Animal Rights Human Wrongs By Tom Regan

Words: 1779
Pages: 8
Open Document
Imagine a world of almost millions of people own a pet or have a professional career taking care of animals. Even though we hunt animals for certain resources, we can still need them for proper goods. People might debate between the two authors about their reasoning. Two of the prominent authors were Tom Regan and Stephan Rose. In both of the article “Animal rights, Human wrongs” by Tom Regan and “Proud to be specialist” by Stephen Rose, two divergent aspects are expressed towards animal rights and medical specimen. In the articles, the author’s shows their consciousness of the problem of animal harm. Rose and Regan propose different types of reasoning why animal should have their rights or used for human survival. Tom Reagan essay, Focus more …show more content…
Stephan Rose confront his audience in his essay and truthfully say, “ I research on animals” which gives him a reason why he justify himself as medical researcher and fights back for other scientists who’s been carried out of their research lab for using animals as specimen (Rose 342). He shows enough evidence that he value his time with coming up with new medicine for people in general besides taking pleasure of harming animals. He also mentions “ takes a term near the heart of many animals rights” which makes a claim he’s “using it make his own case for using animals in research” as evidence he claim that using animals will solve certain issues happening to children without looking for a cure since one is already found. On the other hand, although Regan make a valid argument about animal rights, he still chooses mention this in his essay that’s related to ethos. “Animal Rights, Human wrongs”, Reagan shows he concern about the animals that being harmed that can’t defend themselves and the irreplaceable species that’s being killed for human goods and resources. He states “Why is this to the last remaining members of an irreplaceable species, certainly until recently, possibly at this very moment, by supposedly civilized men? For Candle wax, for soap and oil. For pet food, margarine, fertilizer” (337). He makes a claim that Rose will use animals for unnecessary …show more content…
He wants the industries to stop harming animal and start relating practices to be a halt, knowing that animal’s rights can be justified. As a reader, Regan agrees that animal abuse can be stop and be more concerned than more things. However, Rose’s reasoning is not about animal rights, but how people think. “All the facts shows that most animal righters are really arguing that the closer human beings get to animals, the more attached they will defend their rights and the more rights they should have” (343-344). He makes it clear “that it is we, as humans, who are conferring rights on animals-not the animals themselves” (344). He makes a very good point about animals making rights for themselves, which is really illogical coming from a philosopher who should make more valid reason behind
Show More

Related Documents: Animal Rights Human Wrongs By Tom Regan

Tom Regan Animal Rights

Dog or Human Liability? Tom Regan’s Case for Animal Rights gives a scenario in which there is a group of people and a dog floating on a raft after a shipwreck. A dilemma arises when the survivors realize the raft is sinking rapidly and cannot hold all of its occupants, lest they sink and everyone on board becomes shark bait and dies. There is one solution to save lives, but it requires one person on board to decide between a well trained hunting dog or an antisocial potentially liable human to be…

Words 1398 - Pages 6

Essay about answers q2

greatest good CORRECT all of the above Instructor Explanation: The answer can be found in section 2.1 of Understanding Philosophy Question 2. Question : According to the video “Meet Your Meat”, which of the following is not true of how animals are slaughtered on factory farms Student Answer: They are driven in extreme weather conditions without food or water They are often still conscious while being slaughtered They are often roughly handled and severely injured by the…

Words 1829 - Pages 8

Animal Rights In Animal Testing

Using animals in research and to test the safety of products has been a topic of heated debate for decades. According to data collected by F. Barbara Orlans for her book, In the Name of Science: Issues in Responsible Animal Experimentation, sixty percent of all animals used in testing are used in biomedical research and product-safety testing (62). People have different feelings for animals; many look upon animals as companions while others view animals as a means for advancing medical techniques…

Words 1542 - Pages 7

Animal Rights Research Paper

Seminar 26 April 2013 Animal Rights Everyone has their own opinions on animal rights. Some think animals should have the same rights as humans and some do not. Supporters of animal rights believe that animals have an ‘inherent worth”. They believe that every creature with a will to live has a right to live free from pain and suffering. They believe all animals are unique just like humans. Non-supporters believe animals aren’t as important as humans and use animals for things such as entertainment…

Words 1525 - Pages 7

Dog and Pets Essay

annoying if they are in a reduced space, such as an apartment, some others states that they are unconditional and lovely. Who is right? Those who like pets say that they are as their best friend, even though they cannot speak together. Why people want a pet? I will tell you: because, pets could be a friend, a child, a sister or brother, even they can be a doctor. Animals are such agreeable friends - they ask no questions, they pass no criticisms. (George Eliot) It is often one of the most valued…

Words 833 - Pages 4

Ethics: Same-sex Marriage and People Essay examples

situations. For example, ignorant people only see one side of an issue, which is their own. They are completely unaware of what is going on around them, but that is by choice. Therefore, these people are happy because they are not able to distinguish right from wrong. Ignorance is for the lazy. Many times you hear the famous “if only” phrases after a life changing event or decision has been made. “If only I have known”, “If only I had thought about it more”, “If only I had done this”, “If only I had done…

Words 2293 - Pages 10

Animal Testing Synthesis Promptttt Essay

Animal Testing Synthesis Prompt Madison Beaver Sydney Buchanan Olivia Drake Kaylee Pressley AP ENGLISH LANGUAGE AND COMPOSITION FREERESPONSE QUESTION Internationally, animal testing is used for everything from drugs to cosmetics. Over 100 million animals are tested in US labs every year. Some people believe that animal testing is cruel. Others, however, believe that animal testing is necessary in order to advance medically and test products. Carefully read the following six sources, then synthesize…

Words 5301 - Pages 22

Is Animal Testing Wrong

Animal Experimentation : Is It Wrong To Experiment On Animals? There is an ongoing battle between animal rights activists and scientific researchers on the topic of Animal Experimentation. A scientific researcher, Gina Solomon, said, “While we would prefer not to sacrifice a single laboratory rat, we believe that the sacrifice is warranted to protect our children and future generations.” These experiments on animals are needed for the greater good. Animal experimentation is essential for the discovery…

Words 1777 - Pages 8

Essay on Morality and Flame Retardant Agent

goal and deliver him the commission, Wayne has promised a customer a delivery date which will almost certainly be fulfilled. 8. Chris Kemp is the manager of a local toy store. The ‘hottest’ Christmas toy of the year is a “Peter Panda” stuffed animal which is in great demand and almost impossible to find. The store has just taken delivery of 12 “Peter Pandas”, all of which have been promised to people who have paid a deposit to reserve the toy. The manufacturer has assured Chris that the store…

Words 1826 - Pages 8

Bioethics Paper

Animal Experimentation: Is it Cruelty or the Key to Advancing and Bettering our Future? Jasmine L. Smith Southeastern University March 6, 2014 Abstract Testing on animals has been around for centuries but recently it has become a highly argued bioethical issue. It has become a question of where our commitment lies; to the safety and health of other humans, or to the welfare and rights of animals. Debates between animal welfare advocates and organizations that use animal testing have…

Words 4626 - Pages 19