The Pros And Cons Of Senate Reform

Words: 948

Pages: 4

Open Document

However, given Canada’s claim to democracy and responsible government, an unelected, partisan body is limited in the extent to which it can influence the legislative process. Thus, rather than actively check the power of the House of Commons, the Senate focuses “almost exclusively on the principle of legislative review” (Lusztig, 1995). As previously mentioned, the Senate is lauded for its proficiency in legislative review, however, a more legitimate Senate might be entrusted with other functions as well. For many critics, a truly legitimate Senate is an elected Senate. While this proposal certainly addresses the issue of legitimacy, given the failure of previous constitutional amendments, it is of questionable feasibility. However, not all Senate reform necessarily requires constitutional changes. Senators themselves might take measures to increase transparency, such as …show more content…
Such an act presents no legal challenges and would alleviate the perception of the Senate as a distant and elitist institution. Moreover, the perception of legitimacy could be reinforced by the depoliticization of the appointments process, ensuring “that highly qualified and more diverse voices are appointed” (Burton & Patten, 2015). Such changes, while significant, pose no legal challenges. In fact, many considerations of Senate reform find “if the federal government was willing to act unilaterally on select issues and the Senate was prepared to pursue self-reform” constitutional amendments would be unnecessary to achieve the kind of legitimacy the Senate ought to have in order to function properly (Burton & Patten, 2015). As the Senate gains legitimacy, some suggest that it ought to assume more responsibilities, for example a more equitable representation of Canada’s regions. Given the diversity of Canada’s electorate, one might expect that the interests of voters differ considerably. The

The Pros And Cons Of The Affordable Care Act

House of Representatives' chief legislative a health reform debate. Then Obama administration devoted much of its time to reform the health care system. Then The House of Representatives' chief legislative proposal during the health reform debated. The Senate passed an alternative health care bill. Final the Affordable Care Act was signed on March 23, 2010, by President Barack Obama. I recall watching the episode on television. There are pros and con resulting in this law just like any law. Despite…

Words 253 - Pages 2

Reformation Of Senate Bill 427

Reformation of Senate Bill 427 Legislative Summary Abstract In August 2013 the 83rd Texas Legislature passed Senate Bill 427, which amended Human Resources Code 42.056 and 43.004 by adding FBI fingerprint check requirements for persons ages 14 years old and older who are affiliated with general residential operations, child-placing agencies, independent foster home, and independent foster group homes who were previously required to have a Department of Public…

Words 645 - Pages 3

PS Senate House Essay

This paper will explore top leaders roles, their job descriptions and take a look into committees and issues these people are representing. As we take a look from behind the scenes, we are able to note why parties are so important in representing the Senate or the House of Representatives and the struggles of the many issues that each politician deals with during their elective terms. Being knowledgeable is the first step in knowing what our representatives are advocating for and if we disagree, it is…

Words 2061 - Pages 9

Persuasion, Teenagers, Party Identification And Call Of Duty

seeing different billboards. The most recent election for congressional seats is a prime example of how different tactics were used to persuade the masses in different parts of the country ultimately increasing republican seats in the house and the senate. So, in lamest terms persuasion as defined by Merriam-Webster, “the act of causing people to do or believe something: the act or activity of persuading people” (Merriam-Webster). The relevance in studying “persuasion” in political psychology is the…

Words 2263 - Pages 10

The Benefits Of Marijuana

doing much more harm than good. Canada should definitely reform its laws regarding marijuana. Rather than criminalizing or decriminalizing marijuana altogether, marijuana should be made legal only for adults over the age of eighteen but prohibited while driving. Such reforms to marijuana laws can create benefits for society including decreased crime rates, improved Canadian economy, and helpful for medical purposes. Canada needs to reform its laws regarding marijuana in order to decrease the crime…

Words 1287 - Pages 6

body of legislation for year round schooling Essay

BODY OF LEGISLATION How could Cape Henlopen School District Implement a Year-Round Educational Program? Section 1: All Schools in the Cape Henlopen School District will be mandated to implement year-round schooling, in order to give students “Academic Superiority”. Implementation Steps • Select schools and grade levels. • Establish a process for resolving issues. • Construct a "Pert Chart" for organizing issues, time lines, and responsibilities. • Meet consultation requirements and November…

Words 1245 - Pages 5

Assembling Your Policy Brief

Domestic Product is growing and it is continuing to grow. After reviewing several reports I will try to recount some of the assembling brief policy of the PPACA Act and other my thoughts on the subject. In March 2010, the 111th congress passed health reform legislation the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, as amended by the health care and Education Reconciliation 2010 Act (www.crs.gov). Jointly referred to as PPACA, the law increases access to health insurance coverage, increase federal private…

Words 2232 - Pages 9

Xiv: Ulysses s. Grant and Southern States Essay

XIV. Reconstruction, 1863 – 1877 XV. Reconstruction, 1863 – 1877 Though slavery was abolished, the wrongs of my people were not ended. Though they were not slaves, they were not quite free. No man can be truly free whose liberty is dependent upon the thought, feeling, action of others, and has no means in his own hands for guarding, protecting, defending, and maintaining his liberty. Frederick Douglass, 1882 The silencing of the cannons of war left the victorious United States…

Words 5288 - Pages 22

Ap Gov Review

state reps in Philly. Originally going to amend Articles but instead got rid of them Great Compromise- called for one house in which each state would have an equal vote (the Senate) and a second house (the House of Representatives) in which representation would be based on population. Created a bicameral legislature Senate would be chosen by state legislature House of Reps. Would be directly elected by public (eligibility of whom could vote left up to the states) 3/5 Compromise- allowed southern…

Words 3457 - Pages 14

Principles Of The Australian Parliamentary System

(currently Sir Peter Cosgrove). Roles include granting royal assent to bills, establishing sitting times for parliament, dissolving the House of Representatives at election time, and appointing ministers. Upper House (Senate) The Upper House at a Commonwealth level is known as the Senate. It consists of 76 members overall – 12 per state and 2 per territory. This ensures equal representation for the states and therefore equal representation when laws are being considered. It is thus known as the States'…

Words 6752 - Pages 28