Argument Against Animal Research

Words: 809
Pages: 4
Open Document
Conducting research on animals in the scientific and medical field is a topic that has been debated worldwide for quite some time. Animals are used in laboratories in order to develop new medicines or test the safety of them and in most cases these experiments inflict pain on the animals involved, or affect their quality of life afterwards. There are people who are completely against it, completely for it and people who are neutral about the idea of it. Knowing that animal research is beneficial and vital towards science, I find myself in the category of being neutral about it, but then knowing that innocent animals are being experimented on, and have no voice of their own to speak up I also find myself being against animal research. PETA, …show more content…
Is an article published in the BMJ journal authored by Pound et al. In general, this article sides with the idea that animal research benefits humans and research in general and states the different ways in which animals are used and their advantages to humans. The authors of this article are all professors at universities whom all have extensive knowledge in the scientific and medical industry. As scholars, their immediate purpose throughout this article was to educate their target through their trustworthiness and credibility as professionals. The audiences for this article are extremely diverse as it can be for the general public who are looking to improve on their knowledge on animal research in general or researchers who are interested in grasping a deeper understanding on how animal testing in science is beneficial. This article gains its credibility by providing references to support their views and findings showing that the authors have thoroughly researched this topic and ensured that all arguments are …show more content…
This article talks about the pros and cons of using animals in experimentation, giving views on both sides of this argument using the theory of evolution. As a Professor of Bioethics at the Linkoping University, Nordgren primarily focus on the ethics of animal experimentation (Christiansen, 2013) and has dedicated his professional career on this issue making him a credible source in regards to this topic. Again, the audience for this article are somewhat similar to the audience targeted in article one ‘Where is the evidence that animal research benefits humans?’ where they are not only focusing on reaching a specific group of people, but aim it towards multiple target audiences who are interested in expanding their knowledge on this issue. Nordgren gains the attention of his readers as talks about feelings and intuition in order to emotionally appeal to his audience. The author’s main goal was to inform the audience on the issue of animal experimentation and explain what exactly goes on before going into depth about the argument where he then compared other researchers’ work to support his own. In contrast, these two articles have many similarities, in terms of the setting, purpose and audience targeted regardless of the fact they are supporting different
Show More

Related Documents: Argument Against Animal Research

Ron Kline's Argument Analysis

opposing arguments. During the animal rights movement in 1989, Dr. Ron Kline was studying experimental medical technology at the National Cancer Institute in Washington D.C. In the Newsweek article “A Scientist: ‘I Am The Enemy’.” Kline is effective in justifying research on animals through his thorough explanation of the necessity of accurate test subjects when discovering new medical treatments. Kline’s first argument begins by addressing what he believes to be a common initial reaction to animal testing…

Words 703 - Pages 3

Essay about Is it better to eat organically farmed food than intensively farmed produce?

organically farmed food or intensively farmed food? I will be using a variety of research I have collected to write arguments for and against organically farmed food. I will be investigating this question using different sources to back up my arguments. Organic farming: a form of agriculture that uses techniques such as crop rotation, using manure instead of fertilizers and pesticides, they also use more land and allow their animals to roam free. This differs from intensive farming because intensive farming…

Words 1841 - Pages 8

Essay about Horse Slaughter in the U.S

the use of animal testing. Carlson is against animal testing. Sabin is for the use of animals to further medicine. Sabin has the inside advantage because her husband was a scientist but Carlson makes a very good argument. The article “Animal Research Saves Human Lives” by Heloisa Sabin’ is about the benefit of animal researching to cure Polio. Sabin gives the example of Forest Gump in the scene where he runs out of his leg braces. The comparison to Forest and the use of animal research is that the…

Words 795 - Pages 4

All Animals Are Equal Essay

occur each day on the issues of animal cruelty and human rights, but when the issues are put together which will reign over the other? The author Peter Singer of “All Animals are Equal” and “Tools for Research” presents his argument for determining when animal experiments are justified. The author starts his paper with a counter argument, questioning if one would be willing to let thousands of people die if those people could be saved by experimentation on a single animal. The answer is a unanimous no;…

Words 1750 - Pages 7

Bioethics Paper

Animal Experimentation: Is it Cruelty or the Key to Advancing and Bettering our Future? Jasmine L. Smith Southeastern University March 6, 2014 Abstract Testing on animals has been around for centuries but recently it has become a highly argued bioethical issue. It has become a question of where our commitment lies; to the safety and health of other humans, or to the welfare and rights of animals. Debates between animal welfare advocates and organizations that use animal testing have…

Words 4626 - Pages 19

Rhetorical Analysis Essay

“Should Animals Continue to Be Used in Research Experiments?” an article by Cynthia Barnett. It seems logical that animals would be used for testing rather than humans. The question is, why? Is it really necessary for animal’s to be used as “guinea pigs?” Burnett provides evidence of how far back in time experimental research has been tested on animals. She argues that the useful information obtained from these test could have been found through alternative testing. In the article she notes strong…

Words 716 - Pages 3

Arguments Against Global Warming Research

warming has slowly presented itself into our society today. With all of the research that has been done, and the many scientist who have researched global warming, two very distinct sides have been developed. Within the global warming argument, two sides, those who believe in global and those who do not believe in global warming, have been formed. There are two opinions on the issue of global warming, and there is one argument that I find most persuasive in forming my opinion on global warming. There…

Words 526 - Pages 3

Research Report Essay

I. Should animal testing be permitted? A. In the past years, we have tested our research/etc. on animals. They use animals to ensure that products are safe and easy to use and not let anything hazardous happen. B. Most people believe that it’s ok to just use what apart of this earth and just use and get rid of it like its nothing… I personally think it’s a crazy thing to do! That’s why I’m arguing against it. C. People who are against animal testing base off their contentions on the fact…

Words 407 - Pages 2

Animal Research: a Very Controversial Topic Essay examples

Animal Research Animal research is a very controversial topic and will probably continue to be for many years. Many people have different point of views about it, and we might not always be on the same page about it. Like everyone else, it's not the first time I have heard about animal research. When I was given this assignment I immediately thought that I would be completely against animal research because like most people I only thought of the pain inflicted to animals at first. As an owner…

Words 979 - Pages 4

Animals Equality final paper wk 5 jolivet

Animals' Equality Noel Jolivet PHI 103 Informal Logic Instructor. Christopher Meyers February 23, 2015 When reflecting on equality we normally conjure up thoughts about human beings whether the issue may be one of race, gender, or creed. Animals other than humans are rarely referred to as having rights, and to many it may seem unusual for us to contemplate any animal other than human beings having equivalence on par to the treatment of humans. It is however a debatable issue in which…

Words 1550 - Pages 7