Black Judges Essay

Words: 754
Pages: 4
Open Document
Are Judges Politicians in Black Robes? Each year thousands of cases come before judges throughout the country. The Bureau of Justice Statistics reports that “the aggregate number of newly filed, reopened, and reactivated cases reported to the Court Statistics Project (CSP) from the nation’s state courts reached a record high 102.4 million incoming cases in 2006.” With the number of court cases only growing, it is clear that judges have an immense amount of influence throughout the United Sates. However, the pertinent question becomes; are these case decisions made by judges who are motivated by their ideological beliefs or are judges able to interpret the letter of the law without allowing political bias into the court room? The overwhelming …show more content…
‘Situation Sense’? An Experimental Study of Motivated Reasoning and Professional Judgment. In this study they attempted to see if judges were in fact political. They posed the question “If you leave a water bottle out for someone else to pick it up later is it littering?” Then they asked judges these questions with added variables such as “immigrant-rights group left the sealed bottles of water because they were expecting illegal immigrants to be crossing through on their journey from Mexico to the U.S” or “the sealed water bottle was left by construction workers building a border fence to stop immigration.” The theory was that when determining if the water bottle was litter or not, the circumstances around why it was left should not matter. The scholars found that “in deciding these specific legal cases, judges were far less influenced by their ideology than members of the public. In other words, whether a judge was personally inclined to support or oppose immigration made much less difference in whether he found the water bottle “litter” or “debris” than it did for a non-lawyer,”(Evans 1). The significance of this finding is that judges use more than their personal opinions to dictate decision making. The structured way of analyzing a case and applying the law to that case often times allows judges to rule cases in a manner that may not align with their personal political
Show More

Related Documents: Black Judges Essay

Summary Of Black Men And Public Space By Brent Staples

In 1986, Brent Staples wrote a nonfictional prose essay, “Black Men and Public Space” from The Norton High School Reader, about his color. To this day, Staples’s essay is still relevant towards Americans and African-Americans. Throughout the years in the United States of America, fatal shooting of unarmed people, especially blacks, have declined, but it is still a major issue today. These shootings have mostly been caused by the police. As Staples writes “Where fear and weapons meet--and they often…

Words 291 - Pages 2

Week 7 Hw Essay examples

Beliefs- Homosexuals are Normal People… There comes a point in everyone’s life when they must take some time to evaluate their lives and beliefs. When I was about to write this essay I got a call from my sister venting about how people judge her and chastise her about being homosexual. I decided that I was going to write my essay on the belief that homosexuals are indeed the same as any other human being, whether they like the same sex or not. Love is described as an expression of one’s affection.…

Words 531 - Pages 3

Brent Staples

1951.He published "Just Walk on By: A Black Man Ponders His Power to Alter Public Space," in 1951. He explains that in his life, he has been discriminated against because he is a black man working as a journalist in a predominantly white field. Brent staples show in his thesis that, racism still exists in this world, even though we would like to think we are all equal. Stereotypes of race and sex can influence how people treat you. Brent Staples begins his essay by making the readers think he is committing…

Words 637 - Pages 3

Black Table Is Still There

groups, because of their race. Lawrence Otis Graham, author of "The 'Black Table' Is Still There," recounts his personal experience of how he encountered this segregation in junior high school, and how the same exact problem still exists at his junior high school over 14 years later. This discovery perplexes Graham and makes him question how such a degrading action could possibly still be practiced. Throughout Graham's essay, he conveys his personal annoyance at the fact that segregation still…

Words 745 - Pages 3

American Romanticism In The Minister's Black Veil

Society will always have their opinions on you no matter what you do, many times people will judge you for the most irrelevant things. In the story, ¨The Minister's Black Veil¨, Mr. Hooper, the minister, because of the fact that he wears a black veil, he gets judged by the community and everyone talks behind his back. The community around you will always have opinions about certain people no matter who it is, occasionally even you will have an opinion and not even notice that you are judging someone…

Words 1239 - Pages 5

Racially Based Jury Nullification Summary

This essay is a summary and analysis of the article Racially Based Jury Nullification: Black Power in the Criminal Justice System, by Paul Butler. It includes identifying the main arguments and thesis of the article, and analyzing the validity of the author’s claims. Additionally, this essay provides a critique of the support the author provides in his article. The author, Paul Butler, is a professor at Georgetown Law in Washington, specializing in race relations law and criminal theory. He was also…

Words 656 - Pages 3

Prewriting Prejudice And Acceptance Essay

What general categories or stereotypes have you observed as a part of Maycomb? ● They hold stereotypes about how individuals will behave as a result of their age, gender, race, social status, and other fixed categories. Like for example; one common criticism in the novel is that the black characters are idealized. And also the stereotype of aristocratic white women is held up to ridicule - their virtue is seen as excessive thoughtfulness, and they appear as selfish and hypocritical. List below the characters that are the victims of stereotyping…

Words 327 - Pages 2

Just Walk On By Brent Staples

subconsciously judge others based on race. He begins by recalling his first realization of the fear people display as he walked behind a young white woman on the street who was visibly nervous about his presence. Instead of being offended, he considers the appearance he might have given off in that situation. In a short amount of time, he soon becomes familiar with these signs of people’s fear. In moving from Chicago to New York, he recalls the dark image of black “muggers” along the streets. The essay “My…

Words 271 - Pages 2

S REssay1

you feed three kids or provide hot water for bathing? Do you know what living in poverty is like? Most of us will never experience first-hand what it is like. In “What Is Poverty?” Jo Goodwin Parker’s essay reveals the hardships she faces as a woman, wife and mother struggling in poverty. In this essay “What is Poverty?” Jo Goodwin Parker describes in very expository language to illustrate herself to the reader: “Here I am, dirty, smelly, with no ‘proper’ underwear on and the stench of my rotting teeth…

Words 720 - Pages 3

How It Feels To Be Colored Me Essay

people that had different color skin than she did, but because everyone was nice to her she didn’t think anything of it. She liked to sit on her porch and watch how black and white people interacted with her and each other. She talked about how white people would give her dimes so they could see her dance and “speak pieces,” and how black people didn’t give her any money, however they were really protective of her dancing and singing. As a result Eatonville Florida was not as bad as the rest of the…

Words 1118 - Pages 5