Van Gogh's The Starry Night

Words: 1283
Pages: 6
Open Document
If asked to identify Van Gogh’s The Starry Night as the original masterpiece or as a deceitful forgery, most of us would not be able to differentiate the real from the replicated. Forgeries have fooled and confounded art enthusiasts throughout the centuries. Thomas Hoving, the author of False Impressions: The Hunt for Big Time Art Fakes, claims that throughout his career approximately 40 percent of the thousands of works he curated were forgeries or misattributed in some way (Hoving, 1996, pg. 24-25). Art forgeries have been given the negative connotation throughout the ages, but it all depends on how one looks at the piece of art. Nonetheless the bigger question in the apparent false history of art may be are these nearly indistinguishable …show more content…
If you define an art “masterpiece” based on aesthetic value, the feeling or emotion it evokes, and if you include in your definition of a masterpiece authenticity or originality, then forgeries come close but may not fit the definition of an art masterpiece. My first criterion for an art “masterpiece” is that the art work should have aesthetic value that captures style, technique, balance, and harmony seamlessly within the work. At first glance a forged piece of art is nearly, if not completely, indistinguishable from the original work. The brush marks, colors, shapes and all the other aesthetic characteristics are intended to be identical in regards to their formal features. Thus, if the forgery is of art that is considered to be aesthetically pleasing than it appears to fulfill this criterion. But the subtlest differences can completely change one’s aesthetic experience. Goodman, in his Book Language of Art says, “Extremely subtle changes can alter the whole design, feeling, or expression of a painting. Indeed, the slightest perceptual differences sometimes matter the most aesthetically; gross physical damage to a fresco may be less consequential than slight but …show more content…
A true artistic masterpiece should be authentic and original. Forged art, being a copy or imitation for deceptions clearly does not meet this criterion. According to Goodman, “Forgers aren’t as great artists as any of the masters since they forge the originality of another artist’s aesthetic uniqueness and originality contribute to aesthetic value and are essential for making an intelligent aesthetic appraisal” (Goodman, 1985). Here Goodman is claiming that by copying another artist you render yourself a sub par artist and therefore the recreation of a masterpiece isn’t a masterpiece at all but a photocopy. The originality of an artist stems from the present time in which the art is created, as well as the limitation and constraints they face. Hoaglund says in his article Originality and Aesthetic Value, “The way in which [the artist] successfully meets the challenge to produce unique works constitutes part of his creativity.” The time period, history, limitations, and pressures that the artist is faced with are unique to the artist and therefore are unique to the artist’s reaction and interpretation of them in his or her artwork. An artist who creates a perfect replication of this cannot claim to have the same originality. As stated a forgeries intention are to deceive, and deception is contrary to authenticity. According to Wreen “a forgery has to be understood as a forged XY… A forged XY isn’t a
Show More

Related Documents: Van Gogh's The Starry Night

Vincent Van Gogh's The Starry Night

Vincent van Gogh, 1989, The Starry Night is a painting that many people are familiar with. To some people the painting would radiate a sense of ease and comfort. Maybe it is because of the swirl of the wave-like clouds or the bright stars that twinkle in the dark blue night sky that gives people a sense of peace. The part of the painting that seemed to be most intriguing is the black like flames that seemed to reach towards the bright night sky that people tend to avoid in the painting. Though many…

Words 336 - Pages 2

Vincent Van Gogh's The Starry Night

Vincent van Gogh uses lines in The Starry Night to grab the audience’s attention and portray his emotions. His use of lines is “emotional and provocative” (Anderson and Carson, 30). According to our textbook, the night sky is painted with thick, swirling lines that surround bright yellow stars, creating a sense of supernatural energy (Anderson and Carson, 30). Van Gogh is actively using lines to convey emotions. This painting is unique among Van Gogh’s paintings. According to vangoghgallery.com…

Words 231 - Pages 1

Vincent Van Gogh's The Starry Night

127 years ago, Vincent van Gogh observed the vast abyss of sky visible from the iron-barred window in his room at the Saint-Paul-de-Mausole lunatic asylum a few hours before the sun crept up from below the horizon. Something about the image delved past the chaotic mess of van Gogh's psychological state and struck a chord with him, inspiring him to create what is now one of the most recognizable paintings of all time - The Starry Night. The Starry Night is one of the most remarkable and breathtaking…

Words 537 - Pages 3

Painted In Vincent Van Gogh's The Starry Night

Painted in 1889, The Starry Night is a landscape painting created by the famous, Vincent Van Gogh. The night sky within the painting is overflowing with sparkling stars, spinning mists, and a brilliant sickle moon. The setting is one that people can identify with and Van Gogh's whirling sky coordinates the viewer's eye around the depiction, with dispersing between the stars and the bending shapes making a dab to-dab effect. In the painting, molded structures are a method for expression and they are…

Words 384 - Pages 2

Art Van Gogh's Starry Night

Van Gogh uses every element of art in his painting, “Starry Night”. The first element of art he uses is Space. He uses space in his painting painting the cypress tree in the foreground of the painting. “The enormous cypress tree in the foreground helps the viewer understand the arrangement of space.” Van Gogh also uses another element of art in his painting, color. He uses color by painting the yellow highlights in the blue sky. “The yellow highlights the yellow highlights in the sky help move your…

Words 206 - Pages 1

Vincent Van Gogh's Starry Night Over The Rhone

mentioned that Van Gogh saw his paintings as his ministry and service. Art was a way for the painter to find a deep connection to his soul and the divine, and the subject matter he chose to portray was often tied to his connotations of Christianity. The Olive Trees (the one painting shown is part of a series) creates a parallel to Christ in the garden of Gethsemane, and further illustrates how the artist interacted with his faith through nature. Starry Night Over the Rhone is one of Van Gogh’s most famous…

Words 1167 - Pages 5

art essay

2015 The Starry night is an oil painting by Dutch past-impressions painter Vincent Van Gogh. The oil painting was created in June, 1889.The visual of the painting shows a view from the east facing a window from his asylum room. The oil canvas painting that’s 73.7x 92.1cm consist of Curving, swirling lines of hills, mountains, and the sky, the brilliantly contrasting blues and yellows, the large flame-like cypress tree and the thickly layered brushstrokes of Vicent Van Gogh’s. In Starry night contoured…

Words 1556 - Pages 7

Van Gogh Essay

Death and Rebirth in Vincent van Gogh’s The Starry Night Perhaps death is not the hardest thing in a painter’s life… Looking at the stars always makes me dream, as simply as I dream over the black dots representing towns and villages on a map. Why, I ask myself, shouldn’t the shining dots of the sky…

Words 300 - Pages 2

Research Paper On Vincent Van Gogh

Many have heard of the great artist Vincent van Gogh. His famed works such as “The Starry Night” and the series of paintings of sunflowers come to mind almost immediately for anyone, including those who have not studied art. His signature brush strokes and theme colors are a big part in what made him a father of the expressionist movement. Van Gogh was one of the most influential figures of post-impressionism in France even though “he sold only one painting during his lifetime” (The Art Story Contributors)…

Words 1866 - Pages 8

Essay Comparing The Lover's Whirlwind And Starry Night

these two beautiful pieces of artwork to compare because to me they are breath taking. The paintings I chose are Starry Night by Vincent Van Gogh and The Lover’s Whirlwind by William Blake. Both of these pieces of artworks are very much alike. The way the spirals wisps on each canvas gives off a sense of depth in the piece. There are also similar colors being used as well. With the Starry Night it seems that the spirals could be taking you somewhere else, just somewhere, anywhere from where you are at…

Words 1049 - Pages 5