Management Theory Essay

Words: 2097
Pages: 9
Open Document
Robbins, Bergman, Stagg and Coulter (2006, p. 11) state “The continued popularity of the functional and process approaches to describe what managers do is a tribute to their clarity and simplicity- managers plan, organize, lead and control.” Compare and contrast how the ideas of Fayol and Mintzberg relate to this statement. In your discussion you should refer to a minimum of academic journal articles and also identify and indicate you understand underlying these ideas.

The following essay will compare and contrast the ideas of Fayol and Mintzberg relating to management which have been developed to assist a manger to complete their job of working with and through others so that organisations can achieve goals and objectives efficiently …show more content…
As the classical functions, other scholars must compare their views with each other. Lamond (2003, p.18) cites Wren (1994, p.357) suggests that “the work of Fayol and Mintzberg represent simply different rather than competing views”. And Carroll and Gillen(1987, p.40) cited Mohoney, Jerdee and Carroll(1963, 1965) who indicate that “managerial time can be allocated to a set of eight basic managerial functions which can be called the ‘PRINCESS’ factors (Planning, Representing, Investigating, Negotiating, Coordinating, Evaluating, Supervising, Staffing)”, because Carroll and Gillen(1987, p.40) considers that Fayol’s five functions do not involve managerial work activities such as “represetnting the organization to outside groups”, which is also pointed out by Mintzberg (1971). Moreover, Lamond (2003, p.13) cites Mintzberg (1973, p.10) argues that Fayol’s five functions are useless for not linking to specific activities. In addition, Parker and Riston (2005, p.186) cites Mintzberg (1994, p. 186) has argued that “the untenability of planning’s view of change is exemplified by Fayol’s view of planning’s role in maintaining organizational stability, allegedly admitting only adaptation to ‘minor perturbations rather than major discontinuities’”. At the same time, Parker and Riston (2005, p.186) use again Mintzberg (1994) to critique “the inflexibility of Fayol’s approach to planning was
Show More

Related Documents: Management Theory Essay

Strategic Management Theory

In the Class: “ Management and Organization Theory”, we have been studying the Management functions by understanding what is the planning function and how does the planning function actually work. We have been also reviewing all about Strategic Management, the planning process and the planning cycle. How does the manager formulate, process, and implement his/her organizational goals and objectives, etc. We also learned that everything starts with a planning stage. The company’s/organization’s…

Words 1019 - Pages 5

Management Theories Essay

Management pt. I Theories * management theories : * allow an organised way of thinking about something * help define concepts and insights about the thing * are able to organise facts, definitions etc. about the thing so they do not contradict one another * try to explain and predict features or behaviour of the thing * may lead to a more objective rather than subjective consideration of the thing * However, our belief in a theory may often be more…

Words 2363 - Pages 10

Management Theory Essay

safe working environment on a construction site is a critical measure of the success of any construction project. Risk management in the context of health and safety at construction site considered as an excellence in construction site in order to greatly minimise the accident rate in construction site. Nowadays, most of the construction project will implement risk management in their project in order to identify and eliminate the risk and keep the accident rate as low as possible. Accident is an…

Words 4300 - Pages 18

Theories Of Security Management

Case study 2 Suhan Kim Professor Nwatu CIS 502 – Theories of Security Management Strayer University February 1, 2014 Abstract WikiLeaks put the many secret U.S. military documents from the Iraq War and Afghan War Logs into a public web site. These documents included descriptions of attacks on Iraqi security forces and U.S. forces, detainee abuse, civilian casualty incidents, and so on. Social engineering and counterintelligence gave potential implications to national security. This paper describes…

Words 1838 - Pages 8

Classical And The Human Relations Theory And Theories Of Management

Classical and the Human Relations theories of management. The classical management is sometimes called the scientific approach, it was developed during the Industrial Revolution in order to cope with the problems that arose in the factories. It attempted to find the most efficient way of managing and completing the tasks that were set for the employees. The classical approach saw organisations as rational entities that should be based on facts rather than intuition. The approach suggested a highly…

Words 1068 - Pages 5

Terror Management Theory Summary

terror management theory “…suggest that the fear of death creates existential anguish that underlies much of human motivation” (Baumeister & Bushman, 2014). The article given describes the terror management theory as “…the idea that reminders of death increase the need for psychological security” (Sheldon Solomon, Jeff Greenberg, & Tom Pyszczynsk, 2004). The terror management theory also proves itself to be very relevant to politics. The article describes how the terror management theory was relevant…

Words 223 - Pages 1

Management Theory and Practice Essay

Management Theory and Practice Adam Cates The Functions of Modern Management MGT 601 Gary Shelton February 23, 2015 Abstract This paper is a brief summary of the classic management theory and its origination dating back to the late 1700’s during the industrial revolution. It describes the basic 5 functions, roles, and skill sets of managers, and the abilities that they need to possess to perform their duties. I summarize these roles, functions, and skills to highlight how managers function…

Words 1419 - Pages 6

Management Theories of Mcdonald's Essay

Management Theories Implemented by McDonald’s McDonald’s demonstrates many different aspects of classical management, including aspects of Frederick Taylor’s scientific management and Henri Fayol’s management principles. McDonald’s also displays how their management styles compares to their competition and how it has led to an effective organization. Taylor’s management style is evident through McDonald’s training, specific systems, and education; while Fayol’s management style manifests through…

Words 1218 - Pages 5

History of Management Theory Essay

Running Head: HISTORY OF MANAGEMENT THEORY History of Management Theory Troy Thompson 5409 Foxglove Drive, Bossier City, LA 71112 318-918-7413 Troythompson98@yahoo.com MSM 500 May 21, 2010 Class Instructor: Dr. David Bouvin Ellis University Introduction People and processes are the main elements under management purview, and it is interesting to learn how managerial philosophy pertaining to these two elements has evolved from the Industrial Revolution throughout the…

Words 1131 - Pages 5

Henri Fayol's Theory Of Management

Management involves the manipulation of the human capital of an enterprise to contribute to the success of the enterprise. This implies effective communication: an enterprise environment (as opposed to a physical or mechanical mechanism), implies human motivation and implies some sort of successful progress or system outcome. As such, management is not the manipulation of a mechanism (machine or automated program), not the herding of animals, and can occur in both a legal as well as illegal enterprise…

Words 508 - Pages 3