Criminal Justice Vs Restorative Justice

Words: 1659
Pages: 7
Open Document
It comes as no surprise to me that restorative justice has these weaknesses as it is not a panacea. However, to address these weaknesses and move toward a better criminal justice system, I think that restorative justice must be used in conjunction with retributive justice. What has been examined previously indicates that both restorative and retributive justice have strengths and weaknesses in delivering justice. An ideal solution for a more robust criminal justice system would include aspects of both these justice systems. This includes a system that is capable of bridging cultural values into modern ideas about justice and its delivery. Such a vision, one of synergy between restorative and retributive justice, would be the ‘best’ of both …show more content…
First, it is important to understand that restorative justice has culturally and context specific aims and principles; practices that may appear unjust from a retributive perspective that supports neutral distribution of justice (Wardak, 2011). Proponents of restorative justice would argue that these factors are a necessary facet of processes that are specifically designed to restore social harmony and “thus cannot be isolated from their social context” (Luccaro, 2016, p. 25). Such characteristics place restorative justice in sharp opposition to retributive justice systems which are structured around rigid rules with outcomes based on conformity and …show more content…
This creates tension and estrangement, threatening social harmony and cohesions. Restorative justice, by contrast, place strong emphasis on reconciliation and making peace among disputants (Roberts, 2004). Thus, unlike the retributive system, which creates losers and winners, in restorative justice systems, there are community-led decisions that promote peace and dignity among the victims, offenders, and the community. Thus, dispute resolution aims not only to punish and compensate, but also to reconcile the parties and reintegrate the offender into society (Lab, 2015).

Moreover, there are paradigmatic differences between restorative and retributive justice in terms of core legal values, the conceptualization of crime and notions of responsibility (Forsyth, 2007). For example, as Adoko and Levine (2009) state:
People don’t see two legal codes at all. The ‘community’ legal framework is not seen as law at all, but as a way of life, how people live —State Law on the other hand is something imposed and foreign. ... It is remote, in a foreign language and has little to do with most people’s lives . . . It isn’t about different laws—it’s about a different world view (Adoko & Levine, 2009, p.
Show More

Related Documents: Criminal Justice Vs Restorative Justice

Restorative Justice Essay

Restorative Justice Chaotic crimes in America have left innocent bystanders severely worried about the safety of everyone in the community in which they reside in. The Justice System has changed their approach when combating crime for the last century, ranging from the deterrence model, rehabilitation model, restoration model, to the incapacitation model. In modern time the Justice system has focused on the philosophy of restorative justice. Restorative justice is the focus on everyone involved…

Words 811 - Pages 4

Circle Justice Vs Criminal Justice

Circle Justice vs. Criminal Justice System Currently in the circle justice is often used, offenders and the juvenile justice system. The Circle Justice system is becoming popular as an alternative in many juvenile courts across the country. Many schools are using restorative processes of mediation. They have resources on how to support victims and on how to treat them with respect. The Circle Justice gives benefits such as, it repeats of offending for some offenders. The offenses brought to…

Words 208 - Pages 1

Restorative Justice System

Effectnives of Restorative Justice system: An analyses through victim and offender Medeation Overview The main goal of this paper is to outline the effectiveness of restorative justice system and how it can help in healing both the victim and the offender. This paper will give a brief introduction to restorative justice system and then mainly focus on the victim and offender mediation process .It will also highlight upon how spirituality and community can play an important role in strengthening…

Words 443 - Pages 2

Essay Jury and family Group Conferencing

or the court appoint local attorneys and reimburse accordingly. Adjudication is the reason for are criminal justice system, whether a public or private wrong, the adjudication is the resolution. Most criminal justice systems operate on the premise of innocent until proven guilty and some variations in application though the crime control model. Importance of an independent judiciary elected vs. appointed. Question that we ask are if elected would be better or if appointed will be better. The importance…

Words 736 - Pages 3

Essay On Recidivism

empirically grounded theory of treatment and emphasizes accountability of service providers, effective implementation of the treatment model, and long-term change.2” 3 - youths who received MST had significantly fewer arrests, reported fewer criminal offences and spent an average of ten fewer weeks in detention during a year long follow-up; - these results were maintained at a 2.4 year follow-up, with MST essentially doubling the % of youth not arrested; - MST has proven effective with adolescent…

Words 8788 - Pages 36

Juvenile Sex offenders Essay

Juvenile Sex Offenders, The Problem No One Wants to Talk About Dennison Muczynski Ashford University CRJ301: Juvenile Justice Instructor: Curtis Turney March 29, 2015 Most people feel uncomfortable openly discussing sex offenders in open forums, let alone juvenile offenders. People often look for simple answers and quick to rush judgement and demand a person to be punished for their actions. We see this type of thinking all over the news, like in Ferguson, MO, where half of society was willing…

Words 3576 - Pages 15

Life: Crime and Criminal Justice Essay

understand the nature of the crime problem in this country and how the criminal justice system works. 14. Why is it more “lethal crime” than “crime” in general, the big difference between America and other developed countries? It can probably be because America is free in a sense when compared to other countries, thus putting Americans at a higher risk of performing violent acts. 15. What is “bait and switch?” in criminal justice terms, the war on crime promised to attack violent crimes but has…

Words 6103 - Pages 25

Law 12 Notes Essay

obligation or a way of doing something because it is the way it has always been done Religion Inclusion of “supremacy of God” found in our Charter Prohibitions against murder, theft and perjury found in the Ten Commandments remain present in our Criminal Code, other things like adultery as grounds for divorce Social and Political Influences Law cannot be separated from the social, political, economic and cultural characteristics of a country or time period e.g. women’s rights before 1983 a man could…

Words 4154 - Pages 17