Ptsd Literature Review

Words: 806
Pages: 4
Open Document
The following peer review is on the literature review regarding the issue of PTSD in Canadian soldiers. As per the grading rubric, the review will identify strengths and weaknesses in the follow areas: research question, literature review, justification of interdisciplinary and overall composition. The footnotes contain direct fragments from the literature review identifying where my conclusions are drawn from. Also, the review has an appendix with the rubric marking breakdown and suggested questions to improve the research question.

Research Question The subject of PTSD treatment in Canadian veterans is important, and it is one to which the author’s research question could make significant contribution towards. However, the research …show more content…
The first sentence and the last sentence are repetitive, both stating what the review will discuss. The sentences that follow introduce ethicalness and veteran integration which are not described in the body of the review. The mid-section of the introduction should be a relevant background for the topic. For example, how many veterans are being treated in Canada unsuccessfully? The last sentence is suitable because it defines what the literature will encompass. In regards to categories, the author does a good job of creating three different categories of focus. The author successfully identifies biological changes to the brain but the other two categories are not as clear. In addition, a concern is that the author summarizes each article rather than extracting information which pertains to their research question. The sources should intertwine, identifying similarities, differences and gaps. Also, there is a detachment between the sources and relationship to the research question. For example, the first article in the public policy category describes public official’s views on PTSD in the United States. The research specifies Canadian veterans with PTSD. There is no connection made to Canada or the views of Canadian public officials. Similarly, treatment protocols are key words in the research question but that is not addressed. Overall, the author should reconsider …show more content…
However, that is a very general assessment; any illness should be treated effectively. The author states that each discipline believes that their research is the most influential in the issue but, none of the articles clearly state that finding. Also, the author identifies gaps within each source but there is no direct connection made with how it relates to the proposed research question. Similarly, the author introduces new concepts of PTSD treatment as a symptom improver , PTSD score and self-regulation which are undefined and clearly related to the research question. Lastly, the author successfully summarizes the entire review. The author does identify which of the sources has the greatest relevance and pertinence to the research question. However, the author introduces a new concept of clinical rehabilitative approaches which was never mentioned earlier in the review. Therefore, the author should improve the analysis of the literature to correlate with the research
Show More

Related Documents: Ptsd Literature Review

PTSD And Substance Abuse: A Literature Review

The hypothesis of this article is that the comorbidity of PTSD and substance abuse (PTSD-SA) is unlike that of other comorbid disorders due to the complex relationship between PTSD symptom presentations, the effects of the substance of choice, and the effects of withdrawal symptoms when attempts are made to eliminate the substance from the body. This article focuses on the review of three theories regarding to PTSD-SA comorbidity. Throughout the article, they mention many statistics that support…

Words 151 - Pages 1

PTSD Among Adolescents

based evidence between life experiences or homelessness in the development of PTSD in adolescents ages 13-18. The evidence founded by the study could be utilized by service providers to develop programs that treat adolescents who is homeless and have a PTSD diagnosis. The evidence could be utilized to develop policy and request funding on the micro, macro, and mezzo level to address this barrier with hopes of reducing PTSD and homeless amongst adolescents. The research is time frame friendly due to…

Words 864 - Pages 4

Post Traumatic Birth Theory Essay

disorder (PTSD) to have a prevalence of 3.17 percent. Taking in account how many babies are born each year, 4.3 million women could develop postpartum PTSD each year. A traumatic birth can be a big risk factor for psychiatric disturbance for postpartum women. PTSD is not the only diagnosis of concern for women, but definitely the most debilitating. PTSD sufferers often choose to avoid triggers, but when your baby is your trigger that can pose a problem for families. Utilizing literature…

Words 784 - Pages 4

Practicum Evau Summary MSN Essay

Medical Center (VAMC). The population of the Domiciliary Residential Rehabilitation Program is veterans with multiple and severe medical conditions, mental illness, addiction, or psychosocial deficits. Military-related posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) can negatively affect the veteran’s well-being (Health Services Administration, 2010). The care needs of the nursing staff were assessed to identify the need for the educational program in the…

Words 1925 - Pages 8

Welcome To The Oceanside Trauma Center Of Daytona Beach

It is highly correlated with the Clinician Administered PTSD Scale (r=.929), has good diagnostic efficiency (>.70), and has robust psychometric properties with a variety of trauma populations. Through our research we have found nothing but overwhelming positive feedback for our assessment tools of choice. Any…

Words 4841 - Pages 20

Compare And Contrast Essay example

emotions. “Posttraumatic stress disorder […] serious condition that can develop after a person has an experienced or witnessed a traumatic or terrifying event in which serious physical harm occurred or was threatened.” (“Posttraumatic Stress order (PTSD”) Hank knew his decision of going down a river, in the condition the river was in, led to the death of his wife and daughter because of this Hank lives in a false reality. In Let the Water Hold Me Down by Michael Spurgeon, Hank is consistently thinking…

Words 878 - Pages 4

School To Prison Pipeline Research Paper

Hello Dr. Middlebrook This is my presentation on School to Prison Pipeline Affecting Juveniles by Sharon Canul My research question is how is school to prison pipeline affecting juveniles around the United States? Juveniles are being treated like criminals that are very young age, some as early as 5-year-old all the way till they are 18 or out of school Many of the juveniles are not graduating from middle school or high school because the schools are acting like prisons, instead of a fun learning…

Words 582 - Pages 3

Summary On Neuroimaging In Pediatric Traumatic Brain Injury

Huisman, 2009) A review by Suskaur and Huisman (2009) discusses new brain imaging techniques (i.e., diffusion weighted (DWI) and diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), susceptibility weighted imaging (SWI), and H-magnetic resonance spectroscopy (H-MRS)) and presents current research on their abilities to identify functional outcomes following TBI in the pediatric population due to their sensitivity in detecting microstructural brain injuries such as diffuse axonal injury (DAI). This review also discusses…

Words 3804 - Pages 16

JURI 3246 Literature Review Essay

JURI 3246 Literature Review The Nexus of Law and Mental Health: Criminally Insane Women Talisa Beaudoin Laurentian University The nexus of law and health of Canadian women can be seen in varying degrees, the degrees in which they are seen are crucial to the distribution of sentences for criminal offences. The highest form of mental disorder defense is known previously as criminal insanity, now it is known as not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder. Although not categorized…

Words 2451 - Pages 10

Anxiety Disorder and Millennium Cohort Essay

panic disorder; stress disorders, post-traumatic; women Abbreviation: PTSD, posttraumatic stress disorder. The effects of deployment on the physical and mental health of US service members continue to receive significant attention from the Department of Defense, veterans, Congress, the American public, and the media. Research has shown that deployment and combat exposures increase the risk of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (1–3), depression (4), binge drinking (1, 5, 6), and smoking (7, 8),…

Words 8451 - Pages 34