Difference Between Obedience And Disobedience

Words: 1010
Pages: 5
Open Document
The difference between obedience and disobedience seems fairly obvious. Obedience is following orders, and disobedience is not following orders.Some authors, including Erich Fromm, Crispin Sartwell, Philip Zimbardo, and Marianne Szegedy-Maszak, offer their own opinions about obedience, and from these articles we can look at obedience versus disobedience. However, in some situations, there can be some confusion between the two. How can something as straightforward as the difference between obedience and disobedience get blurred? There are many authors that offer their own opinions on how there can be confusion between these two very different ideas. Using different perspectives on an event can change someone's opinion on whether or not they …show more content…
He explains, "Hitler didn't kill 6 million Jews, or King Leopold 10 million Africans. They used a bureaucracy and a media machine and, finally, people just like me and you" (119). Sartwell is saying that the authority figures got others to obey to commit their evil acts. To the people committing the acts, they were being obedient, and following the orders of their superior. On the other hand, to the victims and anyone else on the outside, those people are being very disobedient by killing millions of people. Another example of when someone was being obedient and disobedient at the same time is from the movie Cool Hand Luke. One of the characters was told that he needed to move the dirt out of a certain are, and once he was finished, he was told that he had to move the dirt back. This happened again, and then he was punished because he wasn't following orders (Rosenburg). To the superior, he was being disobedient because he didn't do the tasks the way the superior thought they should have been done, but to the man digging, and the others watching, he was doing exactly what he should have been told. The man was following one of the orders that the superior gave him, but in order to complete one order, he had to disobey the other order. It was impossible for him to be completely obedient, so he was being both obedient and disobedient …show more content…
Sartwell begins to explain that, "I am not profoundly different than these people, and if you think you are, then you are either a moral hero or you are profoundly self-deluded" (118). Sartwell understands that genocide is horrible, but he also understands that he isn't very different than the people who were convinced to participate in the genocides. Sartwell is essentially saying that even though genocide is a terrible thing to do, there is still the possibility of being obedient like the others before him. Fromm uses a similar thought about this idea. Fromm says that, "If mankind commits suicide it will be because people will obey those who command them to push the deadly buttons; because they will obey the archaic passions of fear, hate, and greed; because they will obey obsolete cliches of State sovereignty and national honor" (125). Fromm is saying that even though people know that "pushing the deadly buttons" is wrong, there is nothing stopping them from following through because they want to be obedient. Something similar happens in A Few Good Men: the soldiers in the movie were following their orders to punish a fellow soldier who didn't follow their chain of command. The soldiers understood that they killed someone, but they weren't too distraught about it because they believed that they were just
Show More

Related Documents: Difference Between Obedience And Disobedience

english 102 Essay

TO DISOBEY FOR HOPE Civil disobedience can affect civilization in a heartfelt way. It can allow one to stand out of the crowd and let his or her voice be heard. But why must it be one who speaks? If everyone stands up for what is right, every individual can be heard. Erich Fromm and Henry David Thoreau are the masterminds of civil disobedience. They describe the term as if speaking of a great force. Civil disobedience is simply living. Living life to the fullest, taking risks and doing what…

Words 1570 - Pages 7

Essay The Importance of Following Orders

The Importance of Following Orders Following orders is of the utmost importance in the military. Obedience is what enables the military to operate in an organized and effective manner which is clearly very important during challenging military situations. While an individual can question the notion of obedience in daily life, this luxury is often not available in the military where the grand goals and aims require smooth internal functioning and hierarchical coordination. Indeed, many of the standards…

Words 3020 - Pages 13

Rational And Irrational Authority Essay

Obedience has always been perceived as a virtue, and disobedience has always been associated with delinquency. Depending on the circumstances and the relationship a person has with the authority figure, obedience may be given through mutual respect. When there is a lack of mutual respect between the authority figure and the submissive person, complications arise and the person may find themselves submitting to irrational authority. There is a drastic distinction between rational and irrational authority…

Words 561 - Pages 3

Genesis Job And Antigone Comparative Essay

the discussion of the matters regarding the laws of God and laws of man, punishments for disobedience, and the role of knowledge. Even though, all three of these written works discuss and acknowledge all four already mentioned factors, and each of these works have their own unique way to approach and explain these factors. Genesis, Job and Antigone are very alike because they talk about the faith and obedience that the characters have for God in each story. For instance, in Genesis, it is seen how…

Words 867 - Pages 4

Strong-Willed Child Book Report Essay

Another expert focused on a “positive” parenting and discipline method. This method to Dobson was as equally absurd, as it just ignored the willful disobedience. Just because you ignore the elephant, does not mean it is not in the room! These methods according to Dobson take more energy from the parent than just dealing head on with their strong-willed child. Once the child understands who is in charge…

Words 2634 - Pages 11

The Pros And Cons Of Fate Vs Free Will

is good? Our choices are limited since we have a responsibility to choose wisely. Freedom of choice places huge responsibility and make us accountable for our actions. Therefore, individuals still bore an obligation to choose obedience to God. Moreover, the difference between the world before sin and the world today is shocking. Suffering and diseases are rampant, wars are everywhere and people treat each other with…

Words 846 - Pages 4

Compare And Contrast Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X

bus boycotts which quickly made him well known (Isserman & Kazin, 2012). He used this “fame” to get people to listen to him and follow him. He also put together and led many marches which drew a lot of attention due to their scale. When the civil disobedience and nonviolent demonstrations went poorly or when King was sent to jail it only fueled the fight and increased his publicity and the publicity for the movement (King Jr.). This massive following from supports and critiques alike that King acquired…

Words 1135 - Pages 5

Essay on Ezekiel and the New Temple

LIBERTY UNIVERSITY BAPTIST THEOLOGY SEMINARY Ezekiel’s Prophecy of the new Temple Submitted To Dr. Joel Ajayi, In Partial Fulfillment Of The Requirements For The Completion Of The Course Evan 535 do7 comtempory evangelism By Thessalon M. Harrison September 13, 2015 The Bible has many passages that require interpretation for a deeper understanding of its meaning and purpose. For example, Ezekiel’s vision in chapters 40-48 is a difficult interpretative passage because of the eschatological…

Words 2350 - Pages 10

Essay on Berger 2e Chp06

Emotional Development Emotional regulation •Ability to control when and how emotions are expressed •Possibly due to connections between limbic system and prefrontal cortex Initiative versus guilt •Erikson's third psychosocial crisis •Children undertake new skills and activities and feel guilty when they do not succeed at them Guilt and Shame Guilt •Self-blame that people experience when they do something wrong Shame •People's feeling that others blame them, disapprove of them, or are disappointed…

Words 1935 - Pages 8

Amish Culture Essay

dominant cultures,” (wittmer, 1970, Para2). The Amish people feel that their differences put them “closer to god” (wittmer, 1970, Para2). The Amish are a Christian community well known for their simple style of living. They originated from a group that followed Jakob Amman during the religious schism in Switzerland of the Alsatian Anabaptist.”Membership into the Amish starts with a baptism which most often occurs between the ages of 18-25 and the member is expected to follow the Ordung which are the…

Words 1612 - Pages 7