The Giver Dystopian Analysis

Words: 677
Pages: 3
Open Document
No one is perfect, and everyone makes mistakes. Yes, we tend to get down on ourselves when we make a mistake, but we have people around to make us feel better. Imagine living in a society where the committee criticizes people for every mistake, and punishment is given with whips, lectures, and even death. The citizens of the community don’t have choice, love, and freedom. In the book The Giver, by Lois Lowry, Jonas’ community is living in a dystopian society. The rules that the committee makes to try to achieve perfection, the way they hide memories from their people, and the killing of innocent newborns due to their imperfections makes the “world” that Jonas is living in dystopian. The community is dystopian because of the rules that the …show more content…
We know all about the generations back and back and back, and about the events that happened. Picture living in a place where only stories from your generations are familiar to you, and you only get the knowledge the committee chooses to share with you. Also, the community needs a Receiver to keep the memories away. The Receiver is “‘the one chosen to lift the burden of the memories from the whole community’… ‘And that’s the real reason that the Receiver is vital to them, and so honored’” (113). The committee is selfish, and guilty of having fear. They want to have nothing to do with the memories, and they make others deal with the pain and loneliness of having to keep it to themselves. Utopian isn’t the word to use to describe this society, because of the way that they take away joy through the …show more content…
However, not one person has succeeded. So why should they now? Jonas’ community is dystopian because they have so many rules to try to achieve perfection, they take away memories from the people, and they penalize innocent newborns and others because of the differences they have. The society is trying to achieve the impossible by doing terrible things, and controlling people. This book is important for 6th graders to read because it teaches people the true effects of trying to achieve perfection. Since you’ve learned about Jonas’ dystopian society, is it safe to say that there is no such thing as
Show More

Related Documents: The Giver Dystopian Analysis

Step 2 Secondary Sources Essay

1. Dave Astor - Why do we like dystopian novels? http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dave-astor/why-do-we-like-dystopiannovels_b_1979301.html A large chunk of the novels we read in school are classified under dystopian novels, needless to say many of the world’s greatest books are related to or based on the idea of dystopia. Examples of some of these great dystopian pieces are 1984, The Giver, Brave New World, and Fahrenheit 451, which is actually the main piece I chose for my ISU. That being said,…

Words 685 - Pages 3

Ecofeminest Perspective In Blade Runner

society negatively influences the relations of humans and nature as conveyed in BR-DC, thus proving my hypothesis. The Critical text “Flesh Curtain: The Future of Industrial Oppression in Blade Runner”, written by Paige Eggebrecht explores a Marxist analysis of BR-DC. The futuristic society in the film BR-DC reveals how corruption infiltrates when the distribution of power is shared unequally among societal parties. The Tyrell corporation is prominently conveyed as a clear Bourgeoisie,- “an omniscient…

Words 2749 - Pages 11