The Great Compromise: The Three Branch Government

Words: 481

Pages: 2

Open Document

The topic that I have chosen to write about for this proposal will be discussing The Great Compromise, how is started and the different issues that were faced during that time and how they have affected us today in government.

Thesis The articles of government back in 1787 were not really working out too well, and the thing that was making it ineffective threatened to challenge any attempts at new government. This was the resulting issue of competing interest between the different states, the states with larger populations versus the smaller ones. So a state with a large population, say Virginia, had different needs that a state with a lesser population like Delaware for example. So that the large states are the ones that really benefit from government …show more content…
The Chief Executive (president, chosen by the legislature), Legislature Bicameral, and the Judicial Branch (court system).
II. The New Jersey Plan
a) Delegates from Delaware, New Jersey, Rhode Island and other small states at the time immediately objected to the given Virginia Plan, feeling cheated out by their larger populations getting the better end of the deal. The smaller states preferred to have something more like the Confederation System, in which all of the states were represented equally.
b) Delegates that were not pleased with the mentioned Virginia Plan stood with a man called William Paterson of New Jersey. On the 15th of June he proposed a different plan that then were to revise the Articles of Confederation.
c) The New Jersey plan kept the idea of the Confederation’s one house legislature, which consists of a vote from each state to be more equal to the states with fewer representatives than and not as high as a population. Yet congress could regulate the trade and set taxes, powers that it did not have under the Articles of Confederation. Congress would then elect a sort of weak executive branch containing more than one

Constitution Vocabulary

Opposed the adoption of the U.S. Constitution b/c it gave too much power to the national government at the expense of the state government and it lacked a bill of rights Sentence: To Antifederalists the proposed Constitution threatened to lead the United States down to political corruption. 3. Articles of Confederation: The compact among the thirteen original states that established the first government of the United States. Sentence: The Articles of Confederation were adopted by the Continental…

Words 1165 - Pages 5

Essay Camila

ways: federalism, separation of powers, checks and balances and the compromise between big and small states in Congress. Federalism guarded against tyranny because it divided the power between the central government and state government. Certain powers are exclusively held by the central government and other powers are held by the state government, and some are shared between the two. James Madison explains, “The central government has the power to regulate trade, conduct foreign relations, prive…

Words 867 - Pages 4

Explain The Three Major Compromises

There were three major compromises reached at the Constitutional Convention. The firsts compromise was, The Great Compromise (Connecticut Compromise), which came from two plans that were brought forth called, The Virginia Plan and The New Jersey Plan. The Virginia plan called for strong national government and three legislative branches. One would be directly elected by the people, the second would be selected from those whom were elected to the first house, and the third the president and national…

Words 554 - Pages 3

Confederation and Constitution copy 2 Essay

became independent from Great Britain, the Congress drafted what would become the first constitution. The Articles of Confederation were drafted in 1777 and was ratified by all 13 states four years later in 1781. During this time American colonists were cautious about a central government, as they had suffered at the hands of the Great Britain government, who abused its powers. For this reason, the Articles of Confederation rejected the idea of a single central government. The Articles of Confederation…

Words 1562 - Pages 7

Us Honors Notes Essay

Freedom- statue stating in part that the human mind was created free and that government control over religious beliefs or worship is tyrannical 3. Articles of Confederation- document that created an association of states while guaranteeing each state its “Sovereignty, freedom, and independence” 4. Daniel Shays- a former Revolutionary War captain, along with other angry farmers, took up arms against the government due to “taxation without representation” 5. James Madison- of Virginia, served…

Words 752 - Pages 4

Constitution Dbq Analysis

Britain, the Founding Fathers needed to create a government for the new nation. They were afraid of a government with too much power, so when they created the Articles of Confederation, our first plan of government, they organized the country around a weak central government along with strong state governments. However, this did not create an effective bureaucracy and the Founding Fathers were driven to meet again to form a new plan of government in 1787. The product of this meeting was the Constitution…

Words 984 - Pages 4

Constitutional Convention Dbq

Although moral among the population may have been high the leaders knew that the Article of Confederation would not and could not sustain as the Governing document for the new nation. The new Nation needed a new document that would allow for a federal government. The new document was the Constitution. From the beginning the Constitution was controversial by many of the states within the colonies. However, everyone knew that for the country to succeed each state would have to find a common ground on which…

Words 597 - Pages 3

What Was The Reason Of Shay's Rebellion

The Constitution: The constitutional convention was held on May 25, 1787 in Philadelphia's Pennsylvania state house. Shay's rebellion was the main reasoning of the convention. Daniel Shay led a 1200 people protested because of high taxes that all of the states were facing. Rhode Island was the only state who didn't send representatives to the convention. The small state didn't want to lose their rights as a state just because they were small. Even though the rebellion was the main reason for the…

Words 358 - Pages 2

What Is The Great Compromise Of 1787

The Great Compromise of 1787 also knows as the Connecticut Compromise was a highly controversial issue due to the conflicting views proposed by the Virgina Plan and the New Jersey Plan. The Virgina plan proposed by Edmund Randolph and James Madison suggested that representation should be based on the population. They wanted three branches of government: legislative, judicial and executive. The legislative branch should have two houses, the House of Representative and the Senate. However, the New…

Words 237 - Pages 1

Pros And Cons Of The Great Compromise

The Great Compromise, which was a reached during the U.S. Constitutional Convention in 1787, was an agreement met by the states to honor each sides needs in the U.S. Congress. There were 2 sides, the party who were in favor of the Virginia Plan and the party who was in favor of the New Jersey Plan. The 2 sides who were in argument were the small and large states. The large states wanted the Virginia Plan because it made representation in the House of Representatives based on population. The Virginia…

Words 508 - Pages 3