At the start of the labor movement, almost all middle-class Americans were anti-union, while today most liberals and democrats tend to be pro-union, while republicans and conservatives are usually more anti-union. Even with this growth of support from democrats, there are still many Americans who don’t see the benefits of labor unions. As recently as August, Governor Chris Christie of New Jersey said that the American Federation of Teachers, the second-largest teachers union, deserves a “punch in the face” and called it the “single most destructive force in public education.” Christie claims that the teachers union only cares about higher wages and benefits, but not about the children they are educating. Christie has often disagreed with public employee unions, but he has a particularly poor relationship with teachers unions, frequently protesting their pensions and health care benefits. He has previously called these unions “political thugs,” and he has had
Show More

Related Documents: Sherman Anti-Trust Act Against Labor Unions

The Major Anti-trust Laws and Their Impact on Professional Sports Essay

Antitrust and labor issues in sports addresses how labor issues have affected sports and how courts have treated the application of antitrust rules to the sports industry, particularly to the situation involving a professional sports union that negotiates with owners of a league. While the concepts of antitrust and labor law are often considered distinct subjects on their own, in the sports industry, these areas of the law are quite often interrelated. This paper will outline the key antitrust laws…

Words 1392 - Pages 6

Monopolies In The Progressive Era

into action to get these trusts complaisant. In 1890, the first federal act was passed, known as the Sherman Anti-Trust Act. This act was written by John Sherman and basically expressed that elimination of competitors by monopolies and trusts were unlawful. Unfortunately, this act was poorly written, and many people had a hard time understanding or enforcing this act due to the lack of clarity. To help strengthen/clarify the Sherman Anti-Trust Act, the Clayton Antitrust Act was implemented in 1914…

Words 237 - Pages 1

Progressive Reformers Dbq

the progressive movement was successful in bring federal attention to issues such as monopolies and trusts, the working conditions in factories and the women’s rights movement. Strong reformers and the support from active presidents like Roosevelt and Wilson encouraged the progressive movement to flourish and pass bills and amendments, but when Wilson declared that America was to go to war against Germany in 1917, the movement which should have continued…

Words 1280 - Pages 6

The Populist Movement

Greenback Party, and the Union Labor Party, its views were centered around the benefit of farmers, anti-monopoly beliefs, and the reform of labor laws. Moreover, it was composed of many angry farmers…

Words 974 - Pages 4

APUSH Chapter 24 Key Terms And People To Know Essay

Commerce Act: prohibited rebates and pools and required the railroads to publish their rates openly. Forbade unfair discrimination against shippers and outlawed charging more for a short haul than a large one. SET UP ICC to administer and enforce the Act. 3. Vertical integration: pioneered by Carnegie; combining into one organization all phases of manufacturing from mining to marketing 4. Horizontal integration: allying with competitors to monopolize a given market; Rockefeller 5. Trust: mechanism…

Words 487 - Pages 2

Monopolies Dbq Analysis

government policy in favor of their interests. Furthermore, since monopolies were wealthy and powerful, they had great control over the Senate, as Document D depicts. The government did not interfere with monopolies until 1890, with the Sherman Anti-trust act that prohibited trusts. However, not all the owners of big businesses had an evil intent with their influence. For example, Carnegie believed in charity and that wealth comes with a responsibility of social obligation, as he explains in Document E. Big…

Words 322 - Pages 2

Fortunate Son Essay

widespread perception backed to Congress’s passing of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act in 1890. The Sherman-Antitrust Act allowed the Government to initiate accounts against trusts and monopolies to disband them. Anyone starting such groups was subjected to fines of $5,000 and one year in jail. Persons and businesses going through struggling losses because of monopolies were allowed to sue in court for triple the amount of damages. The Sherman-Antitrust Act was intended to reinstate competition but was lightly…

Words 1746 - Pages 7

Inequalities During The Progressive Era

The Chinese Exclusion Act was the first law passed by Congress that excluded an entire group based on race. A major supporter of this legislation was James Phelan. Phelan, as well as most Americans, saw the Chinese as a “vastly inferior civilization in completion with our own” (Phelan, “Excluded”) due to their tendency to drink and gamble. Inequality from Americans towards non-Americans was extremely evident in the Imperialist Era. Americans resisted Imperialism with the Anti-Imperialist League which…

Words 1062 - Pages 5

Progressive Era Dbq

hunts down “bad trusts.” He was the first president to defend the population against monopolies and to…

Words 578 - Pages 3

Essay On The Cult Of True Womanhood

domesticity, and submissiveness. American men used this attitude towards women to restrain women from getting involved in politics. During this time, there was a common belief that industrialization made men feminine. With the switch from manual labor on the frontier to office jobs, working class men felt a loss of masculinity. Therefore, men fought to preserve their masculinity by imposing the Cult of True Womanhood which closely corresponded with Muscular Christianity. Muscular Christianity attempted…

Words 1529 - Pages 7