Essay about France and U.S Health Care

Submitted By kalajones
Words: 2196
Pages: 9
Open Document
http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/03/france-and-us-health-care-twins-separated-at-birth/254033/

The Atlantic

France and U.S. Health Care: Twins Separated at Birth?
Megan McArdle Mar 6 2012, 11:10 AM ET
Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry

By way of introduction, I want to make clear that I have no particular expertise when it comes to healthcare policy. My knowledge is merely that of a layman who follows the news. I'm even well-aware that one of my esteemed co-guest bloggers is Avik Roy, who's one of the most talented health care wonks on the internet, whose work I avidly followed at his previous National Review digs. In fact, this post can be read as an invitation to Avik to enlighten me.

All that being said, from my outlook there's something that I haven't seen discussed and yet seems striking to me: how similar the French and U.S. healthcare systems are.

On its face, this seems like a preposterous notion: whenever the two are mentioned together, it's to say that they're polar opposites.

France has been called the best healthcare system in the world by the World Health Organization. And if there's something everyone in the US seems to agree on, it's that US healthcare, well, horribly sucks, although they strongly disagree about why and what to do about it.

And yet, to me, the similarities are glaring:

First of all, the French healthcare system is built on a large, highly-regulated private sector. Unlike Britain's NHS, the government doesn't own everything. Some hospitals are public, but many are private and for-profit. Indeed, there are publicly-traded hospital chains, just like in the US. Most doctors and nurses work in private practice. Even most of the ambulances are private. The sector is highly regulated and subsidized to be sure, but that's also true in the US.

Secondly, there's a crucial feature at the heart of the French healthcare system that is also at the heart of the US healthcare system--and that all US wonks hate: employer-provided insurance.

France has had a US-style employer-based healthcare system since the end of World War II, but the Couverture Maladie Universelle (literally: universal healthcare coverage), the government program that covers people who can't get insurance, was only enacted in the late 90s (ah, global macro booms). Given how tantalizingly close Bill Clinton was to passing universal healthcare in the early 90s, it's easy to imagine a parallel universe where Americans had universal healthcare before the French, again something you wouldn't guess from reading stories on French healthcare.

The way healthcare works in France, basically, as I understand it from living here (and I may be wrong about this because it gives me migraines), is that you get insurance through your employer which they deduct from their taxes. You can also buy it on the market (and don't deduct it from your taxes). If you can't get insurance, the government will pay for your treatment in a system similar to (I think?) Medicaid, ie you go to the doctor or the hospital you want, and the government will pay for it in a stingy way that incentivizes you to not want to rely on the government too much but still ensures no one is left to die on the streets. French doctors frequently grumble about CMU reimbursement rates as American ones do Medicaid/Medicare rates. Conversely, if you have a job with coverage, you can buy additional coverage and/or services out of pocket.

Some jobs have better healthcare than others: my wife works for a big management consulting firm and has very generous healthcare coverage; as her husband, I get coverage through her policy, since as a freelancer my options are mediocre.

When we had our baby, my wife and I sprung for a private clinic. We chose this clinic because it is a religious institution that provided religious services on top of medical ones, which was important to us, and only later discovered that it's one of the best clinics in Paris and
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about France and U.S Health Care

Health Care Policy In The United States And France

2012 Health Care Policy in the United States and France: Common Ideals, Diverging Approach Health care policy is one of the foremost issues of controversy in most modern societies across the globe today. The debate centers on the government’s role in providing health services to its citizens. No two countries in the world have a system in which their governments play the exact same part in regulating health care, portraying the vast number of opinions and views on the issue. France and the…

Words 2912 - Pages 12

Universal Healthcare In The US Essay

in the U.S. outline Jason Mitchell Introduction: I. 1. Everyone would agree that a good healthcare system, contributes to an overall healthy individual. While the U.S. is considered a world leader in numerous categories, that they are judged in; however, the U.S. healthcare system remains probably one of the worst in the world. Just image what your life would be like if you were one of the millions of Americans without medical coverage. Over 50 million Americans are currently without health coverage…

Words 1066 - Pages 5

Essay on Egypt Healthcare

United States Healthcare vs France Healthcare Americans spent 17.9% of their gross domestic product on health in 2010 while France spent 11.9% of it on the same year on health (according to the World Health Organization). The lower level in French spending demonstrates a better efficiency of the system. There is no unique public insurance organization like in France. According to Reinhardt, only 10% of the French population has a private health insurance. French health-care system are universal multi-payer…

Words 552 - Pages 3

COMPARISON OF U.S. AND OTHER HEALTH SYSTEM Essay

Health Statistics and Costs: Comparison between U.S. and France An outline of rising life expectancy has been observed in many high-income countries around the world, and United States and France are not the exception. According to the WHO the total population of the United States in 2012 was three hundred eighteen million habitants. In the same year the average life expectancy at birth was seventy-six years for men and eighty-two years for women (WHO, 2012). Similarly, in France from a total population…

Words 840 - Pages 4

Strengths of the Us Healthcare System Essay

US Health Care Systems Strengths Tiara McDaniel American Intercontinental University HCM630-1205D-01 January 27, 2013 Introduction There is an opinion amid several Americans that regardless of coverage, price and other difficulties in the health care system, the eminence of health care in the United States is more superior than it is anyplace else in the world and there is a possibility that it may be threatened by restructuring of health care by President Obama. In addition to that, an article…

Words 1374 - Pages 6

Essay Healthy Americans

Bingo, “46.3 million people in the U.S. are uninsured,” according to the 2008 U.S. Census Bureau. In the past month, I have taken my grandma back and forth to the hospital and to the pharmacy. She had slight bronchitis and was prescribed with medicine. She was shocked to hear that one of her medicines would have costed $310, but she only had to pay $3.10 because she had health insurance. She had complained to me about the prices of medicine and the trips she had to the pharmacies when I had to remind…

Words 879 - Pages 4

Health Care in the United States Essay

role in the world. On the world stage, the U.S. often challenges other countries about their records regarding human rights. Yet the United States is failing its own citizens by not granting every citizen access to basic health care. Many citizens in the United States needlessly suffer and die each day due to the inequities of the health care system in the U.S. This is a horrible national catastrophe! The United States needs to provide universal health care to all of its citizens and legal residents…

Words 2426 - Pages 10

Telemedicine Affecting The Healthcare Industry

than wages in recent years. Lubotsky & Olson (2015) report policy-makers, employers, and individuals are concerned that the growth in health care costs have continued to exceed the growth of per capita incomes, wages, and the price of other goods for several decades. In 1960, the annual per capita health spending was $809 and by 2009 the annual per capita health spending had increased to $7375, an annual growth rate of 4.6 percent (Lubotsky & Olson, 2015). Annual premiums reached…

Words 953 - Pages 4

Obamacare Argumentative Analysis

Affordable Care Act in 2010 in order to reduce the overall costs of health care, expand coverage to many more Americans, and ultimately make health care more affordable. Although Obamacare has been successful in insuring tens of millions more Americans and not denying services to those with pre-existing conditions,…

Words 1692 - Pages 7

The Best Healthcare System In The United States

their illnesses worsen (www.newyorktimes.com, 2007). The large gap in access to adequate healthcare has affected the quality of life, life expectancy and quality of care across the United States. The United States healthcare system is the only developed nation that does not offer universal coverage for its citizens. England, France, Germany and many other developed nations offer their citizen’s universal coverage through tax financed systems. In comparison to the United Kingdom healthcare system…

Words 1416 - Pages 6