Thoreau's View Of Civil Disobedience

Words: 791
Pages: 4
Open Document
Since the dawn of civilization, human beings have been questioning the honesty of the establishments under which they are governed. Henry David Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience is a prime example of this mindset. In his dissertation, Thoreau expresses his disdain for what the American government has become during his time, as well his disbelief at the complacency of the populace in the face of such unbridled injustice. Through his speculations on the people themselves, the prevalence of morality in society, and the duty of mankind to resist corrupt behavior, Thoreau develops his view that the best government is one which governs least. Thoreau initially makes his view of the role of government clear by explaining that the power of society should …show more content…
He believes that the populace knows what is right and wrong, but has surrendered its collective conscience for the sake of security. He writes, “When I converse with the freest of my neighbors, I perceive that, whatever they may say about the magnitude and seriousness of the question, and their regard for public tranquility, long and the short of the matter is, that they cannot spare the protection of the existing government, and they dread the consequences to their property and families of disobedience to it” (Part 2, Paragraph 11). This excerpt reveals that the citizens are aware that disobedience may be the solution, but they fear the consequences that will result from taking action. Thoreau condemns this behavior, explaining that action is the only way to assert the majority’s will over the government. He explains that the knowledge of right and wrong is rooted within everyone , and that the system’s design has forced many to abandon their morality for the sake of conformity. Simply voting and hoping that change will come about is not enough, in his opinion; instead, the people must take charge and make a tangible stand against what they know is unjust treatment. Only in this way will the government be reduced to its proper place as a servant of the people, rather than the …show more content…
He states, “I think we should be men first, and subjects afterward” (Part 1, Paragraph 4), meaning that people’s duty to their conscience takes precedence over their obligation to follow the law. Thoreau acknowledges the fact that a respect for the law is inherent in many, but that this can become a hindrance when the law is developed from unjust foundations. When this occurs, he writes, the citizens have a duty to their country to overthrow the existing system and reestablish a better one. In Thoreau’s mind, a better government would be one that does not exert any sort of tyranny whatsoever. It should simply exist to serve the people, not to govern their every action as if it is dealing with a herd of sheep.
Henry David Thoreau’s Civil Disobedience sheds a new light on the role of the government in America. According to Thoreau, the role of the people, the prevalence of morality in society, and the duty of mankind to resist corrupt authorities all find their root in the fact that the best government is one which governs least. Thoreau reminds the people of his time that they are the true foundation of the nation, and that the government should exist simply to reflect their collective will as American
Show More

Related Documents: Thoreau's View Of Civil Disobedience

Henry David Thoreau's Argument For Improving The Government

with the government's choices. Thoreau, a famous writer for his piece of, "Civil Disobedience", an argument for disobedience to an unjust state. Thoreau's interest in change, and natural decay; also trying to find the true essential needs for life. Civil Disobedience should be an option for improving the government rather than abolishing it. “I ask for, not at once no government, but at once a better government”. Thoreau’s direction for the government is to not get rid of it, however to improve the…

Words 1199 - Pages 5

Henry David Thoreau's Accomplishments

however his sole aim was in observation of nature. His essays, books and journal entries show his experiences in nature. They also give us philosophical and practical approaches on many subjects, including human nature towards nature and life. Thoreau’s achievements have influenced world renown philosophers and leaders including, Mahatma Ghandi and Martin Luther King Jr. Combining several different philosophies including Greek and Asian, his literature and actions cause to reflect upon…

Words 585 - Pages 3

The Role Of Transcendentalism In Henry David Thoreau's Walden

My topic for this project was Thoreau and his novel Walden. I had previously read Thoreau’s “Civil Disobedience,” and had an understanding of him as a person, Walden was brand new to me. It did not surprise me that Thoreau found spiritual meanings behind ant battles and sought out religion from the perspective of a loon. However, his role within the Transcendentalist movement in America surprised me. I had no idea that he was that involved within that particular movement. As my group spent a vast…

Words 366 - Pages 2

Henry David Thoreau And Ralph Waldo Emerson

philosophers who preached self reliance as well as nonconformity (Brewton). One of Henry David Thoreau's most famous work "Civil Disobedience" entails on what grounds an individual should disobey the government.…

Words 857 - Pages 4

Examples Of Undermining The Rule Of Law

reservation, break the law, but rather to damage a law’s reputation. In these circumstances, undermining the law is only justified when a group of people can affect a significant change without bloodshed. From Gandhi’s nonviolent resistance in India to the civil rights movement in the United States, peaceful movements have become key elements of political change. Undermining the rule of law peacefully is justified when conventional politics are not responsive in situations that violate justice, human rights…

Words 1756 - Pages 8

Civil Disobedience Rhetorical Analysis Essay

In “Civil Disobedience” David Thoreau reveals many interesting points of views on subject matters that relate to the idea of the government ruling over the people. David Thoreau’s ideas were so well received with the public that they are still used in modern society as the use of helping the minority achieve goals that might otherwise not be achievable. For example, Martin Luther King Jr. used David Thoreau’s ideas to help gather large groups of people to do exactly what “civil disobedience” means…

Words 1003 - Pages 5

Thoreau Civil Disobedience Rhetorical Analysis

In “Civil Disobedience”, Thoreau criticizes not only a useless government but also incompetent citizens who sit idly by while the government does as it pleases. Thoreau’s direct piece calls for inherent human action to comply with the intelligence of man to stand against an unfitting government. Thoreau’s analysis of government and the way its run sets the stage for his argument. He criticizes the dwindling integrity of “the government itself, which is only the mode which the people have chosen…

Words 628 - Pages 3

Transcendentalism: Ralph Waldo Emerson And Henry David Thoreau

philosophical and social movement that developed in New England around 1836 in reaction to rationalism. Influenced by romanticism, Platonism, and Kantian philosophy, it taught that divinity pervades all nature and humanity, and its members held progressive views on feminism and communal living. Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau were central figures. Explanation- A movement where a bunch of bandwagoners decided to rebel against the intellectual days where they were finding out why things happened…

Words 639 - Pages 3

Comparing Thoreau's Letter Of Civil Disobedience And Martin Luther King

Thoreau’s letter of civil disobedience and Martin Luther King’s letter from jail were on some aspects two different things and looked to serve two different purposes when you look at the letters themselves and the stories or backgrounds behind each of them. An example being that Thoreau’s letter seems more geared towards trying to put down or frown upon the government in his writings as many times throughout his writing this is illustrated and reinforced. You can find many examples all throughout…

Words 539 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience And Thoreau's Analysis

yet life in these our bones, we will never comply with your arbitrary laws” (Gandhi). This statement from Mohandas K. Gandhi’s “from On Civil Disobedience,” is stating his belief that civil disobedience does not have to be a violent act, but a peaceful and public protest. In many ways Gandhi is similar to Henry David Thoreau, who wrote “from Civil Disobedience,” and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., who wrote “from Letter from Birmingham City Jail.” Thoreau argues that people should go against governmental…

Words 938 - Pages 4