Utilitarian Lens

Words: 405

Pages: 2

Open Document

Strengths: The topic of comparing and contrasting the eras of Cold War to Post Cold War, or as Sadovnik (2014) writes, the “War on Terror” (p.50) and the issue of information leaked to the media is fascinating. That it is examined through a utilitarian lens is also interesting. The author does a good job of defending her thesis. I believe she proves her thesis. She argues that there is merit in journalists publishing leaked politically sensitive information, because it helps the public advocate for change within a society. The tie-in of the ethical standards of journalism and linking this to utilitarianism is strong. The literature review appears thorough and the author is adept at describing the Pentagon Papers, the Snowden leaked documents and detailing their respective importance. I read this in one sitting, which is a testament to how engaging a read it was. …show more content…
When I think of Benthum I think of the Panopticon, which he designed. I have difficulty reconciling this cruel form of incarceration as “for the greater good.” Also, in utilitarianism the issue of “treating everyone the same” is fraught with difficulty. I argue that those in historically marginalized groups are not treated the same as everyone else. To use an example from Orwell’s allegoric novel Animal Farm, first published in 1945, the phrase, “All animals are equal” (Orwell, 1990, p. 21) eventually became, “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others” (Orwell, 1990, p. 118). Perhaps the author thought that she could have presented additional information about utilitarianism, because when she discusses limitations, she does admit that her own belief about this ethical perspective may have influenced the research. This affirmed my view that utilitarianism has

Ethical Case Study: Working In Groups

In the book Think Communication, Third Edition (2015), interdependence is a necessity when working as a group. (p. 180) Firstly, should Greg have been looking at his problem through the Utilitarian Approach, there was an immediate and apparent chance to reduce harm at the outset of the problem. In not speaking to Natalie about the problem, or by capitulating to the others in that “it would be more trouble than it’s worth to confront her about…

Words 900 - Pages 4

Puna Native American Tribe Case Study

the Relevant Facts? 1. Len Quill has a major in cultural anthropology and is aware of the negative impacts that can come from changing a culture. 2. There is a strong demand for woven baskets by the Puna Native American Tribe by Bob Littman whom owns several art galleries. 3. Len is the only one who can make or break this deal. 4. The Puna Native American Tribe has an opportunity to make a lot of money. 5. Due to the short time frame and knowing the demand that is needed Len knows that men from the…

Words 1223 - Pages 5

Contact Lens: Study on the Consumer Buying Behavior Essays

Submitted By, Arun Ravindran PGP 14/138 Section A Contact Lens: Study on the Consumer Buying Behavior Contents Executive Summary 3 Objective 3 Importance to business and marketing 3 Introduction 4 Types of contact lenses 4 Brands 5 Comparison with Spectacles and Lasik 5 Research Methodology 5 Insights from Secondary Research 6 Insights from Interview and Survey 6 Analysis 6 Hierarchy of Effects: ABC model 7 Consumer Involvement: High Involvement/Emotional…

Words 3001 - Pages 13

Essay on Nestes Corporation Sample Assignment

1.Negligence A. Negligence involves the ability to foresee the consequences of acts and fault for failing to take appropriate actions to avoid the harmful consequences. In this case, there is reasonable foresee ability, which implies that Zonar is responsible for any consequences that they could have reasonably foreseen had they been reasonable. Furthermore, there was actual foreseeability as well, which is that they are responsible for consequences they actually foresaw occurring. First of all,…

Words 4969 - Pages 20

Engineering Fetuses and the Ethical Conflicts Essay

it is made individual and small-scale by bioethicists, genetic engineering is a field that is dedicated to assisting the entirety of the community and improve the country as a whole (Hahn). Hahn also argues that consequentialism falls under a Utilitarian ethical code and…

Words 1978 - Pages 8

Plato's Cave Susan Sontag Analysis

When a photo is taken that moment of time is framed as a definitive thing, something that can be remembered, something that is immortal. Susan Sontag touches on this idea in her essay, “In Plato’s Cave”, as she goes through the pros and cons of photography’s effect on the world. Sontag states “A photograph passes for incontrovertible proof that a given thing happened” expanding on her previous claim that when a person takes a picture, they show their part of the world, their reality (5). What she…

Words 1314 - Pages 6

Journal Article Critique (Amn400 - Consumer Behaviour) Essay

Item 1 - Journal Article Critique Word Count: 944 Words Introduction Thøgersen, Jørgensen & Sandager in their 2012 article Consumer Decision Making Regarding a “Green” Everyday Product” discuss consumer’s interaction with brands through the lens of product differentiation and the effects on involvement in the purchase process. The article examines the consumer behaviour of involvement and develops an understanding qualifying the differences between a high involvement interaction and a simple…

Words 1293 - Pages 6

Essay about Sociology 1301 Lecture notes

Whorf Claimed languages shapes reality Each language has its own distinct symbols Serve as the foundation of reality All languages connect symbols with distinctive emotions Sapir Whorf Thesis: People see and understand the world thru cultural lens of language evidence does not support the notion that language determines reality the way Sapir and Whorf claimed Values Culturally defined standards that people use to decide what is desirable, good, and beautiful and that serve as broad guidelines…

Words 4056 - Pages 17

Essay about Hito Steyerl Too Much World

the flick of a finger. ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊData, sounds, and images are now routinely transitioning beyond screens into a different state of matter.7 They surpass the boundaries of data channels and manifest materially. They incarnate as riots or products, as lens flares, high-rises, or pixelated tanks. Images become unplugged and unhinged and start crowding offscreen space. They invade cities, transforming spaces into sites, and reality into realty. They materialize as junkspace, military invasion, and botched…

Words 4547 - Pages 19

Essay on Midterm Study Guide

1. political economy a structural analysis of how politics, law, and economics influence one another 2. surplus population those who are unemployed or unemployable and are thus considered the "dangerous class"; economically marginal persons; those with little attachment to the conventional labor market and little "stake in conformity"; "marginal classes" 3. slave codes From 1619 to 1865, constituted the criminal law and procedure applied against enslaved Africans. The codes regulated slave life from…

Words 8778 - Pages 36