Tom Robinson Case

Words: 1770
Pages: 8
Open Document
Imagine being a black man accused of rape when the crime wasn’t committed. Everyone in the courtroom is against him, and nobody believes the truth told. How would the feeling of being proven guilty of a crime not committed affect someone? Tom Robinson was a man accused of raping a white woman, named Mayella, and was declared guilty, even though Mayella made the move on him. Victoria Price and Ruby Bates said that they were raped and attacked by six negro boys, and injustice was served once again. Although the Scottsboro Boys case and the Tom Robinson case are similar in the aspect of blacks being accused of rape by white women, they are different in several ways.
The Scottsboro Boys case was used by Harper Lee as a storyline to write To Kill …show more content…
The attorney for the Negro boys was going to do anything in his power to help these boys be declared innocent. Not all of the boys were in the same train car, and the girls couldn’t even pick them out of a lineup. People knew they were lying, the attorney just had to prove it. This outlook of not surrendering until justice is served was shown in both the actual case and To Kill a Mockingbird. The attorney for the Negro boys was going to fight with all of his being to try to free these boys. Although all the fighting in the world couldn’t change the fact the boys weren’t white, therefore, they had raped these girls. Of course this was in the eyes of the jury and the people, the boys didn’t seem to stand a chance. Due to Atticus thinking that if he doesn’t take the case, he won’t be able to show his face in town: “‘The main one is, if I didn’t I couldn’t hold up my head in town, I couldn’t represent this county in the legislature, I couldn’t even tell you or Jem not to do something again’” (Lee 78). Atticus made himself believe he wouldn’t be much of a figure to his kids if he didn’t take this black man’s case, that people would view him differently, and his kids wouldn’t need to obey him. He feels as if he has to take it to prove Tom Robinson’s innocence. Atticus knows his job is to represent people, and in that everyone deserves equal representation. Just like in the Scottsboro case, Atticus was going to fight for Tom’s freedom because he felt like he had to, or wouldn’t have any respect left. When he first took on the case, Atticus just knew it was the right thing to do. Then he began to get wrapped up in it and made it a must to win this case. When the decision was made by the jury, it hit Atticus hard
Show More

Related Documents: Tom Robinson Case

Scottsboro Boys And Tom Robinson Case Study

1. Trials such as those of the Scottsboro Boys and Tom Robinson have sometimes been referred to as “courtroom lynchings.” What do you think that description means? It doesn't mean physically lynching, but that it's more like a mental thing. Like when the whites are oppressing and discriminating against the blacks with their words and privileges. 2. What roles did race, gender, and class play in whom juries believed and whom they did not believe in Southern courtrooms in the 1930s? Race played…

Words 405 - Pages 2

Case Tom Robinson Trial In To Kill A Mockingbird

MAYCOMB— Yesterday morning, Judge Taylor and an all white jury presided over Tom Robinson’s case of the accused 1934 rape of 19 year old Mayella Ewell. After over two hours of deliberation, the jury concluded the defendant, 25 year old Tom Robinson, guilty of rape. The crime in question took place on November 26th of last year on the Ewell property. Tom Robinson had supposedly raped and beat Mayella after an invitation into her house. Mr. Gilmer of the prosecution called upon three witnesses…

Words 318 - Pages 2

Englishspeechcorrections.Wps Essay

2013 Ms, Bannerman Speech Does being born colored make you a rapist? I am Catalina Grajeda, and I am defending Tom Robinson in this case. The evidence proves Tom Robinson is not guilty of this crime. You, fellow men of God, must acquit him. The case is purely based on the color of his skin. This will be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. The victim in this case is white, my client is black. The men on the jury are not piers of my client and the presumption of guilt outweighs even basic…

Words 1140 - Pages 5

To What Extent Did Tom Robinson Trial In To Kill A Mockingbird

Tom Robinson is innocent in the case of Mayella Ewell’s rape case. Heck Tate and the Ewells agree that Tom Robinson beat and raped Mayella. However, on the other hand Tom Robinson states that he did not beat or rape Mayella. When Heck Tate was called up to testify he stated that he discovered Mayella on the floor with the right side of her face badly beaten with bruises that Tom Robinson had caused. As Atticus asked Tom Robinson to stand up, Scout notices something odd about him. Jem states, “He…

Words 288 - Pages 2

Tom Robinson Should Never Have Come To Trial In To Kill A Mockingbird

convicted by an all-white jury. Just like these nine men Tom Robinson was falsely accused of rape. Despite the hard work of Atticus. Despite Atticus Finch's failure to acquit his client Tom Robinson in To Kill a Mockingbird, his closing statement presents a captivating argument that is both logically and ethically persuasive evidence. Initially, Atticus uses the persuasive device logos to show the jury that the case against Tom Robinson should never have come to trial. In the beginning of the…

Words 348 - Pages 2

What Are The Stereotypes In To Kill A Mockingbird

disadvantage. Although it seems like there is no way out of this accusation, Atticus still finds the courage to stand up for what is right and what he believes in. He finds that Tom isn’t just a black man but an innocent black man and blacks are people just like whites. Atticus Finch defending a black man by the name of Tom Robinson from the accusations of Mayella and Bob Ewell. What people of the jury don’t understand is that people are created equal and just because someone is black doesn’t mean they…

Words 1140 - Pages 5

Atticus The Ewells

like racism, poverty, and domestic violence. Atticus, the Ewell’s, and Tom Robinson. These three people all had one thing in common; they all had a need. It was racism, poverty, and also domestic violence. Atticus was a person who fits this category the best. He has been having some problems with racism. Atticus has been called a nigger lover or people had said that he defends niggers because of the Tom Robinson case. One person that has insulted Atticus in that way was Cecil Jacobs. “He’s…

Words 841 - Pages 4

Equality: A timeless Struggle Essay

most cinematic portion of the book, as is the main focus of the movie of the book produced in 1962. Though the trial targets Tom Robinson, in another sense it is Maycomb that is on trial, because it reveals the injustice and classifying community that do things such as force blacks to sit in a different areas of the courthouse, and while Atticus eventually loses the court case, he successfully reveals this about Maycomb. That is why I chose Atticus’s final argument of the trial as my passage; his closing…

Words 700 - Pages 3

Effects Of Racism In To Kill A Mockingbird

seen in Tom Robinson, the Finch family, and Bob Ewell. Tom Robinson, a black man, is a main character in this novel who faces the biggest effects of racism. The first effect is that Tom is falsely accused of beating Mayella Ewell. In the trial, he faces an unfair trial because of his skin color. During this court case, Tom's identity changes from a hardworking, family man to a careless man that has nothing to live for. Tom decides to take matters into his own hands because of this case, it made…

Words 562 - Pages 3

To Kill a Mockingbird Essay

the test when a black man named Tom Robinson is falsely accused of raping a white woman, and Atticus is chosen to defend him. The verdict is doomed to be guilty due to the fact that their society is deeply rooted in racism and the belief that black people do not deserve a fair trial. Despite knowing the trial would be lost; Atticus holds strong to his morals and defends Tom with all that he can. Atticus’s greatest act of courage was defending Tom Robinson in a case he knew could not be won, and genuinely…

Words 1127 - Pages 5