The Structural Strain Theory

Words: 1072
Pages: 5
Open Document
The articles A spate of random, cruel murders, committed by teens - coincidence or a sign? and Wagga Police: We can’t ‘arrest our way’ out of youth crime issues detail a number of deviant acts committed by teens in different areas across Australia. These deviant acts can be explained by four theories of deviance: cultural transmission, structural strain, control theory and labelling theory.

Cultural transmission theory developed by Edwin Sutherland is based on symbolic interactionist view that deviance is learned through interactions with other deviants. It focuses on the age, ratio and intensity; the age of the individual becoming deviant, ratio of deviants to conformists and the intensity of the interactions and relationship between the …show more content…
It explores the anomie that occurs due to the organisation or disorganisation of society; strains placed on the individual by society encourage them to achieve goals by deviant means. The four types of deviance according to this theory are innovation, ritualism, retreatism and rebellion. Innovation occurs when the individual accepts the goal but rejects the means, therefore achieving the goal using deviant means. An example of this is when Ryan Miller and Brad Stevens achieved the goal of possessing and driving a car by “stealing cars and doing drive-bys and stuff” (Guilliatt 2013). Ritualism occurs when the goal is abandoned but the means are continued, losing sight of the objective. Retreatism is when both the goals and means are abandoned and the individual is no longer a functioning part of society, and rebellion occurs when the goals and means are abandoned and replaced with new deviant ones. An example of rebellion is when Miller sets the goal of killing someone because he “Felt like killing someone” (Guilliatt 2013) then achieves it with the disapproved means of stabbing. This theory explains the high rate of crime in Glenfield Park as it is identified as a disadvantaged area that is well on its way to “lose a generation to the judicial system” (ABC 2015). This theory fails to explain how Miller and Stevens became …show more content…
It outlines that people who feel attachment (relationships with others), commitment (application to genuine goals), involvement (engagement in legitimate activities) and belief (values shared with dominant society) are less likely to deviate due to their emotional ties to other people and society. This theory helps explain how Miller became deviant because his parents marriage was described as “acrimonious… their continuing hostility had exposed him to domestic violence” and his father was later described to have “paid scant attention” to his activities (Guilliatt 2013), this means he would not have felt the attachment to his parents that could have prevented him from deviating. He would have also not felt involved with any social activities as he was described as a ‘social outcast, bordering retardation’. Miller’s lack of intelligence and unusual thoughts meant he did not share many values with larger society, another likely cause for his deviant behaviour. Young people in Glenfield Park would likely not feel any commitment to goals because of their lack of education, which would cause them to deviate. This theory explains the cause for deviance but not why the deviance takes the particular form it does; it clarifies why Miller became deviant but not why his deviance occurred in the form of violence and
Show More

Related Documents: The Structural Strain Theory

Agnew's General Strain Theory

take on anomie and strain theory, and focusing their lens on “street” crime in high poverty neighborhoods. The theory direct our focus to how society puts pressure on individuals to achieve socially accepted goals (such as the American Dream), though they lack the means, which then leads to breakdowns in, detachment from, norms. They argue that some substitute “counter norms,” “stretching” norms, and “innovate” to achieve their goals through deviance and crime. Despite these theories specifically focusing…

Words 1717 - Pages 7

Strain: Sociology and Social Structure Essay

Strain Theory There are four different varieties of strain theory. The first is anomie theory originally proposed by proposed by Dr. Robert Merton. The second theory is institutional anomie theory proposed by Steven F. Messner and Richard Rossenfeld. The third theory is general strain theory proposed by Robert Agnew. Finally relative deprivation theory originally proposed by James Davis, next to tackle this subject was Walter Garrison Runciman, followed by Ted Robert Gurr, and finally by Faye…

Words 2602 - Pages 11

The Labeling Theory: The Role Of Deviance In Society

There are many theories as to why individuals strike out against society’s expectations; these individuals are known as “deviants.” Theories such as The Labeling Theory, The Subcultural Theory, The Control Theory, and The Anomie Theory as well as Structural Functionalism all focus on why deviance exists and how individuals end up falling under such an incredulous category. The Labeling Theory is the concept of labeling individuals to a significant group. By being…

Words 1430 - Pages 6

Effects Of Internet Deviant

Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines fraud in three ways; a crime of using dishonest methods to take something valuable from another person, a person who pretends to be what he or she is not in order to trick people and a copy of something that is meant to look like the real thing in order to trick people. Combine all three definitions, the internet, a few good hackers and one has a recipe for the worst thieves on the planet today. The internet is an amazing source of information, a place where people…

Words 1701 - Pages 7

Essay on Crime: Sociology and Lower Class Crime

suggests that crime and deviance can be explained through the `strain to anomie' theory. This is where it is near impossible to achieve socially approved goals which ends in frustration and the individual turning to criminal means in order to get what they want, which is a quick fox answer. This theory has two main elements under lining it: these are structural and cultural. Deviance is the result of strain between these factors. Merton argues that an individual’s position…

Words 624 - Pages 3

Criminology and Immigrants Essay

does the video you selected support Social Theory? I selected this particular video that supports social theory because it is a major problem in the United States. With the social structure theory, criminologists believe the reason people commit crimes is because they are subject to crime by their tough lifestyles. Criminologists believe it supports the hypothesis, meaning crime rates may vary on based on social structure. This also supports the social theory of society influences changes the way people…

Words 944 - Pages 4

Anomie Strain Theory

applied the theory. Cloward and Ohlin’s Differential Opportunity Theory is applied to understanding gangs and gang behavior, as read in the text. According to the application of this theory to gang research, what must be considered in understanding criminal learning environments of gangs? According to Robert Agnew’s General Strain Theory, strain leads to anger and frustration which leads to deviant behavior, but not all individuals respond to strain with crime and deviance. What types of strain are most…

Words 1381 - Pages 6

FUNCTIONAL SUBCULTURAL THEORIES Essay

Assess the usefulness of functionalist and sub-culture theories in our understanding of crime and deviance today (21 marks) Durkeim … Social Solidarity – achieved by society having 2 main mechanisms 1) Socialisation – instils a shared culture of society’s norms & values and act in the way society requires 2) Social Control – rewards for conformity and punishments for deviance (helps people behave the way society wants you to) Society fulfils 2 important positive functions - 1) Boundary Maintenance…

Words 614 - Pages 3

The School Of Thought Surrounding Posit Essay

holistic view to explain why and how crime occurs, in attempts to prevent criminal behaviour. Subcultural theories explain deviance in terms of the subculture of a social group, believing that certain groups and cultures develop norms and values that may be considered deviant to other groups. The Strain and Control theories have both linked crime with conformism, yet the Strain theory aligns itself with the belief that crime occurs due to the need to conform. Robert K. Merton outlined a different…

Words 3691 - Pages 15

African American and High School Essay

dropouts between African American males, but there are also other factors that can pay an even bigger role in the effect on academic success. Also research shows the dropout rate differs between races and gender. However, in my research I have found theories to why African American males dropout of high school, resulting in the gap African American males graduating high school. It is my goal to reliably answer the following questions: Given the data of Oakland Technical High School does the location…

Words 1862 - Pages 8