Why Is Athens Better Than Sparta

Words: 662

Pages: 3

Open Document

Would you rather live in Sparta where military is number one, or in Athens where trade is key? Athens and Sparta were both city-states in ancient Greece. They’re both located on the Iberian peninsula, yet about 150 miles apart. Athens in on the coastline, about 4 miles from the Aegean Sea. Sparta however, is farther inland about 25 miles from the nearest harbor. I would rather live in Sparta because of how they treated women and slaves, and their military.

One of the reasons Sparta is preferable is because of how they treated women and slaves. In section 6 it mentions that women in Athens couldn’t own property, vote on or attend the Assembly, and some couldn’t even choose who they married. Some slaves in Athens worked in silver mines 300 feet below the …show more content…
Sparta has an oligarchy where the power is in the hands of a few people. In section 3, it states that in Athens, laws had to be approved by a group known as the Assembly containing 6,000 people. People in the Assembly could be young, and vote for what’s best for them and not everyone. The economy in Athens were coins, which are easy to steal. However in Sparta they had big silver bars making it hard to steal and replicate their currency. In section 2, Comparing Two City States, it reveals that Sparta was surrounded by mountains. The mountains made it hard for enemies to attack Sparta. In addition, it made it so that Spartan soldiers could see the enemies for miles away. These are just some of the many reasons why Sparta is better than Athens.

Now answer the question, would you rather live in Sparta where military is number one, or in Athens where trading is key? All in all, Sparta is a better city-state to live in due to how they treated women and slaves, and their military. Women were treated with more rights in Sparta. Spartan boys also had more experience, making their military much more capable and put

Why Is Sparta Better Than Athens

I think Sparta had a better geographic advantage than Athens because it had hills, mountains, and good soil. Sparta was surrounded by hills and mountains which really helped them out. Athens was attacked more than Sparta was because it didn’t have the hills and mountains like Sparta did. The hills and mountains is the main thing that kept Sparta from being attacked. Sparta also had better soil than Athens. Sparta’s soil was easier to farm on. Farming was a necessary thing, because that’s how they…

Words 131 - Pages 1

Why Athens Is Better At Culture Than Sparta

Athens is better at culture than Sparta. Here’s some reasons why they are better. Also, their will be evidence why their better. Lastly their will also be arguments why Athens are better at culture than Sparta. One reason is that they were open to new ideas. The reason why they were open to new ideas is because they could get new or good ideas for the war and the could have a better chances to win the war with new ideas. Another, reason is because their city was on water. The good thing of having…

Words 242 - Pages 1

Athen Vs Sparta Dbq Analysis

Athens was very intellectual which made them superior to other city-states. Athens was a small city-state located on the coast of the aegean sea. They were more social than sparta because they weren’t isolated. The city-state that was superior was Athens because of their geography, lifestyle and government. Between the two city-states of athens and sparta I would have to choose Athens. Athens had the geographical advantage because of the placement of their city-state. Specifically Doc D states,“Athens…

Words 606 - Pages 3

Athens And Sparta Compare And Contrast Essay

both Athens and Sparta were both powerful Greek city-states, they had striking differences in economic structure, government, and cultural values. Athens and Sparta both had unique types of government, education, military involvement, woman’s role in society, and slaves. Throughout this paper I will analyze the similarities and differences between Athens and Sparta. As well as which one is better. Besides all of their differences, they as also had many similarities. The education of Athens and Sparta…

Words 1996 - Pages 8

Women In Ancient Athens

structure in ancient Sparta women were able to have more freedom and access to rights and responsibilities, then women in ancient Athens. In comparing both civilizations we need to ask What legal rights did Spartan women have that Athenian women did not have? Or Was the education system in Athens fair and equitable to women, and how was Spartan education different? As well as to compare both cities we need to look at how was personal freedom different to Athens than Sparta? And lastly overall we…

Words 1492 - Pages 6

Why Did Sparta's Strengthes Outweighed The Weaknesses

outweighed the weaknesses. One reason why Sparta’s strengths outweighed the weaknesses is in the field of education and the topics that are taught. A quote to support this is, “Only the rudiments [basics] of reading and writing were taught; instruction consisted for the most part in … obedience, bodily fitness, and courage to conquer in battle” (Hooker 3). From this quote, I understand that these boys were taught the essential education topics. For Sparta, those were basic reading and writing skills…

Words 567 - Pages 3

Greece Newspaper

Tamjid Islam Parthenon The Parthenon is a temple on the Athenian Acropolis, Greece. It was dedicated to the maiden goddess Athena and was built on top of the highest hill in Athens, the Acropolis. In about 1300 BC, the Acropolis had been where the kings of Athens lived, and where everybody went to defend them when there was a war. After the Dark Ages, the Athenians had no more kings to rule them. Instead they had an oligarchy, and so there was no king to live on the…

Words 923 - Pages 4

Athens v Essay

courtesans: prostitutes with wealthy clients Comparing Athens and Sparta: Where Would You Rather Live, and Why? Source: PBS.org ATHENS SPARTA Population & Map Approximately 140,000; Approximately 40,000 men were citizens; and slaves (about 40,000). By 432 BC, Athens had become the most populous citystate in Hellas. In Athens and Attica, there were at least 150,000 Athenians, around 50,000 aliens, and more than 100,000 slaves. Approximately 8,000 Spartiates (adult male citizens) ruled over a…

Words 1447 - Pages 6

Compare And Contrast Sparta And Athens

Keenan Entress Due: 12/12/11 Athens to Sparta Final Paper “Athens to Sparta” Kings and queens have been around for thousands of years. Ruling over their people with power that used to be believed was divine. These kings and queens have always represented the people they ruled over. The king or queen gave a general idea of who the people were that they ruled. Yet, kings and queens weren’t the only leaders to represent their people. There were also…

Words 1721 - Pages 7

Women's Roles In Ancient Greece

700 B.C. many changes gave way to new forms of government in city-states. In the city of Athens, women were believed to intellectually weak and inferior. Mostly every Athenian philosopher, except for Plato, theorized that women had strong emotions and because of that needed guardians. Women in Athens were regarded as second-rate citizens who had no influence on politics, economics or culture. Women in Athens were known to be “household” women. Basically all their rights were inside the household…

Words 2216 - Pages 9