Private Government Argument Analysis

Words: 1367
Pages: 6
Open Document
Throughout this essay I will explain why Linda is being subjected to private government by Technology Corp. in insisting that she signs a non-compete agreement. First I will clarify what is meant by private government according to Anderson, followed up with my arguments that Technology Corp is exercising private government. Next I will present an objection to the arguments followed by a response to the objection, and then wrap it all up in the conclusion. Private government, defined by Anderson, “is government that has arbitrary, unaccountable power over those it governs (pp. 44).” When she says it is ‘arbitrary’ she means that there are reasons, but they are not very good or significant ones. When she says it is ‘unaccountable’ she means that there are ways to keep in check the governors, but they are not consistently used or make a big difference. You are subject to …show more content…
One of the main reasons being that it is a threat to our three concepts of freedom; negative, positive, and republican. Negative freedom is how the private government interferes with one’s actions. Positive freedom is how the private government doesn’t leave you with a rich option of choices. Republican freedom is how the private government expresses its dominance over you with its arbitrary, unaccountable will (Anderson, pp. 45-46). An example of this threat to our freedoms is how employers use the concept of private government to govern our everyday lives outside of work. Penn State recently threatened to impose a $100 per month surcharge on workers who didn’t answer a health survey (Anderson, pp. 49). This clearly shows Penn State is acting as a private government and threatening the freedoms listed above. Expressing dominance over their employees by enforcing a fine, interfering with one’s actions by making them reveal their health choices, and limiting their options by making them feel self-conscious of their health
Show More

Related Documents: Private Government Argument Analysis

Managing Out: the Public Sector in the Community Essay examples

psm unit 2: MANAGING OUT: THE PUBLIC SECTOR IN THE COMMUNITY |MINOR ASSIGNMENT – ASSESSMENT RESPONSE SHEET FOR ESSAY | Participants – complete your details and submit this sheet with your minor assignment. Your assessor will provide feedback and your grade on this sheet. |Participant to complete…

Words 2680 - Pages 11

Essay on Analysis Weigth 2013

25, 2013 Article Analysis of Who is Responsible for Obesity In his article “Obesity: Who is Responsible for Our Weight?”Bradly Balko tries to convince his readers that obese people are responsible for their weight ploblems. He uses moral arguments related to the governments rights to interfere in people’s private lives. He uses pathos to convince the people to feel angry about the government interfering with their food. Finally he uses logic to give reasons for his argument. All of the techniques…

Words 792 - Pages 4

Explain Free Cash Flow

in multi-dimensional analysis. 4. Explain ‘Options’ trading. State their significance in modern day trading. 5. Comment on the business models of private equity funds. 6. Comment on valuation of ‘distressed companies’. 7. Illustrate with an example any three capital structure ratios. 8. Illustrate with an example any three profitability ratios. 9. State and explain ‘time value of money’. 10. Explain with an example, the ‘if-then’ analysis & features in excel…

Words 1669 - Pages 7

Essay about Modules3/ Case Assignment

Module 3/ Case Assignment CJA302 Criminal Justice System Dr. Campbell Are private prisons safe, efficient, and effective? How would you rate them in effectiveness as compared to public sector prisons? Make sure you define ‘effective’ for your professor… and support your position with well reasoned argument. The prison system in Washington state is being severely stretched by overcrowding, threatening the safety of the staff, the inmates…

Words 791 - Pages 4

politics for global economy final paper

POLITICS FOR THE GLOBAL ECONOMY FINAL PAPER Ecuador experienced many economic and political difficulties during the 1990’s. These different economic displacements, as Kindleberger will name them, lead the Ecuadorian government, into finally declaring the U.S. dollar as the official national currency early in 2000. This policy was implemented as a “policy of last resort” since it was the last resource that could possible provide a path out of economic recession and help avoid the disastrous effects…

Words 2775 - Pages 12

Marketing: Economics and Price Essay

or service means producing less of another good or service. Opportunity cost: the highest-valued that must be given up to engage in an activity. Three fundamental questions:1. What goods and services will be produced? Consumers, firms, and the government face the problem of scarcity by trading off on good or service for another. 2. How will the goods and services be produced? Firms may need to choose between a production method in the united state that uses fewer workers and more machines and a…

Words 2215 - Pages 9

Private Prisons Paper

Private Prisons Ashley Johnson, Crystal Hickman, Janet Roberts and Steven Martinez Public Policy Issues AJS/582 June 16, 2014 Timothy Cariker Private Prisons Use of Private Institutions vs. Public Institutions The use of private organizations to manage prison operations has existed for decades. The government consistently has contracted for services from external vendors and suppliers to provide for instance, medical services, food preparation, and kitchen duties, inmate vocational programs and…

Words 3036 - Pages 13

school choice Essay examples

the government via the public-school system. While some individuals opt out of the system by sending their children to private or Character schools, most Americans still attend their government-assigned local public schools (Hess 2010). This behavior creates a virtual struggle for public schools, as they receive a fresh group of students every year regardless of school performance as well as affecting their budget. Private and character schools, on the other hand, are like any other private business:…

Words 927 - Pages 4

Essay on New Deal Program of Recovery during the Great Depression

harmful, or a mixed bag of both. In your analysis consider the following. 1. Who was helped by the new deal, and who was not. (consider urban vs. rural, ethnicities, gender, labor vs. owning classes, age, north vs. south, east vs west, etc) 2. The financial costs of new deal legislation, and the debt incurred. 3. the impact of the idea of private enterprise and capitalism. 4. The legality and constitutionality of new deal measures. 5. The governments increase in size and new responsibilities…

Words 317 - Pages 2

Critical Reading Essay

on the topic of anti-globalisation. Bryan Gould‘s perspective is in the left wing ideology which can be seen from the article. He pointed out the consequence of privatisation and another aspect of foreign investment, thus endorsing the need for government to protect New Zealand from the influence of globalisation. Context The article was published on New Zealand Herald, the number one daily newspaper connecting with more than half million readers each day. By using simple language, Bryan Gould’s…

Words 822 - Pages 4