Should We Celebrate Columbus Day

Words: 513

Pages: 3

Open Document

Each year the second monday in October is met with the familiar smells of a cookout and sound of the “1492” poem. Kids are taught all about how Columbus discovered America with the help of his three famous ships, the Nina, the Pinta, and the Santa Maria. But why is Columbus day a national holiday? What is celebrated? Any 3rd grader can answer that, it is a national holiday to celebrate Columbus finding America. But it’s not quite that simple. Columbus didn't actually discover America. In fact, he never set foot on North America. His four voyages led him to Caribbean Islands and the Central and South American coasts. Not only that, but he didn't even discover the places where his ships landed. Natives had already been living there for thousands …show more content…
It appears not. Columbus did not intend to discover the Americas, he was actually trying to sail around the world to Asia in an attempt to initiate trade outside of the Ottoman Empire controlled trade routes. Once he realized where he had landed was not Asia, he proceeded to enslave the local Taino tribe and force them to collect gold for him. They were punished with loss of limb or death if they didn't collect enough gold. Columbus was allowed to keep 10% of this gold and anything else he found on his trip according to a deal he made with the Spanish Monarchs before departing. Everything else would be given to Spain. Even with all of the riches Columbus gained for Spain through his exploitation of the native people, the Spanish government recognized how immoral his practices were and in 1499, he was stripped of his title as governor of the land he claimed. Along with his barbaric treatment of the natives, Columbus also contributed to countless native deaths through the introduction of diseases that the Indians’ immune systems were not accustomed to. This leads to the question, did Christopher Columbus do anything worth

Should We Celebrate Columbus Day

Should we celebrate Columbus Day? by-Giana Williams Can we trust the books? History books may only skim the surface of the whole truth. Take Christopher Columbus for example, Hero who founded america...Is this the whole truth? They left out the violence and diseases, and forced conversion to christianity and none the less slavery. With that in mind...do you still want to celebrate a day about him? Most likely not but if so let me show you how and why you might want to change your mind. The history…

Words 367 - Pages 2

Should We Celebrate Columbus Day

is: “What day should we celebrate Columbus Day or Indigenous People’s Day?” I think that we should celebrate Columbus day because: Going back to when Christopher Colombus was alive he was the first person to sail from Europe, to America. One example of this is in the article on NewsEla titled: “PRO/CON: Should we celebrate Christopher Columbus?” “Columbus Was the first person to sail from Europe to America. He reached America in 1492.” This is one of the main reasons that we should keep on celebrating…

Words 256 - Pages 2

Should We Celebrate Columbus Day?

Should We Celebrate Columbus Day? Have you ever thought about the origins of our holidays? Columbus day in particular has recently been thought to be controversial. Maybe the textbook version isn’t the same as the truth. The truth about Columbus provides evidence that the holiday made in his honor should be abolished. Christopher Columbus was not the first to discover the New World, the Native Americans were; he treated those who were there before him unfairly and unjustly. Columbus used violence…

Words 189 - Pages 1

Should We Celebrate Columbus Day

British and gaining our freedom from British rule, Americans have Independence Day. In honor of the soldiers who have sacrificed their lives and continue to risk them in many of America's wars, we have Veterans Day. In honor of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s great contributions to the civil rights movement, we have Martin Luther King Jr. Day. Columbus Day, however, is a peculiar holiday. What positive contribution has Columbus made for our beloved country? What did he do that no one else has done? His…

Words 734 - Pages 3

Why We Should Celebrate Columbus Day

for the glory of God.” once stated Columbus. (Columbus). Columbus Day has been celebrated in the United States since 1937. October 12, 1942 is the day that is celebrated every year because of the landing of Christopher Columbus in the Americas. Columbus is a man worthy of honoring because his discovery lead to the founding of the United States of America which is the worlds greatest nation. Although many say that we should not have a day to celebrate just Columbus, he is an important historical figure…

Words 569 - Pages 3

Why We Should Celebrate Columbus Day

I believe we should most definitely celebrate Columbus Day. This man and his crew were very courageous with their expedition into unknown seas. Some people say Columbus was one of the first to circumnavigate the sea. Columbus set up a colony in the new world he found. Columbus Day has been a Federal holiday since 1937. President Franklin D Roosevelt decided this. This is a long time to celebrate something and then just do away with it I believe. Columbus Day was unofficially celebrated as…

Words 231 - Pages 1

Why Should We Celebrate Columbus Day

Columbus day should not be celebrated as a National Federal Holiday because he did more evil than good when connecting the New World to the Old. He mistreated the “Indians” and was an avarice leader. Christopher Columbus recognized the natives abundance of hospitality and quickly took advantage of it. “When you ask them for something they have, they never say no”, Columbus wrote when discussing the Indians. Another reason as to why Columbus day should not be celebrated as a holiday is the way he…

Words 293 - Pages 2

Essay On Why We Should Not Celebrate Columbus Day

who has, in today’s terms, committed genocide should not be celebrated in the eyes of any reasonable person. Columbus Day, a national holiday, should not be celebrated in the United States (US) for three simple reasons, honesty, morality and exclusion. These three issues are the leading factors on why we should not celebrate Columbus Day. In all honesty, Christopher Columbus did not discover America. Across the US, our children are taught that Columbus discovered our noble land and claimed it for…

Words 774 - Pages 4

Why We Should Celebrate Columbus Day Be Abolished

America has been celebrating Columbus Day, the holiday that honors Christopher Columbus for discovering America. He was a Portuguese explorer, who during his exploration of the New World was sponsored by the queen Isabell of Spain. Because the Columbus’s men killed thousands of Native American, the day has good meaning for some, and bad ones for others. So, many people wonder if America should keep celebrating Columbus Day or not. Even though it was because of Christopher Columbus that America got colonized…

Words 976 - Pages 4

Pros And Cons Of Christopher Columbus

Should Columbus Day be Celebrated or Renamed? The general argument made by Silvio Laccetti in his work, “PRO/CON: Should we celebrate Christopher Columbus?”, is that Christopher Columbus was a great adventurer and explorer and helped create a path for the modern world, and we should celebrate his accomplishments. He writes, “Christopher Columbus also enjoys iconic status in the wider American mind. Parks, playgrounds...” (Paragraph 11). Christopher Columbus is viewed as a very successful man by…

Words 287 - Pages 2